bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 14:08:01 +0000 (UTC)
> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
> Cc: 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> 
> On Sep 13, 2023 09:26, Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> wrote:
> 
>  > I am not sure what you're suggesting.  Can you show how the equivalent 
>  > of: 
>  > 
>  > emacsclient --apply message-mailto -- %u 
>  > 
>  > would work with that design? 
> 
>    emacsclient --qeval '(message-mailto %u)'
> 
> I don't think this can work in general for arbitrary user input: what if %u is replaced with something
> that contains parentheses?

They are inside '..', so the only one who'd care is Emacs, not the
shell.  In which case it's the job of whoever provides the value for
%u to handle that.

And anyway, how is that different from the same problem happening with
your suggested --funcall or --apply? they will bump into the same
issues.

>  Let's not do that this time, okay?
> 
> Agreed, I think we reached a consensus in that bug and now I am implementing that consensus.

AFAIU, there was no consensus reached there, so I'm unsure what are
you alluding to here.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Andreas Schwab]

On Sep 13 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:

> They are inside '..', so the only one who'd care is Emacs, not the
> shell.  In which case it's the job of whoever provides the value for
> %u to handle that.

The spec does not allow that.  The %u marker cannot be part of a quoted
argument.

-- 
Andreas Schwab, SUSE Labs, schwab@suse.de
GPG Key fingerprint = 0196 BAD8 1CE9 1970 F4BE  1748 E4D4 88E3 0EEA B9D7
"And now for something completely different."

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Spencer Baugh]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
>> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 14:08:01 +0000 (UTC)
>> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
>> Cc: 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> 
>> On Sep 13, 2023 09:26, Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> wrote:
>> 
>>  > I am not sure what you're suggesting.  Can you show how the equivalent 
>>  > of: 
>>  > 
>>  > emacsclient --apply message-mailto -- %u 
>>  > 
>>  > would work with that design? 
>> 
>>    emacsclient --qeval '(message-mailto %u)'
>> 
>> I don't think this can work in general for arbitrary user input: what if %u is replaced with something
>> that contains parentheses?
>
> They are inside '..', so the only one who'd care is Emacs, not the
> shell.

Agreed.  The problem I'm referring to is in Emacs, interpreting
arbitrary input from the web as code.  (The .desktop commands don't even
use a shell, a shell doesn't need to be involved at any point)

> In which case it's the job of whoever provides the value for
> %u to handle that.

The value for %u is an arbitrary string from some other application
which wants to open a mailto: URI, and passes it to xdg-open which then
passes it to Emacs.  Other applications are not aware of what escaping
is needed to make Emacs not interpret it as code.  And indeed, there's
no point in doing that: Emacs is in the best position to do that
escaping, if it needs to be done.

> And anyway, how is that different from the same problem happening with
> your suggested --funcall or --apply? they will bump into the same
> issues.

No, they won't: --apply passes the arguments as a string, without ever
trying to parse them as Lisp.

Let's be concrete: imagine %u is replaced with
(shell-command "rm -r /")
as could happen if an application receives some malicious input.

The command line with --qeval is:
emacsclient --qeval '(message-mailto (shell-command "rm -r /"))'

Emacs receives
-eval (message-mailto (shell-command "rm -r /"))
and evals
(message-mailto (shell-command "rm -r /"))
and deletes your files.

The command line with --apply is:
emacsclient --apply message-mailto '(shell-command "rm -r /")'

Emacs receives
-apply message-mailto --applyarg (shell-command "rm -r /")
and evals
(message-mailto "(shell-command \"rm -r /\")")
and nothing bad happens.

Emacs just needs to get the verbatim string without trying to parse it
as Lisp at any point.  This is an extremely standard security technique
when dealing with malicious input, which is why the previous thread
converged on it so quickly.

>>  Let's not do that this time, okay?
>> 
>> Agreed, I think we reached a consensus in that bug and now I am implementing that consensus.
>
> AFAIU, there was no consensus reached there, so I'm unsure what are
> you alluding to here.

Everyone in that thread agreed that something like this --apply design
(which passes the strings verbatim to Emacs without evaling them) is
what we need, they were just discussing the exact design, and in the end
the design that everyone who posted agreed on, matched what I have
implemented...  I don't think we need to relitigate it.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Jim Porter]

On 9/13/2023 8:23 AM, Spencer Baugh wrote:
> Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
>> AFAIU, there was no consensus reached there, so I'm unsure what are
>> you alluding to here.
> 
> Everyone in that thread agreed that something like this --apply design
> (which passes the strings verbatim to Emacs without evaling them) is
> what we need, they were just discussing the exact design, and in the end
> the design that everyone who posted agreed on, matched what I have
> implemented...  I don't think we need to relitigate it.

That was my impression as well. Most of the discussion in that bug was 
among Robert (already commenting on this bug in agreement with the 
current patch), Gregory (who I believe supports the --apply design[1]), 
Lars (who proposed a form of the --apply design to handle multiple 
--apply calls[2]), and me (I support --apply, using Lars' semantics if 
we can get it).

[1] https://debbugs.gnu.org/cgi/bugreport.cgi?bug=57752#119
[2] https://debbugs.gnu.org/cgi/bugreport.cgi?bug=57752#122

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>
> Cc: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 11:23:06 -0400
> 
> >> Agreed, I think we reached a consensus in that bug and now I am implementing that consensus.
> >
> > AFAIU, there was no consensus reached there, so I'm unsure what are
> > you alluding to here.
> 
> Everyone in that thread agreed that something like this --apply design
> (which passes the strings verbatim to Emacs without evaling them) is
> what we need, they were just discussing the exact design, and in the end
> the design that everyone who posted agreed on, matched what I have
> implemented...

That's not my reading of that long discussion.

And I don't understand why we need to add any options to Emacs itself,
btw.  The suggestion to have some "symmetry" here was one of the
reasons that discussion got nowhere.  So let's learn from that
mistake, at least.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Jim Porter]

On 9/13/2023 12:13 PM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
> And I don't understand why we need to add any options to Emacs itself,
> btw.  The suggestion to have some "symmetry" here was one of the
> reasons that discussion got nowhere.  So let's learn from that
> mistake, at least.

There's a practical benefit to this. If you have $EDITOR set in your 
environment to something like "emacsclient --alternate-editor=emacs", 
then it would be nice if you could say this:

   $EDITOR --apply some-func arg1 arg2

and have it do the same thing whether or not there was already an Emacs 
server running. The symmetry between the two commands (plus proper 
argument forwarding) would make that work.

However, if people can't agree, then we could probably drop that part. 
To me, it sounds like people *do* agree that this would be good to have 
though.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Spencer Baugh]

Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com> writes:

> On 9/13/2023 12:13 PM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
>> And I don't understand why we need to add any options to Emacs itself,
>> btw.  The suggestion to have some "symmetry" here was one of the
>> reasons that discussion got nowhere.  So let's learn from that
>> mistake, at least.
>
> There's a practical benefit to this. If you have $EDITOR set in your
> environment to something like "emacsclient --alternate-editor=emacs",
> then it would be nice if you could say this:
>
>   $EDITOR --apply some-func arg1 arg2
>
> and have it do the same thing whether or not there was already an
> Emacs server running. The symmetry between the two commands (plus
> proper argument forwarding) would make that work.

