Re: LUKS-encrypted root and unencrypted /boot ?

["Clément Lassieur" <clement@lassieur.org>]

Benjamin Slade <beoram@gmail.com> writes:

>  > Do you use Libreboot?
>
> Yes, I'm using Libreboot. Does this make a great difference over the
> manufacturer firmware in this case?

It might, because the GRUB used is the one shipped with Libreboot.  So
it has nothing to do with Guix.  I think talking to the libreboot people
would help you more.  (Disclaimer: I have the same issue, I find that
pressing 'c' and typing 'cryptomount ahci0,gpt3' makes the process
faster.)

>  > I'm unsure [using an unencrypted /boot] would help, because GRUB
>  > would still have to unencrypt / to access the kernel (the kernel is
>  > in /gnu/store).
>
> Ah, I see. Is this an immutable design decision?  It would seem good to
> be able to keep the kernel in a separate space in order to avoid the
> issue of extremely long unlocking times when booting.

Nothing is immutable, but it's a strong design decision that all
packages data are put in /gnu/store.  Linux is just one of them.  Plus,
a characteristic of GuixSD is that you can revert to previous
configurations.  Those configurations appear as GRUB lines.  Each
configuration could have a different kernel and kernels take space, so
it wouldn't scale well.  Plus, I think some other stuff is needed as
well, like the initrd, which is large too, etc.

There are probably reasons I don't know about too :-)

Good luck!
Clément