From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 From: Moonchild Subject: Re: Licensing question about Pale Moon Browser binary distribution Date: Sun, 4 Feb 2018 15:32:57 +0100 Message-ID: <5A771999.1050509@palemoon.org> References: <878tc96k6t.fsf@abyayala.i-did-not-set--mail-host-address--so-tickle-me> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/signed; micalg=pgp-sha256; protocol="application/pgp-signature"; boundary="O0gCcJ4USUavWwk4qI3A8VnCmQiMD58S8" Return-path: Received: from eggs.gnu.org ([2001:4830:134:3::10]:54964) by lists.gnu.org with esmtp (Exim 4.71) (envelope-from ) id 1eiLgn-0001yu-62 for guix-devel@gnu.org; Sun, 04 Feb 2018 09:54:42 -0500 Received: from Debian-exim by eggs.gnu.org with spam-scanned (Exim 4.71) (envelope-from ) id 1eiLgj-0006rC-Um for guix-devel@gnu.org; Sun, 04 Feb 2018 09:54:41 -0500 Received: from vmx.palemoon.org ([80.255.0.163]:63677) by eggs.gnu.org with esmtps (TLS1.0:RSA_AES_256_CBC_SHA1:32) (Exim 4.71) (envelope-from ) id 1eiLgj-0006oe-Ex for guix-devel@gnu.org; Sun, 04 Feb 2018 09:54:37 -0500 Received: from [192.168.0.53] by vmx.palemoon.org (Cipher TLSv1:-SHA:256) (MDaemon PRO v13.0.5) with ESMTP id md50000145814.msg for ; Sun, 04 Feb 2018 14:33:11 +0000 In-Reply-To: <878tc96k6t.fsf@abyayala.i-did-not-set--mail-host-address--so-tickle-me> List-Id: "Development of GNU Guix and the GNU System distribution." List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , Errors-To: guix-devel-bounces+gcggd-guix-devel=m.gmane.org@gnu.org Sender: "Guix-devel" To: ng0@n0.is Cc: guix-devel@gnu.org This is an OpenPGP/MIME signed message (RFC 4880 and 3156) --O0gCcJ4USUavWwk4qI3A8VnCmQiMD58S8 Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="rICHnpSXH3wHK03tO4NC2RXxfP6mMf5tR"; protected-headers="v1" From: Moonchild To: ng0@n0.is Cc: guix-devel@gnu.org Message-ID: <5A771999.1050509@palemoon.org> Subject: Re: Licensing question about Pale Moon Browser binary distribution References: <878tc96k6t.fsf@abyayala.i-did-not-set--mail-host-address--so-tickle-me> In-Reply-To: <878tc96k6t.fsf@abyayala.i-did-not-set--mail-host-address--so-tickle-me> --rICHnpSXH3wHK03tO4NC2RXxfP6mMf5tR Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------080806020400020405070608" --------------080806020400020405070608 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Hi! You've read the exception point correctly: Using New Moon (=3Dunofficial) branding, you