This already works out of the box with --alternate-editor='', no need
for any argument forwarding, and no need for support for this argument
in Emacs itself.

It doesn't work with --alternate-editor=emacs, but I think that is OK.
I think the alternate-editor='' configuration is far more common, and
that works just fine.

And we have not before done any special casing for forwarding arguments
from emacsclient to alternate-editor=emacs, so I don't think there's any
reason to start now.  (I personally think that alternate-editor=emacs is
somewhat ill-advised, since it doesn't ensure that the server gets
started)

That being said, supporting --apply in Emacs itself is fine with me,
although it's not strictly necessary since in Emacs itself,
--apply func --
is basically equivalent to
--eval (apply func command-line-args-left)

(This doesn't work in emacsclient, and would be very difficult to
support, so --apply is necessary for emacsclient)

> However, if people can't agree, then we could probably drop that
> part. To me, it sounds like people *do* agree that this would be good
> to have though.

I'm fine either way.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Jim Porter]

On 9/13/2023 1:00 PM, Spencer Baugh wrote:
> It doesn't work with --alternate-editor=emacs, but I think that is OK.
> I think the alternate-editor='' configuration is far more common, and
> that works just fine.

In that case, I think the benefits of "emacs --apply" are somewhat 
reduced, but it does still make some cases a bit easier. 
("emacs-mail.desktop" could use it, which would let us simplify the 
implementation of 'message-mailto' a little.)

Still, if we dropped "emacs --apply" I wouldn't stamp my feet about it. 
The main benefit is for emacsclient anyway, where it seems we have 
consensus.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 12:33:01 -0700
> Cc: sbaugh@catern.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> From: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>
> 
> On 9/13/2023 12:13 PM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
> > And I don't understand why we need to add any options to Emacs itself,
> > btw.  The suggestion to have some "symmetry" here was one of the
> > reasons that discussion got nowhere.  So let's learn from that
> > mistake, at least.
> 
> There's a practical benefit to this. If you have $EDITOR set in your 
> environment to something like "emacsclient --alternate-editor=emacs", 
> then it would be nice if you could say this:
> 
>    $EDITOR --apply some-func arg1 arg2
> 
> and have it do the same thing whether or not there was already an Emacs 
> server running. The symmetry between the two commands (plus proper 
> argument forwarding) would make that work.
> 
> However, if people can't agree, then we could probably drop that part. 
> To me, it sounds like people *do* agree that this would be good to have 
> though.

People might agree, but I don't.  Please consider the perspective.
This started as an obscure and rare problem in a desktop file (which
we provided solely out of good will, since it really isn't our job to
do so, it's the job of downstream distros).  The proposed solution was
to add a completely new option to emacsclient, with its own special
syntax and rules about what can and cannot be done with it.  This is
already something that should raise brows: how can such an unimportant
reason cause us to make such significant changes?  We didn't yet
finish discussing that nor even had time to understand all the
implications (remember: Lars suggested to support several such
options, which required another special option), and we already are
told that "for symmetry" we should add the same to Emacs.  All that
where just yesterday there was no need for any new options in either,
and if we decided to drop those desktop files from our sources (which
I personally am tempted to do every few weeks, due to issues they
cause us all the time since their introduction), then even the
original need will miraculously disappear into thin air.

So this is a classic case of the tail wagging the dog.

What about alternative solutions: use a shell script in the desktop
files, and delegate to that script to solve the problem with quoting?
Had anyone considered this strategy?  If not, why not?

I would in general prefer not to add any new options to our programs
due to this weak reason.  Once again: it is not our job to get these
desktop files right in every single downstream environment, so let's
not make it our problem, certainly not a problem we should solve using
such non-trivial solutions.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 12:33:01 -0700
>> Cc: sbaugh@catern.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> From: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>
>> 
>> On 9/13/2023 12:13 PM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
>> > And I don't understand why we need to add any options to Emacs itself,
>> > btw.  The suggestion to have some "symmetry" here was one of the
>> > reasons that discussion got nowhere.  So let's learn from that
>> > mistake, at least.
>> 
>> There's a practical benefit to this. If you have $EDITOR set in your 
>> environment to something like "emacsclient --alternate-editor=emacs", 
>> then it would be nice if you could say this:
>> 
>>    $EDITOR --apply some-func arg1 arg2
>> 
>> and have it do the same thing whether or not there was already an Emacs 
>> server running. The symmetry between the two commands (plus proper 
>> argument forwarding) would make that work.
>> 
>> However, if people can't agree, then we could probably drop that part. 
>> To me, it sounds like people *do* agree that this would be good to have 
>> though.
>
> People might agree, but I don't.  Please consider the perspective.
> This started as an obscure and rare problem in a desktop file (which
> we provided solely out of good will, since it really isn't our job to
> do so, it's the job of downstream distros).  The proposed solution was
> to add a completely new option to emacsclient, with its own special
> syntax and rules about what can and cannot be done with it.  This is
> already something that should raise brows: how can such an unimportant
> reason cause us to make such significant changes?  We didn't yet
> finish discussing that nor even had time to understand all the
> implications (remember: Lars suggested to support several such
> options, which required another special option), and we already are
> told that "for symmetry" we should add the same to Emacs.  All that
> where just yesterday there was no need for any new options in either,
> and if we decided to drop those desktop files from our sources (which
> I personally am tempted to do every few weeks, due to issues they
> cause us all the time since their introduction), then even the
> original need will miraculously disappear into thin air.

The issue is not really with the desktop file.  It's a generic problem:
Suppose I have some arbitrary data which I want to send to the Emacs
server (in this case, a URI).  Today, there's no easy way to do that.

- One approach is to stick the data inside an --eval call, as
  emacsclient-mail.desktop is doing.  Getting the quoting right is hard
  and complex, and even Emacs developers have failed at it over multiple
  iterations, and when they fail it either breaks or exposes a security
  vulnerability.  It is currently broken for me.

- Another approach is to do what org-protocol does (shipped with
  Emacs!), and advise server-visit-files (with
  org-protocol-check-filename-for-protocol), and pass the data as a
  string FILE argument to emacsclient which gets intercepted by advice.
  But this is of course a gross hack, and also it still requires
  escaping the data, since some characters will still be specially
  interpreted.  It would be nice to get rid of this org-protocol hack
  which is shipped with Emacs.

- A third approach is to put the data in a temporary file and pass the
  path of that file to emacsclient, then use an --eval to process the
  file.  But this doesn't work when emacsclient and the Emacs server are
  on different hosts or in different environments.

- Finally, a fourth approach is to teach emacsclient to be able to send
  this arbitrary data to Emacs on its own.  Such as by adding --apply.
  There are a bunch of designs for that, but all of them require
  modifying emacsclient.

