bug#62892: proposal to extend mark-sexp to go forward and backward on command

[Zachary Kanfer <zkanfer@gmail.com>]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 3600 bytes --]

> Is it an "internal" function?  Then its name should
> maybe use `--'.  (But why should it be internal?)

Hrm, I figured it would be an internal function because it's intended to be
wrapped by other code. But this describes a whole lot of functions. So it
can't be that.

I suppose that if there are other types of things that are created that one
might want to mark, then a user could use this method to mark them. So
perhaps it shouldn't be internal -- it really could be used by other code.

> Is it a helper function?  Then its name should maybe
> use a suffix that indicates that, such as `-helper'
> or `-1' (old-school Lisp, I suppose).

It's certainly a helper function -- it's intended to be called by a bunch
of different functions we write.

> `mark-thing' should be reserved for a function that
> takes a THING name as arg: `sexp', `page', etc.,
> instead of a movement function such as `forward-sexp'.

This makes a lot of sense to me.

On Fri, Apr 28, 2023 at 3:28 PM Drew Adams <drew.adams@oracle.com> wrote:

> > > +(defun mark--helper (move-fn number-of-things)
> >
> > A nicer name would be 'mark-thing' as a reference to thingatpt.el.
>
> FWIW, I have a different take on this.
>
> Is it an "internal" function?  Then its name should
> maybe use `--'.  (But why should it be internal?)
>
> Is it a helper function?  Then its name should maybe
> use a suffix that indicates that, such as `-helper'
> or `-1' (old-school Lisp, I suppose).
>
> `mark-thing' should be reserved for a function that
> takes a THING name as arg: `sexp', `page', etc.,
> instead of a movement function such as `forward-sexp'.
> ___
>
> FWIW, I think MOVE-FN is a fine name for the argument.
> My own preference, and what I use in my code, is the
> name FORWARD-THING-FUNCTION.
> ___
>
> FWIW, in my library isearch+.el), I use the arg name
> THING for a thing name, not a movement or other
> function.
>
> E.g.: Function `isearchp-in-thing-p' is a helper
> function for defining specific THING-type predicates,
> such as `isearch(-not)-in-email-address-p'.
> ___
>
> FWIW, my library `thing-cmds.el' has a command named
> `mark-things', which prompts for a THING type as arg:
>
>  mark-things is an alias for 'select-things' in 'thing-cmds.el'.
>
>  (mark-things THING &optional ARG ALLOW-EXTEND)
>
>  Set point at one end of THING and set mark ARG THINGs from point.
>  THING is a symbol that names a type of thing.  Interactively, you are
>  prompted for it.  Completion is available (lax).
>
>  (If THING doesn't have an associated `forward-'THING operation then
>  do nothing.)
>
>  Put mark at the same place command `forward-'THING would move point
>  with the same prefix argument.
>
>  Put point at the beginning of THING, unless the prefix argument (ARG)
>  is negative, in which case put it at the end of THING.
>
>  If `select-things' is repeated or if the mark is active (in Transient
>  Mark mode), then it marks the next ARG THINGs, after the ones already
>  marked.  In this case the type of THING used is whatever was used the
>  last time `select-things' was called - you are not prompted for it.
>
>  This region extension reusing the last type of THING happens even if
>  the active region is empty.  This means that you can, for instance,
>  just use `C-SPC' to activate an empty region and then use
>  `select-things' to select more THINGS of the last kind selected.
>
>  If there is no THING at point, and `thgcmd-use-nearest-thing-flag' is
>  non-nil, then select a THING near point.
>
>

[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 4530 bytes --]