bug#72174: guix download does not support Mercurial

bug#72174: guix download does not support Mercurial

[PIERRE AUGIER]

https://foss.heptapod.net/fluiddyn/fluidsim is a Mercurial repository.

```
guix download --commit=62c4dbe4f786 https://foss.heptapod.net/fluiddyn/fluidsim
```

fails with:

```
SWH: revision "62c4dbe4f786" originating from https://foss.heptapod.net/fluiddyn/fluidsim could not be found
guix download: warning: revision 62c4dbe4f786 of https://foss.heptapod.net/fluiddyn/fluidsim could not be fetched from Software Heritage
guix download: error: Git error: unexpected http status code: 404
```

I studied `guix download -h` which shows that `guix download` only supports Git repositories. Since there is `hg-download`, it would make sense that the command `guix download` support Mercurial.

--
Pierre Augier - CR CNRS                 http://www.legi.grenoble-inp.fr
LEGI (UMR 5519) Laboratoire des Ecoulements Geophysiques et Industriels
BP53, 38041 Grenoble Cedex, France                tel:+33.4.56.52.86.16

bug#72174: guix download does not support Mercurial

[Ludovic Courtès]

Hi,

PIERRE AUGIER <pierre.augier@univ-grenoble-alpes.fr> skribis:

> I studied `guix download -h` which shows that `guix download` only supports Git repositories. Since there is `hg-download`, it would make sense that the command `guix download` support Mercurial.

Indeed, only Git is supported at this point.  Supporting Mercurial and
other VCSes would be nice though there’s no plan to do so at this point
(Git support was a low-hanging fruit since Git is already tightly
integrated).

Thanks,
Ludo’.

bug#72174: guix download does not support Mercurial

[Simon Tournier]

Hi,

On Mon, 22 Jul 2024 at 09:11, Ludovic Courtès <ludovic.courtes@inria.fr> wrote:

>> I studied `guix download -h` which shows that `guix download` only
>> supports Git repositories. Since there is `hg-download`, it would
>> make sense that the command `guix download` support Mercurial. 
>
> Indeed, only Git is supported at this point.  Supporting Mercurial and
> other VCSes would be nice though there’s no plan to do so at this point
> (Git support was a low-hanging fruit since Git is already tightly
> integrated).

Somehow, “guix download” does not rely on the module ’(guix
git-download)’ that provides ’git-fetch’ but it relies on the module
’(guix git)’.  Therefore, “hg-download” is not helpful here and somehow
a brick seems lacking. :-)

Maybe I misread, my understanding in short is that “git-download” or
“hg-download” works with fixed-output derivations, hence the hash must
be known beforehand; source code is fetched via a derivation that the
guix-daemon processes.

Instead, “guix download” fetches using code from user side and not from
guix-daemon side and the source is fetched inside some user’s cache that
is then copied to the store.  This way there is no hash check.

The code behind “guix download” supporting Git is implemented with
guile-libgit2 – tightly integrated ;-); see latest-repository-commit
calling update-cached-checkout from (guix git).  It would be possible to
implement the equivalent for Mercurial or redesign “guix download”; in
both cases, todo. :-)

HTH

Cheers,
simon