I have many times before wanted to be able to pass data to Emacs without
worrying about escaping.  This would be a very useful feature to have.
And it would be nice to get rid of the org-protocol hack, and get rid of
the complicated and broken escaping needed for things like
emacsclient-mail.desktop.

> So this is a classic case of the tail wagging the dog.
>
> What about alternative solutions: use a shell script in the desktop
> files, and delegate to that script to solve the problem with quoting?
> Had anyone considered this strategy?  If not, why not?

Getting the quoting right is hard and complex, and even Emacs developers
have failed at it over multiple iterations, and when they fail it either
breaks or exposes a security vulnerability.  This solution is far
simpler, and is reusable for many other different purposes.

> I would in general prefer not to add any new options to our programs
> due to this weak reason.  Once again: it is not our job to get these
> desktop files right in every single downstream environment, so let's
> not make it our problem, certainly not a problem we should solve using
> such non-trivial solutions.

We don't have to add it to Emacs itself.  But it's not just for the
desktop files.  It's a relatively small feature to add to emacsclient,
and it's something that I've heard years of user requests for.

I have many times before wanted to be able to pass data to Emacs without
worrying about escaping.  This would be a very useful feature to have.
It would be nice to get rid of the org-protocol hack, and get rid of the
complicated and broken escaping needed for things like
emacsclient-mail.desktop.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 115 bytes --]


Here's a revised patch which drops adding the argument to Emacs itself;
it only adds an argument to emacsclient.


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-apply-argument-to-emacsclient-to-avoid-escaping.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 7960 bytes --]

From d4558462598eaa33466b3b2fb1dbcc26ea877ede Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 07:12:22 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add --apply argument to emacsclient to avoid escaping

Passing arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval requires
complicated escaping (as seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this
change).

The new --apply argument for emacsclient passes command line arguments
as uninterpreted strings to the specified function.  This simplifies
use cases where arbitrary input needs to be passed to Emacs.

org-protocol will be able to use this as well, which will allow it to
eventually drop its current advice on server-visit-files.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use --apply. (bug#65902)
* lib-src/emacsclient.c (longopts, decode_options, main): Add support
for --apply.
* lisp/server.el (server-apply-and-print): Add.
(server-process-filter): Add support for -apply and -applyargs
---
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  7 ++-----
 lib-src/emacsclient.c        | 36 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--
 lisp/server.el               | 34 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 3 files changed, 70 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-)

diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..ea0690bacd9 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --apply message-mailto -- %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,7 +13,7 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --apply message-mailto -- %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
diff --git a/lib-src/emacsclient.c b/lib-src/emacsclient.c
index 698bf9b50ae..159c22d1ae9 100644
--- a/lib-src/emacsclient.c
+++ b/lib-src/emacsclient.c
@@ -116,6 +116,9 @@ #define DEFAULT_TIMEOUT (30)
 /* True means args are expressions to be evaluated.  --eval.  */
 static bool eval;
 
+/* The function to call.  Other arguments are passed as strings.  --apply.  */
+static char *apply;
+
 /* True means open a new frame.  --create-frame etc.  */
 static bool create_frame;
 
@@ -169,6 +172,7 @@ #define DEFAULT_TIMEOUT (30)
   { "quiet",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'q' },
   { "suppress-output", no_argument, NULL, 'u' },
   { "eval",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'e' },
+  { "apply",	required_argument, NULL, 'y' },
   { "help",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'H' },
   { "version",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'V' },
   { "tty",	no_argument,       NULL, 't' },
@@ -552,6 +556,10 @@ decode_options (int argc, char **argv)
 	  eval = true;
 	  break;
 
+	case 'y':
+	  apply = optarg;
+	  break;
+
 	case 'q':
 	  quiet = true;
 	  break;
@@ -690,6 +698,7 @@ print_help_and_exit (void)
 -F ALIST, --frame-parameters=ALIST\n\
 			Set the parameters of a new frame\n\
 -e, --eval    		Evaluate the FILE arguments as ELisp expressions\n\
+-y, --apply FUNC	Call ELisp FUNC, passing all FILE arguments as strings\n\
 -n, --no-wait		Don't wait for the server to return\n\
 -w, --timeout=SECONDS	Seconds to wait before timing out\n\
 -q, --quiet		Don't display messages on success\n\
@@ -1953,7 +1962,7 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
   /* Process options.  */
   decode_options (argc, argv);
 
-  if (! (optind < argc || eval || create_frame))
+  if (! (optind < argc || eval || apply || create_frame))
     {
       message (true, ("%s: file name or argument required\n"
 		      "Try '%s --help' for more information\n"),
@@ -1961,6 +1970,14 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
       exit (EXIT_FAILURE);
     }
 
+  if (eval && apply)
+    {
+      message (true, ("%s: can't pass both --eval and --apply\n"
+		      "Try '%s --help' for more information\n"),
+	       progname, progname);
+      exit (EXIT_FAILURE);
+    }
+
 #ifdef SOCKETS_IN_FILE_SYSTEM
   if (tty)
     {
@@ -2080,6 +2097,13 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
               send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
               continue;
             }
+	  else if (apply)
+	    {
+              send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "-applyarg ");
+              quote_argument (emacs_socket, argv[i]);
+              send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
+              continue;
+	    }
 
 	  char *p = argv[i];
 	  if (*p == '+')
@@ -2136,10 +2160,18 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
       send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
     }
 
+  if (apply)
+    {
+      send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "-apply ");
+      quote_argument (emacs_socket, apply);
+      send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
+    }
+
+
   send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "\n");
 
   /* Wait for an answer. */
-  if (!eval && !tty && !nowait && !quiet && 0 <= process_grouping ())
+  if (!eval && !apply && !tty && !nowait && !quiet && 0 <= process_grouping ())
     {
       printf ("Waiting for Emacs...");
       skiplf = false;
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index c3325e5a24c..5981e90625d 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -873,6 +873,17 @@ server-eval-and-print
                        (point-min) (point-max))))
             (server-reply-print (server-quote-arg text) proc)))))))
 
+(defun server-apply-and-print (func args proc)
+  "Call FUNC on ARGS and send the result back to client PROC."
+  (let ((v (with-local-quit (eval (apply (intern func) args) t))))
+    (when proc
+      (with-temp-buffer
+        (let ((standard-output (current-buffer)))
+          (pp v)
+          (let ((text (buffer-substring-no-properties
+                       (point-min) (point-max))))
+            (server-reply-print (server-quote-arg text) proc)))))))
+
 (defconst server-msg-size 1024
   "Maximum size of a message sent to a client.")
 
