Hi,

Ludovic schrieb am Dienstag der 08. Februar 2022 um 23:59 +01:

> Hi!
>
> Xinglu Chen <public@yoctocell.xyz> skribis:
>
>> This patchset adds a new updater, which scans Repology[1] for updates.
>> It should technically support all packages in Guix!  :-)
>
> I wouldn’t want to spoil the party, but I’m mildly enthusiastic.
>
> Repology implements the same functionality as our updaters, so
> repology.org is effectively “service as a software substitute”
> (SaaSS).

Right, but it tracks a lot more repositories than what our updaters do,
so why not take advantage of that.

> My preference would be to keep our existing updaters rather than
> effectively ditch them and delegate the work to Repology.  It’s tempting
> to think we can have both, but I’m not sure this would last long.

The point of the Repology updater is to act as a fallback if none of
the other updaters can update a package, e.g., ‘maven-dependency-tree’.
I already mentioned that language-specific updaters usually provide more
accurate and detailed information, so they should be used when possible;
we aren’t losing anything here.