Release 1.2.1: Remove 31 Python 2 packages

Release 1.2.1: Remove 31 Python 2 packages

[zimoun]

Hi,

Using “guix weather --display-missing” at commit 6bed29b, I have
identified these 31 Python 2 packages to remove:

--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
python2-arrow
python2-cairocffi
python2-cairocffi
python2-dulwich
python2-fido2
python2-flask
python2-flask-babel
python2-flask-htmlmin
python2-flask-login
python2-flask-multistatic
python2-flask-wtf
python2-furl
python2-graphql-core
python2-httpbin
python2-ipykernel
python2-ipyparallel
python2-ipython
python2-ipython-cluster-helper
python2-ipywidgets
python2-jupyter-console
python2-mpd2
python2-mutagen
python2-nbxmpp
python2-pyfakefs
python2-rq
python2-sh
python2-stem
python2-tables
python2-utils
python2-widgetsnbextension
python2-wsgiproxy2
python2-yubikey-manager
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---


They do not build.  The Python 3 variant builds or does not exist.

Last, “guix refresh -l <pkg>” is fine.


Any objection?


Cheers,
simon

Re: Release 1.2.1: Remove 31 Python 2 packages

[Maxim Cournoyer]

Hi Simon,

zimoun <zimon.toutoune@gmail.com> writes:

> Hi,
>
> Using “guix weather --display-missing” at commit 6bed29b, I have
> identified these 31 Python 2 packages to remove:
>
> python2-arrow
> python2-cairocffi
> python2-cairocffi
> python2-dulwich
> python2-fido2
> python2-flask
> python2-flask-babel
> python2-flask-htmlmin
> python2-flask-login
> python2-flask-multistatic
> python2-flask-wtf
> python2-furl
> python2-graphql-core
> python2-httpbin
> python2-ipykernel
> python2-ipyparallel
> python2-ipython
> python2-ipython-cluster-helper
> python2-ipywidgets
> python2-jupyter-console
> python2-mpd2
> python2-mutagen
> python2-nbxmpp
> python2-pyfakefs
> python2-rq
> python2-sh
> python2-stem
> python2-tables
> python2-utils
> python2-widgetsnbextension
> python2-wsgiproxy2
> python2-yubikey-manager
>
>
> They do not build.  The Python 3 variant builds or does not exist.
>
> Last, “guix refresh -l <pkg>” is fine.
>
>
> Any objection?

It's hard objecting to removing Python 2 packages, with Python 2 having
been EOL since 2020.  In my opinion, some exceptions could apply, if
something provides unique value that cannot be substituted.  I guess
these are increasingly rare...

In the end though, the Python 2 packages must go, so I think it's not
unreasonable to remove the broken ones to start.  Someone finding the
packages important enough could fix them and publish them in a separate
Python 2 channel.

So, no objections here.

Maxim

Re: Release 1.2.1: Remove 31 Python 2 packages

[zimoun]

Hi Maxim,

On Sun, 14 Mar 2021 at 02:03, Maxim Cournoyer <maxim.cournoyer@gmail.com> wrote:
> zimoun <zimon.toutoune@gmail.com> writes:

> In the end though, the Python 2 packages must go, so I think it's not
> unreasonable to remove the broken ones to start.  Someone finding the
> packages important enough could fix them and publish them in a separate
> Python 2 channel.

I removed 25 packages from the list.   See:
<http://issues.guix.gnu.org/47165>.  Feel free to push if everything
is fine. :-)

The remaining ones are:

> > python2-ipykernel
> > python2-ipyparallel
> > python2-ipython
> > python2-ipython-cluster-helper
> > python2-jupyter-console
> > python2-pyfakefs

because "guix weather" reported them as substituable with recent commit.

All the best,
simon