@@ -1196,6 +1207,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		tty-type   ; string.
 		files
 		filepos
+		applyargs
 		args-left)
 	    ;; Remove this line from STRING.
 	    (setq string (substring string (match-end 0)))
@@ -1323,6 +1335,28 @@ server-process-filter
                          commands)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
+                ;; -apply FUNC:  Call a function on arguments.
+                ("-apply"
+                 (if use-current-frame
+                     (setq use-current-frame 'always))
+                 (let ((func (pop args-left)))
+                   (if coding-system
+                       (setq func (decode-coding-string func coding-system)))
+                   (push (lambda () (server-apply-and-print func applyargs proc))
+                         commands)
+                   (setq applyargs nil)
+                   (setq filepos nil)))
+
+                ;; -applyarg ARG:  Add an argument for later -apply.
+                ("-applyarg"
+                 (if use-current-frame
+                     (setq use-current-frame 'always))
+                 (let ((arg (pop args-left)))
+                   (if coding-system
+                       (setq arg (decode-coding-string arg coding-system)))
+                   (push arg applyargs)
+                   (setq filepos nil)))
+
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
                 ("-env"
                  (let ((var (pop args-left)))
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

sbaugh@catern.com writes:
> - Finally, a fourth approach is to teach emacsclient to be able to send
>   this arbitrary data to Emacs on its own.  Such as by adding --apply.
>   There are a bunch of designs for that, but all of them require
>   modifying emacsclient.

BTW, if this specific approach of --apply seems inelegant to you, I
could make a different design work.  As long as Lisp code gets direct
access to the arguments as strings, without needing escaping.

One person in the previous thread proposed making a
command-line-args-left equivalent for emacsclient.  If we did this, it
wouldn't require adding any new arguments to the emacsclient interface.

This could be called server-eval-args-left, so that --apply could be
done instead as:

emacsclient --eval
'(progn (apply func server-eval-args-left) (setq server-eval-args-left nil))'
arg1 arg2

I can do that if you prefer that, but it will require some more
significant changes to the internals (because currently server.el
processes -eval commands one at a time and doesn't have access to the
subsequent ones).

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 11:03:44 +0000 (UTC)
> Cc: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org,
> 	sbaugh@janestreet.com
> 
> The issue is not really with the desktop file.  It's a generic problem:

No, it isn't.  If it were, we'd have heard about it much sooner, and
not because of the desktop files.

What you are doing is representing a rare problem related to a niche
feature is if it were a general one, by inventing use cases to justify
that.  But if those use cases were important, people would have asked
for them long ago.  They didn't.  Why? because --eval already exists.

> > What about alternative solutions: use a shell script in the desktop
> > files, and delegate to that script to solve the problem with quoting?
> > Had anyone considered this strategy?  If not, why not?
> 
> Getting the quoting right is hard and complex, and even Emacs developers
> have failed at it over multiple iterations, and when they fail it either
> breaks or exposes a security vulnerability.

Emacs developers make mistakes even in the simple regexps we have in
our code.  That doesn't mean we should abandon regexps.  The solution
for sending Lisp forms to the server exists, and the quoting, although
tricky in some cases, is not rocket science to get right.  I don't see
why we would need another mechanism to do something similar with
radically different syntax, a separate set of rules and restrictions
that need to be documented, etc. etc.

> This solution is far simpler

That's an illusion.  There's nothing simple about it.  You are
inventing a new mechanism for passing Lisp forms as something other
than Lisp.  This has got to have issues into which we will bump sooner
or later.  E.g., assume that two or more of the arguments to the
function begins with single quote, as in

  $ emacsclient --apply func arg1 'foo arg2 'bar

Escape-quoting, here we come again!

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Spencer Baugh]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> From: sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 11:03:44 +0000 (UTC)
>> Cc: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org,
>> 	sbaugh@janestreet.com
>> 
>> The issue is not really with the desktop file.  It's a generic problem:
>
> No, it isn't.  If it were, we'd have heard about it much sooner, and
> not because of the desktop files.
>
> What you are doing is representing a rare problem related to a niche
> feature is if it were a general one, by inventing use cases to justify
> that.  But if those use cases were important, people would have asked
> for them long ago.  They didn't.  Why? because --eval already exists.

No... these are real use cases that I personally have.  I have really
wanted this for a long time.  As I said in my original email, "I expect
this to also be useful in other places; the need to escape arbitrary
inputs before passing them to emacsclient is frequently annoying."

- I've wanted the ability to pass arbitrary data to Emacs through
  emacsclient since at least 2016, for other reasons:
  https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2016-06/msg00051.html

- The fact that there is currently advice in org-protocol to implement
  this behavior means there are people who want it.  I'm sure the
  org-protocol authors really wanted to be able to avoid that advice,
  back when they developed it in 2009.  They didn't bother contributing
  a solution upstream back then, but why stop it from happening now?

- It would allow lazy loading of org-protocol as desired by the org devs
  https://list.orgmode.org/strc07$3o0$1@ciao.gmane.io

- I'm working on a package which allows using Emacs to do
  completing-read over arbitrary strings passed in from the command
  line, as a replacement for the popular terminal software fzf.  Since
  this is completion over arbitrary strings, I need the ability to get
  those arbitrary strings into Emacs.

- There are numerous examples on the web of users trying and failing to
  get the quoting right to pass arguments to emacsclient; for example

  https://www.reddit.com/r/emacs/comments/hhbcg7/emacsclient_eval_with_command_line_arguments/
  this would become
  emacsclient --apply switch-to-buffer

  https://stackoverflow.com/questions/8848819/emacs-eval-ediff-1-2-how-to-put-this-line-in-to-shell-script
  this would become
  emacsclient --apply ediff

  No shell complexities required in either case.

>> > What about alternative solutions: use a shell script in the desktop
>> > files, and delegate to that script to solve the problem with quoting?
>> > Had anyone considered this strategy?  If not, why not?
>> 
>> Getting the quoting right is hard and complex, and even Emacs developers
>> have failed at it over multiple iterations, and when they fail it either
>> breaks or exposes a security vulnerability.
>
> Emacs developers make mistakes even in the simple regexps we have in
> our code.  That doesn't mean we should abandon regexps.  The solution
> for sending Lisp forms to the server exists, and the quoting, although
> tricky in some cases, is not rocket science to get right.

I think this (the current contents of emacsclient-mail.desktop):
sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec
emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval
\\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u

is in fact rocket science, and rocket science that needs to be repeated
by every user who wants to pass arbitrary strings to Emacs.

And keep in mind this mass of escaping *is currently broken*.

> I don't see
> why we would need another mechanism to do something similar with
> radically different syntax, a separate set of rules and restrictions
> that need to be documented, etc. etc.
>
>> This solution is far simpler
>
> That's an illusion.  There's nothing simple about it.  You are
> inventing a new mechanism for passing Lisp forms as something other
> than Lisp.

But I don't want to pass Lisp forms, that's the entire point.  I have
some arbitrary string which is *not* Lisp, and I want Emacs to *not*
parse it as Lisp.

> This has got to have issues into which we will bump sooner
> or later.  E.g., assume that two or more of the arguments to the
> function begins with single quote, as in
>
>   $ emacsclient --apply func arg1 'foo arg2 'bar
>
> Escape-quoting, here we come again!

That example works fine with --apply.  The call becomes:
(func "arg1" "'foo" "arg2" "'bar")
which is reliable and expected.

Maybe you're referring to how, if you run that command through a shell,
the shell interprets the single quotes as creating a string?  But that's
that's a separate issue, because:

- I don't plan to run any of my commands using --apply through a shell
  (which means they will require zero escaping or quoting whatsoever)

- Right now with --eval you have to do escaping for both the shell and
  Lisp.  With --apply you only have to do escaping for the shell, if you
  do use a shell, and if you don't use a shell you don't have to do
  anything.

