El 21/06/24 a las 14:15, MSavoritias escribió: > On Fri, 21 Jun 2024 13:45:04 +0000 > Luis Felipe wrote: > >> El 21/06/24 a las 10:44, MSavoritias escribió: >>> On Fri, 21 Jun 2024 11:46:56 +0200 >>> Andreas Enge wrote: >>> >>>> Am Fri, Jun 21, 2024 at 11:14:18AM +0300 schrieb MSavoritias: >>>>> Aside from that even Guix uploading all code from the packages to >>>>> SWH that basically feeds it to a LLM model is indeed not honoring consent of the author of the package. >>>> Guix does not upload code to SWH. It gives them a pointer to a public git >>>> repository that SWH then harvests or not according to their rules (see my >>>> reply to Dale yesterday). These are not the same things at all. >>> This is bikeshedding and arguing on schemantics. Guix gives them a url to download the source code from, so ultimately we (the Guix project) is responsible for the code showing up in there. >>> Lets not argue over schemantics like this. It is even posted on their website in case you want to argue otherwise https://www.softwareheritage.org/2019/04/18/software-heritage-and-gnu-guix-join-forces-to-enable-long-term-reproducibility/ >> I think the differentiation between sending code and sending a URL is >> necessary. Saying that Guix sends your code or your source files to SWH >> leads people to think that Guix *will* transmit those files from your >> local machine over the Internet to SWH machines when you run "guix lint >> YOUR_PRIVATE_PACKAGE". And that's not the case, is it? > But I didnt say that tho did I? the context you are reading as from the quote is Guix uploading all code from its packages to SWH. > Not any private repos. So i have no idea what you are reffering to here tbh. No, you didn't. What I'm trying to say is that I don't think specifying what Guix sends/uploads to SWH is "bikeshedding". For example, when you say "Guix uploading all code from its packages to SWH", it's ambiguous to me. I don't understand whether you are referring to the package definitions or to the source files those packages refer to. And, if I understand correctly, Guix doesn't upload any of these to SWH.