bug#28261: freeimage uses bundled libraries

bug#28261: freeimage uses bundled libraries

[Efraim Flashner]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 711 bytes --]

The bundled libraries in freeimage are several years old, leading to
build errors of packages that depend on freeimage, such as ogre¹, on
architectures with neon. Debian has an extensive patch collection to use
system libraries which should fix this issue on armhf and aarch64 but I
haven't tried it yet.

¹ https://hydra.gnu.org/build/2220108/log/raw
/gnu/store/p9nzzckb44gbz3v2anzrx7vw10in7j7l-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `png_init_filter_functions_neon'
-- 
Efraim Flashner   <efraim@flashner.co.il>   אפרים פלשנר
GPG key = A28B F40C 3E55 1372 662D  14F7 41AA E7DC CA3D 8351
Confidentiality cannot be guaranteed on emails sent or received unencrypted

[-- Attachment #2: signature.asc --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 833 bytes --]

bug#28261: patch pushed

[Efraim Flashner]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 327 bytes --]

This is fixed in commits a5d4c96b8d90b8bb87e07bd6a7be78991db91bc9 and
1606da6c07b7b35481fb410d0a679c9452f6a319.

-- 
Efraim Flashner   <efraim@flashner.co.il>   אפרים פלשנר
GPG key = A28B F40C 3E55 1372 662D  14F7 41AA E7DC CA3D 8351
Confidentiality cannot be guaranteed on emails sent or received unencrypted

[-- Attachment #2: signature.asc --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 833 bytes --]

bug#28261: libfreeimage has undefined references

[Ludovic Courtès]

Hello Efraim,

It seems that commit a5d4c96b8d90b8bb87e07bd6a7be78991db91bc9 left
libfreeimage with some undefined references.  For instance, the
‘configure’ script of ‘guile-sly’ fails like this:

--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
configure:3888: checking for FreeImage_GetVersion in -lfreeimage
configure:3913: gcc -o conftest -g -O2   conftest.c -lfreeimage   >&5
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PixelFormatLookup'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppRGB555'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppGray'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat24bppRGB'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFormatConverter_Release'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat8bppGray'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageDecode_Create_WMP'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKAllocAligned'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_Create_WMP'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat24bppBGR'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormatDontCare'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat96bppRGBFloat'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetGPSInfoMetadata_WMP'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFormatConverter_EnumConversions'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat48bppRGB'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFreeAligned'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormatBlackWhite'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppBGRA'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppRGB'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat64bppRGBA'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKCodecFactory_CreateFormatConverter'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetEXIFMetadata_WMP'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetXMPMetadata_WMP'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat128bppRGBAFloat'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppGrayFloat'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetIPTCNAAMetadata_WMP'
/gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppRGB565'
collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
configure:3913: $? = 1
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

Any ideas?

Thanks,
Ludo’.

bug#28261: libfreeimage has undefined references

[Efraim Flashner]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 5183 bytes --]

On Thu, Apr 19, 2018 at 12:14:32AM +0200, Ludovic Courtès wrote:
> Hello Efraim,
> 
> It seems that commit a5d4c96b8d90b8bb87e07bd6a7be78991db91bc9 left
> libfreeimage with some undefined references.  For instance, the
> ‘configure’ script of ‘guile-sly’ fails like this:
> 
> --8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
> configure:3888: checking for FreeImage_GetVersion in -lfreeimage
> configure:3913: gcc -o conftest -g -O2   conftest.c -lfreeimage   >&5
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PixelFormatLookup'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppRGB555'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppGray'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat24bppRGB'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFormatConverter_Release'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat8bppGray'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageDecode_Create_WMP'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKAllocAligned'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_Create_WMP'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat24bppBGR'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormatDontCare'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat96bppRGBFloat'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetGPSInfoMetadata_WMP'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFormatConverter_EnumConversions'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat48bppRGB'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFreeAligned'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormatBlackWhite'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppBGRA'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppRGB'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat64bppRGBA'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKCodecFactory_CreateFormatConverter'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetEXIFMetadata_WMP'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetXMPMetadata_WMP'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat128bppRGBAFloat'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppGrayFloat'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetIPTCNAAMetadata_WMP'
> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppRGB565'
> collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
> configure:3913: $? = 1
> --8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---
> 
> Any ideas?
> 
> Thanks,
> Ludo’.

Interestingly guile-sly on aarch64 doesn't find freeimage at all. In any
case, the same issue happens with emulation-station, and from this
not-related-at-all bug
https://github.com/openframeworks/openFrameworks/issues/4993 it looks
like they're all related to libjxr. `guix gc --references $(guix build
--no-grafts freeimage)' doesn't list libjxr, and adding it as a
propagated input doesn't magically fix it. libjxr seems to be abandoned
upstream. The easiest option might be to use the bundled libjxr but I'm
still looking at it.

-- 
Efraim Flashner   <efraim@flashner.co.il>   אפרים פלשנר
GPG key = A28B F40C 3E55 1372 662D  14F7 41AA E7DC CA3D 8351
Confidentiality cannot be guaranteed on emails sent or received unencrypted

[-- Attachment #2: signature.asc --]
[-- Type: application/pgp-signature, Size: 833 bytes --]

bug#28261: libfreeimage has undefined references

[Ludovic Courtès]

Efraim Flashner <efraim@flashner.co.il> skribis:

> On Thu, Apr 19, 2018 at 12:14:32AM +0200, Ludovic Courtès wrote:
>> Hello Efraim,
>> 
>> It seems that commit a5d4c96b8d90b8bb87e07bd6a7be78991db91bc9 left
>> libfreeimage with some undefined references.  For instance, the
>> ‘configure’ script of ‘guile-sly’ fails like this:
>> 
>> --8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
>> configure:3888: checking for FreeImage_GetVersion in -lfreeimage
>> configure:3913: gcc -o conftest -g -O2   conftest.c -lfreeimage   >&5
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PixelFormatLookup'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppRGB555'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppGray'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat24bppRGB'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFormatConverter_Release'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat8bppGray'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageDecode_Create_WMP'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKAllocAligned'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_Create_WMP'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat24bppBGR'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormatDontCare'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat96bppRGBFloat'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetGPSInfoMetadata_WMP'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFormatConverter_EnumConversions'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat48bppRGB'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKFreeAligned'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormatBlackWhite'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppBGRA'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppRGB'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat64bppRGBA'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKCodecFactory_CreateFormatConverter'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetEXIFMetadata_WMP'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetXMPMetadata_WMP'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat128bppRGBAFloat'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat32bppGrayFloat'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `PKImageEncode_SetIPTCNAAMetadata_WMP'
>> /gnu/store/lsbwqzbl17xvbp4clv2mlxmly2xkz219-freeimage-3.17.0/lib/libfreeimage.so: undefined reference to `GUID_PKPixelFormat16bppRGB565'
>> collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
>> configure:3913: $? = 1
>> --8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---
>> 
>> Any ideas?
>> 
>> Thanks,
>> Ludo’.
>
> Interestingly guile-sly on aarch64 doesn't find freeimage at all.

Yes, same on other platforms.  The snippet above are the details that
guile-sly’s ‘config.log’ provides.

Thanks for looking into it!

Ludo’.