bug#41569: build systems cannot set default outputs other than "out"

bug#41569: build systems cannot set default outputs other than "out"

[Ricardo Wurmus]

For the haskell-build-system I want to offer two outputs by default:
"out" and "static".  However, the build system has no way to override
the default as (@ (guix packages) package->bag) passes the package’s
“outputs” value to make-bag.

When the package doesn’t define a value for “outputs”, the default
'("out") is used.  I suggest removing the default value from the
<package> record, so that the build system defaults have a chance.

-- 
Ricardo

bug#41569: build systems cannot set default outputs other than "out"

[Ludovic Courtès]

Hi,

Ricardo Wurmus <rekado@elephly.net> skribis:

> For the haskell-build-system I want to offer two outputs by default:
> "out" and "static".  However, the build system has no way to override
> the default as (@ (guix packages) package->bag) passes the package’s
> “outputs” value to make-bag.

Ah.

> When the package doesn’t define a value for “outputs”, the default
> '("out") is used.  I suggest removing the default value from the
> <package> record, so that the build system defaults have a chance.

Problem is, we don’t want to add an ‘outputs’ line to each and every
package definition.  So how can we deal with that?

We could have a special trick where ‘outputs’ defaults to a special
value and ‘package-outputs’ actually asks the build system what the
default outputs are.

Thoughts?

Ludo’.