I think it is simpler to reduce the amount of quoting and escaping from
"both Lisp and shell" to "just shell, and not even that if you don't use
a shell".

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>
> Cc: sbaugh@catern.com,  jporterbugs@gmail.com,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 10:04:48 -0400
> 
> Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
> 
> > What you are doing is representing a rare problem related to a niche
> > feature is if it were a general one, by inventing use cases to justify
> > that.  But if those use cases were important, people would have asked
> > for them long ago.  They didn't.  Why? because --eval already exists.
> 
> No... these are real use cases that I personally have.  I have really
> wanted this for a long time.  As I said in my original email, "I expect
> this to also be useful in other places; the need to escape arbitrary
> inputs before passing them to emacsclient is frequently annoying."

Maybe it's annoying, but it can be done.  And Emacs has the same
feature, btw.

> > Emacs developers make mistakes even in the simple regexps we have in
> > our code.  That doesn't mean we should abandon regexps.  The solution
> > for sending Lisp forms to the server exists, and the quoting, although
> > tricky in some cases, is not rocket science to get right.
> 
> I think this (the current contents of emacsclient-mail.desktop):
> sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec
> emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval
> \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
> 
> is in fact rocket science, and rocket science that needs to be repeated
> by every user who wants to pass arbitrary strings to Emacs.

We disagree.


> And keep in mind this mass of escaping *is currently broken*.

Patches to fix it are welcome, although as I said I'd be quite glad to
remove these desktop files from our repository.

> > That's an illusion.  There's nothing simple about it.  You are
> > inventing a new mechanism for passing Lisp forms as something other
> > than Lisp.
> 
> But I don't want to pass Lisp forms, that's the entire point.  I have
> some arbitrary string which is *not* Lisp, and I want Emacs to *not*
> parse it as Lisp.

It becomes Lisp when the server executes the request.

> >   $ emacsclient --apply func arg1 'foo arg2 'bar
> >
> > Escape-quoting, here we come again!
> 
> That example works fine with --apply.  The call becomes:
> (func "arg1" "'foo" "arg2" "'bar")
> which is reliable and expected.
> 
> Maybe you're referring to how, if you run that command through a shell,
> the shell interprets the single quotes as creating a string?

Of course, I am!

> But that's that's a separate issue, because:
> 
> - I don't plan to run any of my commands using --apply through a shell
>   (which means they will require zero escaping or quoting whatsoever)

This feature, if it will be added, is not just for you, it's for
everyone.  And emacsclient is a shell command, so invoking it from the
shell is both natural and frequently used.

> - Right now with --eval you have to do escaping for both the shell and
>   Lisp.  With --apply you only have to do escaping for the shell, if you
>   do use a shell, and if you don't use a shell you don't have to do
>   anything.

But we do that for Emacs, and do it quite a lot.

> I think it is simpler to reduce the amount of quoting and escaping from
> "both Lisp and shell" to "just shell, and not even that if you don't use
> a shell".

At what cost?  The cost of adding yet another protocol for passing
Lisp forms to the server is just too high for my palate.

Bottom line: the escaping issue doesn't seem to me a reason strong
enough to justify adding such a new feature.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Jim Porter]

On 9/14/2023 6:36 AM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
>> From: sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 11:03:44 +0000 (UTC)
>> Cc: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org,
>> 	sbaugh@janestreet.com
>>
>> The issue is not really with the desktop file.  It's a generic problem:
> 
> No, it isn't.  If it were, we'd have heard about it much sooner, and
> not because of the desktop files.

This actually *has* come up before, but in Org. "org-protocol.el" tries 
to solves a similar use case (use emacsclient to open an "org-protocol:" 
URL, which calls some Org-mode function). The code for this integration 
is quite complex though, and relies on advising 'server-visit-files' 
(see the code around 'org--protocol-detect-protocol-server' in 
lisp/org/org-protocol.el).

Overall, the Org solution works, though it's hacky, and hooks into 
things a bit too late, so Org has to do extra work to clean up the 
arguments it receives. For example, on MS-Windows[1], instead of seeing 
the original "org-protocol:/..." string that gets passed to emacsclient, 
Org sees something like "c:/WINDOWS/system32/org-protocol:/...". Org 
works around this problem, but it would be nice if there were a way to 
hook into things earlier before the input arguments had been munged.

There have been a few reports/complaints about how this works on the Org 
list in the past, too.

I'm not married to any particular implementation for this problem, but 
given how this has come up for multiple cases (admittedly both for 
handling URLs of some form), I think there's value in considering a 
common way to handle this that's more straightforward than shell 
scripting or org-protocol's advice hacks.

[1] This is also an example of how the problem isn't *just* with desktop 
files, since MS-Windows doesn't use those; instead, you have to set some 
registry keys. Otherwise, the problems are pretty similar to desktop 
files though.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 12:16:17 -0700
> Cc: sbaugh@janestreet.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> From: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>
> 
> [1] This is also an example of how the problem isn't *just* with desktop 
> files, since MS-Windows doesn't use those; instead, you have to set some 
> registry keys. Otherwise, the problems are pretty similar to desktop 
> files though.

No, it isn't: on Windows you configure all kinds of desktop shortcuts
to invoke Emacs or emacsclient, and those shortcuts allow you to
include %x style parameters inside quotes.  In addition, there's no
need to use the "sh -c COMMAND" style of invoking commands.  So most
of the quoting issues mentioned here as the main reason for the change
don't arise at all.

But my problem is not with solving the Windows case, so let's drop
this tangent.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Björn Bidar via Bug reports for GNU Emacs, the Swiss army knife of text editors]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 12:33:01 -0700
>> Cc: sbaugh@catern.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> From: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>
>> 
>> On 9/13/2023 12:13 PM, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
>> > And I don't understand why we need to add any options to Emacs itself,
>> > btw.  The suggestion to have some "symmetry" here was one of the
>> > reasons that discussion got nowhere.  So let's learn from that
>> > mistake, at least.
>> 
>> There's a practical benefit to this. If you have $EDITOR set in your 
>> environment to something like "emacsclient --alternate-editor=emacs", 
>> then it would be nice if you could say this:
>> 
>>    $EDITOR --apply some-func arg1 arg2
>> 
>> and have it do the same thing whether or not there was already an Emacs 
>> server running. The symmetry between the two commands (plus proper 
>> argument forwarding) would make that work.
>> 
>> However, if people can't agree, then we could probably drop that part. 
>> To me, it sounds like people *do* agree that this would be good to have 
>> though.
>
> People might agree, but I don't.  Please consider the perspective.
> This started as an obscure and rare problem in a desktop file (which
> we provided solely out of good will, since it really isn't our job to
> do so, it's the job of downstream distros).

Programs ship their own desktop files. It is not the job of the
downstream to provide desktop files unless it is because of a patch from
said downstream.

In any case it doesn't make sense for each downstream to ship their own
desktop file and fix their own.