are allowed to do whatever you wish with your distribution, including reconfiguration, different home page, etc. Go right ahead! If you make source code changes, you should also supply your modified source code to stay within the requirements of the MPL source code licens= e. Moonchild. On 04/02/2018 12:58, ng0@n0.is wrote: >>From re-reading item 12: >=20 >> Unofficial branding ("New Moon") as supplied in the source code >> may be used for unendorsed binaries at all times. Thusly >> branded binaries with the New Moon logo and product name are >> not subject to the endorsement and exception rules as set out >> in previous points of this license and may be freely >> distributed in altered or unaltered form, subject to the >> Mozilla Public License as regards source code changes and >> availability. This permission does, however, not include any >> rights or license to the Pale Moon name and logo that may still >> be present in the resulting unofficially branded binaries. >=20 > in the above mentioned policy I understand that we will be > allowed to distribute the resulting binaries. Is my understanding > of your policy exception correct or did I miss anything? >=20 > Regards, > ng0 >=20 --------------080806020400020405070608 Content-Type: application/pgp-keys; name="0x6DA5F2AC.asc" Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="0x6DA5F2AC.asc" -----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- Version: GnuPG v2 mQSuBFTGYJQRDADsA69INmywGQW0uwA8ty5UVaVBBHBsFYSw8oYCRcBZj5w/jj2K y8+3EFZ17AntQ7cXI4amHd6tu7IZw+Fmrw6lQ1pA3dLry2k9b7bdhFIjoI3qBlev GvNX4Kye37tfdIv9v/LmtnqsNEG1Q+DVk/xdruv8xIFmn0YTR5AeKZoobTB7xdej OTvZAsGW63MYSbXNbcXKlPfEDenHlg84KONYp9ozRBqMTQ6566TcIMtzHaWUYJps QD5Cz4oINF5y5ZmuqvNUuaTZnX/LLSR22bQ4ca5OttWK0vcYWa4mPv3THSi5m6Xl bSvpHv9aCFvvepouRyfdhTTeCFbO6m6E+z1xTJIpDZ4m5gFmJeDHewL2K1CxHFoj Hb0EPvf2lNXl89ZpH+Z8+Ze96cbaQ8/dtvko8iBVF6hq+JKAR96T9PapOZf7de5J W2IjgDwdFqiBm4ELgxrMXAWfsYYTHtL5PLgOq0BLFs+7hSJFiYMbEdzqNSqbiMC8 obC6OUR9wwmo2hMBALfIbJt6DJIgg0DPg2LVNHGSKIDmul7insggDEIWZZXhC/9i MhNjHAkhwKhOrI5NOJGf8sQmMymR+Iy1jfrl11e8C0PN6hr6ur5xWferConVxkyC pmzVgUgLPMYeBaZGmtRHXRZP5sQ/xSh04oZ9fGG4bdHI+GWPqeKNnOAukhBK0qIY JL5HnbfUMT13bnpfiszijc4D2WebnRZa57uBPTZvC+AYEH+gZM4mqH4F0QVMWchU LdwdPwgXW9oUn69gya7Js/CieqtMxkBX5mXC1JIJTw1ufZaTXT9XIPoKPtJRnYfl U16rO8ot8u2o5f/HnuzyIfoXAoONApmKT5qccJDUSiwjS9NjY8iY5/uXhdpzPUZk PSEPWEwrNKHgTicBL9ZF2OmB7Aol1zKuWpZ/OBdZYGdTJKzsrjar55HhSXhoikKT