On 2022-09-02 16:52, Liliana Marie Prikler wrote:

> Hi,
>
> Am Freitag, dem 02.09.2022 um 17:02 +0300 schrieb Andrew Tropin:
>> Picked (guix build emacs-utils) for now, it's done to avoid huge
>> rebuilds, while testing, later we can move it to (guix build utils).
>> 
>> Also, temporary added pandoc and texinfo to native-inputs for
>> emacs-build-system, otherwise I would need to update inputs for
>> almost every emacs-* package.  Need to figure out what to do with
>> this.
> I still don't like that we need pandoc and texinfo as implicit inputs.
> There ought to be a better solution than this.
>
>> > 
>> > > Attaching the latest version of the documentation-files patch I
>> > > have
>> > Looking at this patch, perhaps we'd also have to allow customizing
>> > command line options.  Also, as for installing, I think this should
>> > be
>> > handled by the install phase, which already has includes
>> > "^[^/]*\\.info$" and "^doc/.*\\.info$" by default.  Thus, you only
>> > need
>> > to build documentation before the install phase.
>> 
>> That's right, but in the new iteration (v3) of build-documentation
>> phase I use find-root-library-file, which expects to be executed when
>> elpa directory is already available, so I can't do it before install
>> phase and need to manually install info files.
>> 
>> Also, current build phases order is a little confusing, a lot of
>> builds happens after install phase, directly in output directory:
>> 
>> `set-SOURCE-DATE-EPOCH'
>> `set-paths'
>> `install-locale'
>> `unpack'
>> `expand-load-path'
>> `patch-usr-bin-file'
>> `patch-source-shebangs'
>> `patch-generated-file-shebangs'
>> `check'
>> `install'
>> `make-autoloads'
>> `enable-autoloads-compilation'
>> `patch-el-files'
>> `ensure-package-description'
>> `build'
>> `validate-compiled-autoloads'
>> `build-documentation'
>> `move-doc'
>> `patch-shebangs'
>> `strip'
>> `validate-runpath'
>> `validate-documentation-location'
>> `delete-info-dir-file'
>> `patch-dot-desktop-files'
>> `make-dynamic-linker-cache'
>> `install-license-files'
>> `reset-gzip-timestamps'
>> `compress-documentation'
>> 
>> What if instead of install phase we will use create-tmp-lisp-and-
>> documentation-directories phase (or something
>> more meaningful) to make a temporary directory, where we will build
>> all the stuff and after that, at the end of the build process will
>> install everything from this temporary directory to the store?  This
>> way emacs-build-system will become more usual and easier to
>> understand andpredict.
> I don't think we would need to do staged installations.  As for why we
> don't build in the temporary directory, I do not know, I merely
> inherited that code.
>
>> +(define* (build-documentation-texinfo
>> +          #:key
>> +          (files '())
>> +          (command '("makeinfo" "--no-split")))
>> +  "Don't forget to add texinfo into list of inputs for the package."
>> +  (lambda* (#:key outputs #:allow-other-keys)
>> +    (for-each (lambda (f) (apply invoke (append command (list f))))
>> files)))
> This is hardly specific to emacs, is it?
> Also, append is usually a code smell.  Can't we (apply invoke
> "makeinfo" file options)?
>
>> +(define* (convert-documentation
>> +          #:key
>> +          (mapping '())
>> +          (command '("pandoc")))
>> +  "Don't forget to add pandoc into list of inputs for the package."
>> +  (lambda* (#:key outputs #:allow-other-keys)
>> +    (for-each (lambda (p) (apply invoke
>> +                                 (append command
>> +                                         (list (car p) "-o" (cdr
>> p)))))
>> +              mapping)))
> As above.
>
>> +(define* (build-documentation-org
>> +          #:key
>> +          (files '()))
> This one is emacs-specific due to emacs-batch-script and can remain
> there.
>
>> +    (add-after 'validate-compiled-autoloads 'move-doc move-doc)
>> +    (add-before 'move-doc 'build-documentation
>> build-documentation)))
> I don't think that we'll have to add this phase once we've added the
> helpers.  And as previously discussed, we'd have to build the
> documentation before install.
>
> Cheers

I think we can consider this patch series as an thought experiment.

Manually adding documentation build phases works good enough and
probably there is no need to do something more generic like this.

Closing the ticket without merging.

Liliana, thank you for you time!

-- 
Best regards,
Andrew Tropin