Re: Package test service for GNU maintainers

[ludo@gnu.org (Ludovic Courtès)]

John Darrington <john@darrington.wattle.id.au> skribis:

> I could give it a go.

Cool!

> 2. By default, guix does not check that out-of-source builds are functional.
>    "make distcheck" on the other-hand does.  Do we want to duplicate the function
>    of "make distcheck"?  Perhaps we do, since I have recently seen a rather bad
>    GNU release where it obviously wasn't run.

That’s not the goal here.  The goal would just be to make sure that the
package can be integrated in the distro.

> 3. Should we check too that a package behaves sanely when cross-compiling?

Perhaps, yes.

> 4. Some years ago, somebody knocked up a similar "GNU package linter" and ran
>    it on all GNU packages.  One maintainer got very shitty about a "deficiency"
>    that was detected - started demanding an apology, blah, blah blah ...

Was it the CI service at hydra.nixos.org that Rob Vermaas and I got
started?  :-)

I think here we’re aiming for something much more focused, which is
integration of (pre)releases in the distro.

Ludo’.