Re: bug#30680: [racket-users] Using Racket's raco on on Guix(SD)

[Nils Gillmann <ng0@n0.is>]

Christopher Lemmer Webber transcribed 3.3K bytes:
> Timothy Sample writes:
> 
> > Christopher Lemmer Webber <cwebber@dustycloud.org> writes:
> >
> >> Konrad Hinsen writes:
> >>
> >>> In my tests, all packages ended up working, but performance is indeed
> >>> worse than with a Racket installation outside of Guix.
> >>>
> >>> It would be nice if someone with more knowledge of Racket internals
> >>> could give a hint or two for debugging this issue!
> >>>
> >>> Konrad.
> >>
> >> I'm posting a bug bounty on this issue: if someone can fix this I will
> >> pay them $250 USD.  I don't have the time or knowledge enough of Racket
> >> internals to do so myself.
> >
> > I have discovered a few things, but I’m not sure how to fix the
> > underlying problem(s).
> >
> > The reason Racket is trying to recompile the OpenSSL files is because of
> > a hash mismatch.  This can be seen by enabling debugging output:
> >
> >     $ PLTSTDERR=debug raco setup openssl
> >
> > Which says a lot of things, but most interestingly it says:
> >
> > --------------------------------
> > ...
> > compiler/cm: checking: /gnu/store/jx0bkmaafb8fq0mqs5ywgnxq8rbpn8j1-racket-6.12/share/racket/collects/openssl/libcrypto.rkt
> > compiler/cm: different src hash... (5d9ca57f3e267d956c7b5e62578467beb8ccc1d2 4d21ac412723fbf33f97669c2f73f0e9367f4510)
> > compiler/cm: maybe-compile-zo starting /gnu/store/jx0bkmaafb8fq0mqs5ywgnxq8rbpn8j1-racket-6.12/share/racket/collects/openssl/libcrypto.rkt
> > compiler/cm:   start-compile: /gnu/store/jx0bkmaafb8fq0mqs5ywgnxq8rbpn8j1-racket-6.12/share/racket/collects/openssl/libcrypto.rkt
> > compiler/cm:   compiling /gnu/store/jx0bkmaafb8fq0mqs5ywgnxq8rbpn8j1-racket-6.12/share/racket/collects/openssl/libcrypto.rkt
> > open-output-file: cannot open output file
> >   path: /gnu/store/jx0bkmaafb8fq0mqs5ywgnxq8rbpn8j1-racket-6.12/share/racket/collects/openssl/compiled/tmp15340167971534016797570
> >   system error: Read-only file system; errno=30
> >   context...:
> > ...
> > --------------------------------
> >
> > This hash mismatch is caused by grafting.  When the package is built,
> > the path to OpenSSL gets hard-coded in a source file.  The SHA-1 hash
> > for this file is stored in its “.dep” file.  When the output is
> > grafted, the source file gets updated with a new OpenSSL path, but the
> > hash does not get updated.  This makes Racket think that the cached
> > bytecode file is incorrect (even though it was likely grafted too),
> > and it tries to recompile it.  It fails because it tries to write this
> > new bytecode file to the store.
> 
> Interesting... I hadn't even considered grafting.  (I still wonder why
> it's even trying to open *any* file in the store for output though...)
> 
> > I double checked this by trying with an ungrafted Racket, and got better
> > results.  (There was still a warning about writing to the store, but it
> > seemed less significant.)
> 
> Cool!
> 
> > The only thing I can think of for a fix would be to patch Racket to be
> > more lenient with bytecode files in the store.  That is, ignore hash
> > mismatches in store-files.  I might give this a try later tonight if
> > nobody has any better ideas.
> >
> > -- Tim
> 
> BTW, some examples of packages where I've had trouble, in case it helps
> with testing:
> 
>  - Raart
>  - Gregor
>  - crypto (seemed to work last time, not sure why it wasn't working before)
> 
> Though at this point I also can't do just "raco setup" on a local
> package either, but maybe resolving this issue will fix that.
> 
From what I've learned in the last couple of hours, the last problem could
be due to leftovers in your raco / dotRacket folder from an older installation.