bug? notmuch earch doesn't search threads

bug? notmuch earch doesn't search threads

[Jason Woofenden]

I added tag:me to all messages from me.

Then I added this to my index page:

tag:notmuch and tag:unread and tag:me

So my attention could be drawn to threads I'd participated in,
which had new messages. (This list has enough traffic that I won't
always keep up).

It didn't work though. I assume because no single message has all
those tags. (The ones with tag:me lack tag:unread and maybe
tag:notmuch.)

If this is not a bug, and you want it to only find messages that
match, and not threads that match, then I make this feature
request:

I want a way to do the above: to search for threads that have the
tags I'm looking for (but not necessarily all in the same message
within the thread.)

The vim ui is exclusively thread-based, and the notmuch manpage
says it's thread-based... I want thread-based searching! :)

Thanks,    - Jason

P.S. I submitted (my first) 6 patches to this list on Monday, and
have not gotten a reply or seen them merged. Is there something
more I should do, or should I just be patient?

Re: bug? notmuch earch doesn't search threads

[Pieter Praet]

On Sat, 16 Jul 2011 08:37:52 -0400, Jason Woofenden <jason@jasonwoof.com> wrote:
> I added tag:me to all messages from me.
> 
> Then I added this to my index page:
> 
> tag:notmuch and tag:unread and tag:me
> 
> So my attention could be drawn to threads I'd participated in,
> which had new messages. (This list has enough traffic that I won't
> always keep up).
> 
> It didn't work though. I assume because no single message has all
> those tags. (The ones with tag:me lack tag:unread and maybe
> tag:notmuch.)
> 
> If this is not a bug, and you want it to only find messages that
> match, and not threads that match, then I make this feature
> request:
> 
> I want a way to do the above: to search for threads that have the
> tags I'm looking for (but not necessarily all in the same message
> within the thread.)

That is indeed expected behaviour.

Filters can help you out though. Bind this to a key:

#+BEGIN_SRC emacs-lisp
  (lambda()
    (notmuch-search "tag:notmuch AND tag:unread")
    (notmuch-search-filter "tag:me"))
#+END_SRC

> The vim ui is exclusively thread-based, and the notmuch manpage
> says it's thread-based... I want thread-based searching! :)
> 
> Thanks,    - Jason
> 
> P.S. I submitted (my first) 6 patches to this list on Monday, and
> have not gotten a reply or seen them merged. Is there something
> more I should do, or should I just be patient?

The Notmuch project is in the unique position of being the product of
Carl's (legimitate) dislike of email (see his talk @ LCA2011 [1]), so
it's safe to say patches may take some time to pass the gatekeeper.
Don't worry, your patience will be rewarded.

> _______________________________________________
> notmuch mailing list
> notmuch@notmuchmail.org
> http://notmuchmail.org/mailman/listinfo/notmuch


Peace

-- 
Pieter

[1] http://blip.tv/linuxconfau/notmuch-what-email-should-be-4745130

Re: bug? notmuch earch doesn't search threads

[Pieter Praet]

On Sat, 16 Jul 2011 16:26:04 +0200, Pieter Praet <pieter@praet.org> wrote:
> [SNIP]
> The Notmuch project is in the unique position of being the product of
> Carl's (legimitate) dislike of email (see his talk @ LCA2011 [1]), so
> it's safe to say patches may take some time to pass the gatekeeper.
> Don't worry, your patience will be rewarded.

s/legimitate/legitimate :)


-- 
Pieter