o0YPIFoo4lXo/1hcnP8XIo0/cZwcso2bv7tlwPpEVQiPT2qk58yKhNmZczkI4HXz G8oq1YdhJQj4tTeNfFoFz5eISSUAGi1wwK0LpPOzbd3EuEX3kQeMpQNxxb0O1CoM AMxF//DGDZq4nvNcmLeWBZU+CtKitJZvbdgADGPVN7kop5mOYbCyzye5kt/iE1g3 xM+nC3ox6LGGQylcSfWXh+a9E0Vb8paV90TS55By5TpNVonEfJLz6BmuBOpGY7KD WfeSN7oUN1mMbPfR3QtcYbOuhE1uaaPxEWDkIYIhTer2G6C3U1QZE9LXAjtdCJM7 1QtKrzc5joco7WShad9KPafiulTAMz4MbLJkfa3sH74BmoM1mllowX+e9c0AEbr0 AQrkyflCVLBV6wahQF812yherJavlIREcDgSb9hwjVZY/KS+SM9t5rBRlC9DA2RT npQSpCSsof9qcKYaWZKU39DMmdeoZcMPpB0xNuo+hh4arcmKAQgpESotMlYQKto+ 7+eDQRRBsKiAzgGrVkPYb9Y+gz3FqQKYZh3QoiWgnGMN9PVbJMYslo7fSyh88+/y LnsugAK+NOnzYPUgfQ1PUVd0IT//xrRdCRMl9SVMRXm3DnHhRNhIEvDC0Ru6F1+P a7Q3TW9vbmNoaWxkIChFLW1haWwgc2lnbmluZyBrZXkpIDxtb29uY2hpbGRAcGFs ZW1vb24ub3JnPoh6BBMRCAAiBQJUxmCUAhsjBgsJCAcDAgYVCAIJCgsEFgIDAQIe AQIXgAAKCRASC7DTbaXyrKxwAP4qn3Ipoyi7QwNgmqogl4SQ4rOSl+Gwjof/Y73/ OSFpigD/TDSDM6kI1zzQH8+91tZIsIi/nD6JY5RcCJX3WOk5PjyJARwEEwECAAYF AlTGYaYACgkQrGoOVatt3bpeXwf/SurKUYrFbUrgAtor8zCUsstTflYypvDwOt1s HCQl0LDiomlqDyytlPFO8U+D9g2f3EjFOeXQtxV3ZNMA1/nzPmGBryWlVdoZqm7I +ZA4HzDjrdxCQ/NEzOWBz3B1yHfK3gezMqPgq3AM4pcmT/JWhqc/1iVFS2fxCMb2 IZoT5vKW15jCNaeJl5w1BbBZ2+Pbu1ybzGWS5pXzoO0UvS5FcEnA8uqnc0ZLhQAX edbMUA2je0PcX4S7WZayievhMy21Lgt4EaDUU6F5e0zG0O51bF7GzgH45mMG6zWi So46kbTCkSjdvIisJBjIG8e0Bzug8/jHwX45PxDxAppR26T4qYkCHAQQAQIABgUC VMZy8gAKCRBASB57j8+c7Nk5EACmHwbroT6idI5SstGUscwNh57yyL2Isf+g9WyD 4RhJixlK/yKNpF7mKbZ0sDdl+0NG7v9tjwDdR8qa66IvCkl+ML/BHRpJw+xvJtRn 1QYFHN9XouE9KZ3dQRMe6zAL+xDurEfRj/ZotILslu0kbEKhyz3EPNmm8AVoe9tR uBrG5rinT4LZjN8+WoZ2qxmHyty5O160GYZeCmcu0Ur6RdrWqS/IYNZs8l+V+QnR G8CLSVXxVGdqPRpu051D18Lz98zxUUZziprlVzXXQTet0mXnOMFhHBxjgCBmpPCt 2h65x5NJ/VuCgcYQtP5eLw2lTwF+/bnXv6VP6qSreGdMQC5SpiX8YDB1RVOgNLhF 6iN7IhqvGAC6FkUL6RWeDADRE/2os3Qai+Kx1J8CQSnUIfPAivMp7RFVW2EFvuKx FBh9/uATS6nbOSmN3N1umqAe5G6Tj1y5xMtaIykLG5TgrKo29nEx6iTn8L6eivNh wZbjFizAs41a2QQmp9f7xOPvBd1FyHi2DVyH3gI0zwXDUbsOuki7lPDBoNKo+My/ iqCv2Ji8/Roaoa+2Xva//acpcvGPeF3yg/ci3EsZz5046VKgFEkWEUSoEUNrHlPF 2Q+prgEL/lBzZ3rkrl6V4W6hhE9YQVlip1jTHNEtP5P4tLrYoH96Mb2ER2quXa7T vNoVH4kCHAQTAQIABgUCVOmc0wAKCRCHlOIWW8qb5Y1pD/9xryAD9e5pOW5WyST9 Iiusl2M0ybAAcraIWfwC+AdTYsreImCfQmeofhEv/oHb8tkHbtcPNxATIHtH0RZT BAurXVxUiDB/xy1qcnA8VMK6PvSzolkY6xIBVH9Wi8+su73Rp8Y4zSlQVrFJzBZI K2ec59+x6wBaWoFWf3KkfixhnDQJyUW8qOPhnCTNKRcGq0dIrNYqP2YrbseyOf9f GMay4Gq2ygu7nS+m0kZfcx9ewiEQpHbkkuoE78NRvFOAwZVy2xLqMT+kxPoOQvs+ kGiIxy9x3CHBnYW9QLRyfIWmLjfp2/9Z/jF2BnkLkwjkUIwxYmc2rFDNhe8RhvTQ 0w7QMFmVZD1wMhqG3uN6YErLQOdNN9srU80H/wCqRiouuQS49xXrHjcFbpuItFIt