Re: [External] : Re: Lisp files that load cl-lib in problematical ways

[Emanuel Berg <incal@dataswamp.org>]

Richard Stallman wrote:

>> Here is the top 100 list.
>>
>> A few hits don't make sense since the command is imperfect,
>> but other than that the list should be a pretty good
>> reflection of the situation.
>
> Would someoe like to filter that list to remove everything
> not defined in cl-lib.el itself?

One can do this in zsh by means of an extended glob pattern.

We see that `cl-pushnew' is on position #15, used 169 times.
So it is popular, but perhaps less so than expected?

`cl-loop' (#2, 979 times) and `cl-incf' (#3, 715 times) are as
expected very popular.

And there are more stuff that has been mentioned that appears
on the top 10 part of the list.

It is the list processing langauge :P

#! /bin/zsh
#
# this file:
#   https://dataswamp.org/~incal/conf/.zsh/emacs

setopt extendedglob

cle () {
    cd ~/src/emacs
    grep -E -h -o 'cl-[-a-z]+' **/*.el~lisp/emacs-lisp/cl-lib.el |
        sort          |
        uniq -c       |
        sort -r -b -n |
        head -n 100
}

$ cle
   1416 cl-defmethod
    979 cl-loop
    715 cl-incf
    611 cl-lib
    486 cl-assert
    309 cl-letf
    301 cl-seq
    279 cl-defstruct
    257 cl-defgeneric
    227 cl-case
    209 cl-end
    208 cl-list
    189 cl-call-next-method
    172 cl-start
    169 cl-pushnew
    149 cl-defun
    142 cl-p
    142 cl-decf
    135 cl-flet
    132 cl-return
    130 cl-keys
    125 cl--loop-args
    114 cl--generic-
    106 cl-block
    103 cl-destructuring-bind
    101 cl-macs
     99 cl-check-type
     95 cl-some
     89 cl-kwds
     88 cl-typep
     76 cl-prin
     72 cl-getf
     67 cl-pred
     67 cl--find-class
     66 cl-remove-if-not
     66 cl-defmacro
     66 cl-callf
     65 cl-labels
     65 cl-extra
     63 cl-x
     62 cl-second
     62 cl-return-from
     62 cl-mode
     62 cl-count
     61 cl-or-cast
     60 cl-set-difference
     53 cl-remove-if
     53 cl-generic
     51 cl-ecase
     50 cl-plusp
     50 cl-first
     50 cl-cvs
     49 cl-position
     47 cl-program
     47 cl-mapcan
     47 cl-every
     46 cl-third
     46 cl-res
     45 cl-tempo-comma
     45 cl-substitute
     44 cl-current-ic
     43 cl-subseq
     42 cl-key
     41 cl-item
     39 cl-tempo-right-paren
     39 cl-tempo-left-paren
     39 cl-function
     39 cl-dolist
     38 cl-print-object
     38 cl-mapcar
     37 cl-tempo-tags
     37 cl--slot-descriptor-name
     37 cl-macrolet
     37 cl-do
     36 cl-progv
     36 cl-find-if
     35 cl-f
     35 cl-embed-code
     34 cl-tree
     34 cl-func
     33 cl-gensym
     33 cl-evenp
     33 cl-defsubst
     33 cl-check-register
     32 cl-rest
     32 cl-print
     32 cl-pos
     32 cl-get-next-code
     30 cl-remove-duplicates
     30 cl--loop-body
     30 cl-block-end-regexp
     30 cl-block-begin-regexp
     30 cl-basic-offset
     29 cl-remove
     29 cl-i
     28 cl-union
     28 cl-member
     28 cl-adjoin
     27 cl-new
     27 cl-mismatch

-- 
underground experts united
https://dataswamp.org/~incal