From my pov letting Emacs do all work in passing arguments is the best
solution as escaping is error prone. I haven't seen any program besides
Emacs using escaped shell syntax to pass the escaped syntax of their
target language. Most just have options to pass the target file or deal
with the dbus activation/interface.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Björn Bidar <bjorn.bidar@thaodan.de>
> Cc: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org,
>   sbaugh@janestreet.com,  sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Sat, 16 Sep 2023 16:43:20 +0300
> 
> Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
> 
> > People might agree, but I don't.  Please consider the perspective.
> > This started as an obscure and rare problem in a desktop file (which
> > we provided solely out of good will, since it really isn't our job to
> > do so, it's the job of downstream distros).
> 
> Programs ship their own desktop files.

Programs are shipped by distros.  Emacs as a project does not ship
anything, we just release the sources in a form that makes building
Emacs easy.  Our source tarballs cannot be installed, so they are not
a finished, ready-to-use product.  Distros, by contrast, do ship
programs ready to be used.

> It is not the job of the downstream to provide desktop files unless
> it is because of a patch from said downstream.
> 
> In any case it doesn't make sense for each downstream to ship their own
> desktop file and fix their own.

I disagree.  Desktop files are specific to the target OS, but Emacs as
the project does not target any specific OS (although there are OSes
that we treat more favorably when considering features).  The know-how
about what exactly is needed for the desktop integration is also
something that the distros have and we don't, except by chance.

Each distro targets a single OS, and so it is reasonable to expect
them to arrange for the necessary desktop integration.  For example,
no one would expect us to provide desktop shortcuts for MS-Windows,
except as a sign of good will and when we have the necessary expertise
on board.

> >From my pov letting Emacs do all work in passing arguments is the best
> solution as escaping is error prone. I haven't seen any program besides
> Emacs using escaped shell syntax to pass the escaped syntax of their
> target language. Most just have options to pass the target file or deal
> with the dbus activation/interface.

We don't require any escapes except those needed by Lisp.

Note that in this case, at least some of the escapes are because the
desktop shortcut invokes emacsclient via "sh -c "COMMAND STRING",
something that should be considered an Emacs problem or a problem we
must solve.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Björn Bidar via Bug reports for GNU Emacs, the Swiss army knife of text editors]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> From: Björn Bidar <bjorn.bidar@thaodan.de>
>> Cc: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org,
>>   sbaugh@janestreet.com,  sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Sat, 16 Sep 2023 16:43:20 +0300
>> 
>> Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
>> 
>> > People might agree, but I don't.  Please consider the perspective.
>> > This started as an obscure and rare problem in a desktop file (which
>> > we provided solely out of good will, since it really isn't our job to
>> > do so, it's the job of downstream distros).
>> 
>> Programs ship their own desktop files.
>
> Programs are shipped by distros.  Emacs as a project does not ship
> anything, we just release the sources in a form that makes building
> Emacs easy.  Our source tarballs cannot be installed, so they are not
> a finished, ready-to-use product.  Distros, by contrast, do ship
> programs ready to be used.
>

Ship source or programs the difference is in semantics.

>> It is not the job of the downstream to provide desktop files unless
>> it is because of a patch from said downstream.
>> 
>> In any case it doesn't make sense for each downstream to ship their own
>> desktop file and fix their own.
>
> I disagree.  Desktop files are specific to the target OS, but Emacs as
> the project does not target any specific OS (although there are OSes
> that we treat more favorably when considering features).  The know-how
> about what exactly is needed for the desktop integration is also
> something that the distros have and we don't, except by chance.

Emacs contains many files specific to operating system or shared by
operating systems (in the case of desktop files mostly about different Linux
distributions that share 90% of their specific attributes).

But again it's about semantics, if it really was about not having any
operating specific parts in Emacs than why is there Windows or macOS
specific functions in Emacs.

> Each distro targets a single OS, and so it is reasonable to expect
> them to arrange for the necessary desktop integration.  For example,
> no one would expect us to provide desktop shortcuts for MS-Windows,
> except as a sign of good will and when we have the necessary expertise
> on board.

Emacs has operating specific code, for Windows or macOS even in low
level interfaces and not just lisp code or accessories such as desktop shortcuts.

Each distribution complies with XDG, all desktop file are XDG compliant.
Emacs has desktop files that work with all distributions be it Linux or BSD.

>> >From my pov letting Emacs do all work in passing arguments is the best
>> solution as escaping is error prone. I haven't seen any program besides
>> Emacs using escaped shell syntax to pass the escaped syntax of their
>> target language. Most just have options to pass the target file or deal
>> with the dbus activation/interface.
>
> We don't require any escapes except those needed by Lisp.
>
> Note that in this case, at least some of the escapes are because the
> desktop shortcut invokes emacsclient via "sh -c "COMMAND STRING",
> something that should be considered an Emacs problem or a problem we
> must solve.

I agree. In the desktop files it is assumed that X11 is used (check for
DISPLAY variable to be set) which breaks (native) Wayland usage, but
that is another issue.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 14:48:14 +0000 (UTC)
> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
> Cc: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>, jporterbugs@gmail.com,
> 	65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> 
> Okay, if I do this without making modifications to emacsclient.c or the server protocol, would that be
> more acceptable? The approach I described in another email, with server-eval-args-left, all it adds is
> a new variable.

I cannot find the description of that approach.  What did it say?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Spencer Baugh]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
>> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 14:48:14 +0000 (UTC)
>> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
>> Cc: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>, jporterbugs@gmail.com,
>> 	65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> 
>> Okay, if I do this without making modifications to emacsclient.c or the server protocol, would that be
>> more acceptable? The approach I described in another email, with server-eval-args-left, all it adds is
>> a new variable.
>
> I cannot find the description of that approach.  What did it say?

We could make a command-line-args-left equivalent for emacsclient,
called server-eval-args-left, which contains the FILE arguments passed
to emacsclient as strings.  This can be done without making any changes
to emacsclient.c or the server protocol.  Then the message-mailto
use case would look like this:

emacsclient --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u

This would match how message-mailto uses (pop command-line-args-left)
internally.

This would work for all the use-cases I described before; I'd be very
happy with this solution (actually, I'm starting to prefer it to
--apply).  And again, it doesn't change emacsclient.c or the server
protocol.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>
> Cc: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org,
>    jporterbugs@gmail.com
> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 11:10:44 -0400
> 
> We could make a command-line-args-left equivalent for emacsclient,
> called server-eval-args-left, which contains the FILE arguments passed
> to emacsclient as strings.  This can be done without making any changes
> to emacsclient.c or the server protocol.  Then the message-mailto
> use case would look like this:
> 
> emacsclient --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
> 
> This would match how message-mailto uses (pop command-line-args-left)
> internally.
> 
> This would work for all the use-cases I described before; I'd be very
> happy with this solution (actually, I'm starting to prefer it to
> --apply).  And again, it doesn't change emacsclient.c or the server
> protocol.