ULTeOIt1eSSjwxC0565xXD2ZWoasSBRvjS2/stk4mQJzn2JGnfadXFjEtLjXqg4S i1ibzA+5FjZuVkln/Rs1EwHEXdQ6xymnd1uPbMHaNzwrN8d7h29lwupDuR/XyrlW uKO1ItxHRePWZRIAjm3T2Q1kDncNnuRFV3ClsqjDbfmYuZDuouF9DabVnM6wcIID z0nS3mc9ebcm4ncr5R73q3OlFyxDP2iKNTNP9y/6PtOwTIBJLZ0lsPCOsuebbdvb fqq2BPBHli37yYqGUurBHcQS3IkBHAQQAQgABgUCVQYf2AAKCRCGXmyHxlKF7Dwc B/9CNzxEfbPoGR/HtoRb8ytZrboUlmFrc9j5bACpgbmh3nunDuDOBG0qvbBaYB8T RV+i7YEeVv2IO4K2DRtAx86nsH+Ovi898RDgTprW+ugAz9+sUBLpfeQV5SFa6ANw St0kPWz9EuWzxDBKUFaEOwTxUgU0z5WS8tsICUmLgdywOZz32503N0T2T8CfLw00 SZlf2xtKOAK9ZIYBYj4KGFwJmbVUMn1SbVpdyhMljiuySeFUkfpEbrzssg8iWQhY j/D2A+CSG08xMqH4iXWS6n2lLZNo183AEX5OKNBlIu9heNu85DiBnrOXzPEqG1w8 Bi7LRS+xwtCsYjBUPkyyBcIQiEYEEhECAAYFAlVXJ/sACgkQXNqsZefJxrGiHACe MOF2Aige3SyjvPvXwTpwSXnNVnUAn2aWY9OWfhMVXlEmpB/dxspuIx+BiQIcBBAB CAAGBQJVl9KkAAoJEL2p02EWwp6EdS4P/A0wzMnblk3PV5C53tPn80ZHQNZbzamu MkOejWMHVzhwp3Ox/D5jMpy+0Hmrolfk1fY2ADb2iq4j3URYgumB/3AHzdu43mZm ZRgybr29++kDtMaEZojeuTA+tPDZU1bIZjj0tGvSwRaWvBBgNUT6K1GYdd4qspyQ HEPgtMF/FybmmrIaRN7KMWdUOO9UpZ8YQZu7cry0l3KvqDOKpc6EIrwfyHLc2VZd LHNEOwCKYSNqKUdvoZOZ2LzEN86wcvvhRKxMw16WBwWh5sEbBFbJBOw0PcDIApZf YnxRMTNks3WwWAaG5yFep9pwaV4OjDX513CUjPE+LfyylA3ViNOjqBIptuIxVjMh y6ncleK6apFn1fOKR2Mm7coAo1X54OEd7U0TGtcUEr++PVuRjkSJuj6MwgxrrA2T CVo8wEU5ZaLaU5Fd3R/zlG5lAZwKSjmXZ2Grh0hUzjvyfRooi0mmCsWEAjOBKx/i NgjE255YMZYx+/UU9qzrBYBGTWxjdEBwDtTrJbgH+I2kvzLtVV8pEpVcBPlMDCKL x43MVUhrUp4E9hxK0inLlHD9bU2Old8zHA1wW4QWHu5woZfiGy2wFSbcpv/dBiBc T2n71n/+MyLtYxXg8JTA3o/y0iUr9o6+wL3pWYiQbHRHboXATzWwZllRH679YN5p 8kI/OunrdRuRiQIcBBABCAAGBQJYny2YAAoJEMNOhnPtu9Q14fQQAI95p2+SO8PV ByqQVC3poNrOUjyBtODom4JDVb9Z+DkY/8xns91XWOGu9nC+LX296braAbYfsOMY pa9T0GLHPjymqfxA+8T5OX6uN113ucNXd88BUBJ7+MoBdKljUlmBPl6o1KuTYpJ7 XfVl08J/0P3zAUe/1bmKdVkNQW9JFrlSJSCmT88j8gnzm4UZr1Jre4jR8V9K4S0i V89REgnKBM3RQ138uP+vIDckuO1dpgGdFWt5Fs5O+2nZWk4oqvTaC5to98YmaZJK RQmb/Dvsu1az2UcTrDd3a0fTfT9nH1AoK1XToE7KBFy8h8cZQ3luc79xVctPYy4A iYvvG167aUiB3iZ59xJwwlsK8qz863nhAeDWKC4F53Gh/9iwK3NpCXqumAGSVneL 7E95i5sLzw4PNmln23LhIsjq7cfNu/aG5vMdUcw5129VVU+mfs4lOwsvn9TF9sPp C348+4MkLjJxz6k0WJtSSbiwzyOd4CPnQB970ob6skFHHDOD4ac4N+u3CIsp0it3 ooUS8X/vnRR58hPEkMsROl1ay9Kwl3yQE4OjepsE+3utWGn+MOcp0lLjMY0LWeer 4mBBmOitX+TUkWfoYnjq98PNAvdaRIJpmQ9NPCpxcI1V0kipeiQQn6IwR/FWnyOL 1bBbNL031llUa079pPoySUQA1le33X+9iQIcBBABCAAGBQJYpynKAAoJEK6cJwIB 6v6V6cUP/1+CYlzsBJEUSBXgEM+E92en/ribzAC4kNDNWfxri9iBsCdsn6Kn8eRx xW0KwdfC5wizIcfiF8OOgIM/9mwCXF7EcXpm9F8YvlylJPoxZzQ3mgbUJmr4x3pP 8Pk170moCkkyads0R4mdtAhbzGVMbB28GVaxC0F9H+PwAq1fOuYKVwhED4Lp7Fhp Y2THPFbc91NhxmzwLP3CGZTswkUuhHLwCy5jHSN0Sn7csN9j5/EYRWTBUIFGIe2E pUok++gp5Qfeou2zEnvemzpKgTqsqNqsybAwXwljOzwlo87qs/sziztIF+a7UZef LsS6FIBnCPIXCCQGmHroE3oaSesZGELDmwFAT7iPoquZ6lVrxJNRhSfcwJ8zqpFu aaGhar0MS3epsT/dcoKqochVCnTfV+04IcIYwi0UwyC0tUgGfwENa+SGoDq+S4Gw d6kLDPXMuFb8Joputn6C311uy6+SS7I5k6YvNtUoRa/k70uOglwKnWdaJvLnGc6F 7Uc0MPZJnbXYIJxfINdV2qd7JpzcWtzlygtPA11gJrN1qE+BLZ+cAzo1hxkZi5Lb /5YSb4ZUPuBHOGlqALdu2rLxiy1wd/CeVewZ6P2THleqbrSxiCo9+4IY2cVMiDFB nEYYhWPznf5lh4GbzvyrkdPJ4wenBM5wzOwHhRdDxolYb1lGYY80uQMNBFTGYJQQ DADxyl9V+icAT4ND4jja/17rrrmg7L4vrXtGRtHguY5b4zr1gA/NaGYyp75vNEKZ KL1VMC2SDEf/+Ff1LmN7ohFLA42iSfYyoNRgAZ4rYox5B6uwSW+A4huVE0o9rOpQ 3nkfIUsgKB71Cy8W/ozRJme8U1uyFTEqG0SEE0fSGVUKD0dwqwSYuhrHXxvvFnES W3NI9ioi6OX+nSCK/bWXv/swOCjYgWpEVfZwQc5JpvSpBOlGHaeTBIXxf3o3XhGX igsSWcCzVLpB2ve53ckxdwr6qjsEu0ucX1NBdqHLZDSL2zfBUQF7jpsxQybtYHQV +6k1vR2wZT7tItp6kF93fdbSIAyUw57TwRg1IZhJbaWyzM9zdfFl9OpCorjd4Gou cIuOzZHb30axA7yZWN2PEjX+dQ+zoDLOkSppLbHmgltGuAAhOYnc9HnKzoHsUyjM ZdtfHpKaWEREe5iHlm7mx6FEOx6UCv/jt85l2P9YL3+m41CsvxfZDMDyd0Ou77JR yEsAAwUL/3n53Jo3uq+9+rumoKWWdH+zGkeq9db55XlsaC5MqdtsysTpcysfVo+b WUdadf837BYvk56YoYSfuFhST1oblss6FDdYYu7WNrm/V2o/QoEdpA83U7mEJEb+ xgZe26TcDN4e/NL9vR6vhyUB/yH/OcyEwa7KMwGUEWyeMU+lMLnuA0Qzx+29QJGy 7eMFREcWa1Tpqdfm7kqC5Os9/hkaMhN6zB0IfN5gmhuh5pdoG9yk+/zHTLOLQnJ1 jQF/3qFUbNOJnuUxytt6bthS3R313XlclcFhW8pkVQc2+I18TiOf4lyrwHPyjayy RKuT9xCv+N0KQ4d8GomMeLj75tZsWGFsKaHwDgy2QBApvVVu08EAHg9TMiB7GHtV Qgw4bvRU7P14Yl3Wr9G5Dz9v35JY6uL2hRxLhUCtE5UKBDc1JeOUk29qmqScnq4t 1jjA/BKxwpDHe965JiFA5d6vqYAAtjcp1gHw3wvtFaunptR7wVKZFkB0ZwN5SFFF 9Z217hIcw4hhBBgRCAAJBQJUxmCUAhsMAAoJEBILsNNtpfKs8EIBAKmqlQHwAZkH QTyBq6cyo+Bbih0EYpJPqGY6Cw9wicCiAPwP73lTWPN2MbqwT0Y7GpA44xVXBOoa VpLgVq/tXRjx3Q=3D=3D =3D0THs -----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- --------------080806020400020405070608-- --rICHnpSXH3wHK03tO4NC2RXxfP6mMf5tR-- --O0gCcJ4USUavWwk4qI3A8VnCmQiMD58S8 Content-Type: application/pgp-signature; name="signature.asc" Content-Description: OpenPGP digital signature Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="signature.asc" -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG v2 iF4EAREIAAYFAlp3GaAACgkQEguw022l8qySzQD/TnlGvWRXN0ICYqKHJWpT4UeI NnuaO20ZeecjfbFuWswA/ittFcMcj47CyFrUqGoZqcXFpe+b2tfLZ66xsZG2DFcS =oG7w -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- --O0gCcJ4USUavWwk4qI3A8VnCmQiMD58S8--