This could perhaps be acceptable (although it's still rather kludgey,
IMO), but are you sure you understand all the consequences?
Currently, when emacsclient is invoked like this:

  $ emacsclient --eval '(func args)' foo bar

we send to the server the following commands:

  -eval (func args)
  -eval foo
  -eval bar

IOW, every command-line argument after --eval is treated as being
implicitly preceded with --eval.

With your proposal, how will the server know that some of "-eval foo"
commands should cause foo to be added to server-eval-args-left instead
of being evaluated as it does now?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1598 bytes --]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
>> From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>
>> Cc: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org,
>>    jporterbugs@gmail.com
>> Date: Thu, 14 Sep 2023 11:10:44 -0400
>> 
>> We could make a command-line-args-left equivalent for emacsclient,
>> called server-eval-args-left, which contains the FILE arguments passed
>> to emacsclient as strings.  This can be done without making any changes
>> to emacsclient.c or the server protocol.  Then the message-mailto
>> use case would look like this:
>> 
>> emacsclient --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
>> 
>> This would match how message-mailto uses (pop command-line-args-left)
>> internally.
>> 
>> This would work for all the use-cases I described before; I'd be very
>> happy with this solution (actually, I'm starting to prefer it to
>> --apply).  And again, it doesn't change emacsclient.c or the server
>> protocol.
>
> This could perhaps be acceptable (although it's still rather kludgey,
> IMO), but are you sure you understand all the consequences?
> Currently, when emacsclient is invoked like this:
>
>   $ emacsclient --eval '(func args)' foo bar
>
> we send to the server the following commands:
>
>   -eval (func args)
>   -eval foo
>   -eval bar
>
> IOW, every command-line argument after --eval is treated as being
> implicitly preceded with --eval.
>
> With your proposal, how will the server know that some of "-eval foo"
> commands should cause foo to be added to server-eval-args-left instead
> of being evaluated as it does now?

As in the attached patch.


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-server-eval-args-left-to-server.el.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 5866 bytes --]

From 1f0ff370a23eee1fdf740527efa75c0ddbe625bb Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2023 21:35:50 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add server-eval-args-left to server.el

Passing arbitrary arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval
requires complicated escaping to avoid them being parsed as Lisp (as
seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).

This new variable server-eval-args-left allows access to the arguments
before they are parsed as Lisp.  By removing arguments from the
variable before they're parsed, a snippet of Lisp can consume
arguments, as in emacsclient-mail.desktop.

org-protocol might be able to use this as well, which might allow it
to drop its current advice on server-visit-files.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use server-eval-args-left. (bug#65902)
* lisp/server.el (server-eval-args-left): Add.
(server-process-filter, server-execute): Make -eval arguments
available through server-eval-args-left.
---
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  7 ++-----
 lisp/server.el               | 21 +++++++++++++--------
 2 files changed, 15 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-)

diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..5962fa1764c 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,7 +13,7 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index c3325e5a24c..6eff6ebe140 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -1165,7 +1165,7 @@ server-process-filter
     (when prev
       (setq string (concat prev string))
       (process-put proc 'previous-string nil)))
-  (condition-case err
+  (condition-case-unless-debug err
       (progn
 	(server-add-client proc)
 	;; Send our pid
@@ -1189,6 +1189,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		parent-id  ; Window ID for XEmbed
 		dontkill   ; t if client should not be killed.
 		commands
+		evalexprs
 		dir
 		use-current-frame
 		frame-parameters  ;parameters for newly created frame
@@ -1319,8 +1320,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((expr (pop args-left)))
                    (if coding-system
                        (setq expr (decode-coding-string expr coding-system)))
-                   (push (lambda () (server-eval-and-print expr proc))
-                         commands)
+                   (push expr evalexprs)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
@@ -1345,7 +1345,7 @@ server-process-filter
 	    ;; arguments, use an existing frame.
 	    (and nowait
 		 (not (eq tty-name 'window-system))
-		 (or files commands)
+		 (or files commands evalexprs)
 		 (setq use-current-frame t))
 
 	    (setq frame
@@ -1394,7 +1394,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((default-directory
                          (if (and dir (file-directory-p dir))
                              dir default-directory)))
-                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands
+                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands evalexprs
                                    dontkill frame tty-name)))))
 
             (when (or frame files)
@@ -1404,22 +1404,27 @@ server-process-filter
     ;; condition-case
     (t (server-return-error proc err))))
 
-(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands dontkill frame tty-name)
+(defvar server-eval-args-left)
+
+(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands evalexprs dontkill frame tty-name)
   ;; This is run from timers and process-filters, i.e. "asynchronously".
   ;; But w.r.t the user, this is not really asynchronous since the timer
   ;; is run after 0s and the process-filter is run in response to the
   ;; user running `emacsclient'.  So it is OK to override the
-  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `commands' (as well as
+  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `evalexprs' (as well as
   ;; find-file-noselect via the major-mode) can run arbitrary code,
   ;; including code that needs to wait.
   (with-local-quit
     (condition-case err
         (let ((buffers (server-visit-files files proc nowait)))
           (mapc 'funcall (nreverse commands))
+          (let ((server-eval-args-left (nreverse evalexprs)))
+            (while server-eval-args-left
+              (server-eval-and-print (pop server-eval-args-left) proc)))
 	  ;; If we were told only to open a new client, obey
 	  ;; `initial-buffer-choice' if it specifies a file
           ;; or a function.
-          (unless (or files commands)
+          (unless (or files commands evalexprs)
             (let ((buf
                    (cond ((stringp initial-buffer-choice)
 			  (find-file-noselect initial-buffer-choice))
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 01:36:47 +0000 (UTC)
> Cc: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>, jporterbugs@gmail.com,
> 	65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> 
> > Currently, when emacsclient is invoked like this:
> >
> >   $ emacsclient --eval '(func args)' foo bar
> >
> > we send to the server the following commands:
> >
> >   -eval (func args)
> >   -eval foo
> >   -eval bar
> >
> > IOW, every command-line argument after --eval is treated as being
> > implicitly preceded with --eval.
> >
> > With your proposal, how will the server know that some of "-eval foo"
> > commands should cause foo to be added to server-eval-args-left instead
> > of being evaluated as it does now?
> 
> As in the attached patch.

I wish you'd accompanied the patch with some plain-text description of
the idea, to make it easier to understand and to avoid unnecessary
misunderstandings.

IIUC, this kind of solution is fine by me, but the protocol of
accessing and using server-eval-args-left in the Lisp expressions
specified on the emacsclient command line should be well-documented to
avoid any confusion and UB.

Also, the patch includes an unrelated change:

> --- a/lisp/server.el
> +++ b/lisp/server.el
> @@ -1165,7 +1165,7 @@ server-process-filter
>      (when prev
>        (setq string (concat prev string))
>        (process-put proc 'previous-string nil)))
> -  (condition-case err
> +  (condition-case-unless-debug err

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1769 bytes --]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> From: sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 01:36:47 +0000 (UTC)
>> Cc: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>, jporterbugs@gmail.com,
>> 	65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> 
>> > Currently, when emacsclient is invoked like this:
>> >
>> >   $ emacsclient --eval '(func args)' foo bar
>> >
>> > we send to the server the following commands:
>> >
>> >   -eval (func args)
>> >   -eval foo
>> >   -eval bar
>> >
>> > IOW, every command-line argument after --eval is treated as being
>> > implicitly preceded with --eval.
>> >
>> > With your proposal, how will the server know that some of "-eval foo"
>> > commands should cause foo to be added to server-eval-args-left instead
>> > of being evaluated as it does now?
>> 
>> As in the attached patch.
>
> I wish you'd accompanied the patch with some plain-text description of
> the idea, to make it easier to understand and to avoid unnecessary
> misunderstandings.

Ah, well, the basic idea is that for each -eval request we receive in
the protocol, we accumulate the argument as a string into a single list
(instead of immediately turning it into a closure which calls
server-eval-and-print).  Then we let-bind server-eval-args-left to that
list around the calls to to server-eval-and-print, and consume each
argument from the list one by one.

> IIUC, this kind of solution is fine by me, but the protocol of
> accessing and using server-eval-args-left in the Lisp expressions
> specified on the emacsclient command line should be well-documented to
> avoid any confusion and UB.

Added a docstring and included it in NEWS.  I would have put it in the
manual, but it seems rather niche to put in the Emacs manual and I
didn't see a natural place to put it in the Emacs Lisp manual.


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-server-eval-args-left-to-server.el.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 7851 bytes --]

From cf7fcda1374491cc73a751d5636f36a95b2e8669 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2023 21:35:50 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add server-eval-args-left to server.el

Passing arbitrary arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval
requires complicated escaping to avoid them being parsed as Lisp (as
seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).

This new variable server-eval-args-left allows access to the arguments
before they are parsed as Lisp.  By removing arguments from the
variable before they're parsed, a snippet of Lisp can consume
arguments, as in emacsclient-mail.desktop.

org-protocol might be able to use this as well, which might allow it
to drop its current advice on server-visit-files.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use server-eval-args-left. (bug#65902)
* lisp/server.el (server-eval-args-left): Add.
(server-process-filter, server-execute): Make -eval arguments
available through server-eval-args-left.
* lisp/startup.el (argv): Mention server-eval-args-left in docstring.
* etc/NEWS: Announce server-eval-args-left.
---
 etc/NEWS                     | 10 ++++++++++
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  7 ++-----
 lisp/server.el               | 35 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++-------
 lisp/startup.el              |  5 ++++-
 4 files changed, 44 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-)

diff --git a/etc/NEWS b/etc/NEWS
index cd4c414a64c..de1d79fcb98 100644
--- a/etc/NEWS
+++ b/etc/NEWS
@@ -121,6 +121,16 @@ Anything following the symbol 'mode-line-format-right-align' in
 right-aligned to is controlled by the new user option
 'mode-line-right-align-edge'.
 
+** Emacs Server and Client
+
+---
+*** 'server-eval-args-left' can be used to pop subsequent eval args
+When '--eval' is passed to emacsclient and Emacs is evaluating each
+argument, this variable is set to those which have not yet been
+evaluated.  It can be used to 'pop' arguments to prevent them from
+being evaluated, which is useful when those arguments contain
+arbitrary data.
+
 \f
 * Editing Changes in Emacs 30.1
 
diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..5962fa1764c 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,7 +13,7 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index c3325e5a24c..65f28cdea23 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -1189,6 +1189,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		parent-id  ; Window ID for XEmbed
 		dontkill   ; t if client should not be killed.
 		commands
+		evalexprs
 		dir
 		use-current-frame
 		frame-parameters  ;parameters for newly created frame
@@ -1319,8 +1320,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((expr (pop args-left)))
                    (if coding-system
                        (setq expr (decode-coding-string expr coding-system)))
-                   (push (lambda () (server-eval-and-print expr proc))
-                         commands)
+                   (push expr evalexprs)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
@@ -1345,7 +1345,7 @@ server-process-filter
 	    ;; arguments, use an existing frame.
 	    (and nowait
 		 (not (eq tty-name 'window-system))
-		 (or files commands)
+		 (or files commands evalexprs)
 		 (setq use-current-frame t))
 
 	    (setq frame
@@ -1394,7 +1394,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((default-directory
                          (if (and dir (file-directory-p dir))
                              dir default-directory)))
-                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands
+                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands evalexprs
                                    dontkill frame tty-name)))))
 
             (when (or frame files)
@@ -1404,22 +1404,43 @@ server-process-filter
     ;; condition-case
     (t (server-return-error proc err))))
 
-(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands dontkill frame tty-name)
+(defvar server-eval-args-left nil
+  "List of eval args not yet processed.
+
+When the server receives a request to eval one or more strings,
+it stores them in this variable.  Then, until this variable is
+nil, it `pop's a string from this variable and evaluates it with
+`server-eval-and-print'.  Adding or removing strings from this
+variable during this process will affect what is evaluated.
+
+This allows an expression passed to \"emacsclient --eval\" to
+consume one or more subsequent arguments before they're parsed or
+evaluated, with (pop server-eval-args-left).  This is useful if
+those arguments are arbitrary strings which should not be
+evaluated.
+
+See also `command-line-args-left' for a similar variable which
+works for command line invocations of \"emacs\".")
+
+(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands evalexprs dontkill frame tty-name)
   ;; This is run from timers and process-filters, i.e. "asynchronously".
   ;; But w.r.t the user, this is not really asynchronous since the timer
   ;; is run after 0s and the process-filter is run in response to the
   ;; user running `emacsclient'.  So it is OK to override the
-  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `commands' (as well as
+  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `evalexprs' (as well as
   ;; find-file-noselect via the major-mode) can run arbitrary code,
   ;; including code that needs to wait.
   (with-local-quit
     (condition-case err
         (let ((buffers (server-visit-files files proc nowait)))
           (mapc 'funcall (nreverse commands))
+          (let ((server-eval-args-left (nreverse evalexprs)))
+            (while server-eval-args-left
+              (server-eval-and-print (pop server-eval-args-left) proc)))
 	  ;; If we were told only to open a new client, obey
 	  ;; `initial-buffer-choice' if it specifies a file
           ;; or a function.
-          (unless (or files commands)
+          (unless (or files commands evalexprs)
             (let ((buf
                    (cond ((stringp initial-buffer-choice)
 			  (find-file-noselect initial-buffer-choice))
diff --git a/lisp/startup.el b/lisp/startup.el
index 7f601668369..f2c84751211 100644
--- a/lisp/startup.el
+++ b/lisp/startup.el
@@ -120,7 +120,10 @@ command-switch-alist
     "List of command-line args not yet processed.
 This is a convenience alias, so that one can write (pop argv)
 inside of --eval command line arguments in order to access
-following arguments."))
+following arguments.
+
+See also `server-eval-args-left' for a similar variable which
+works for invocations of \"emacsclient --eval\"."))
 (internal-make-var-non-special 'argv)
 
 (defvar command-line-args-left nil
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Sat, 23 Sep 2023 20:24:07 +0000 (UTC)
> Cc: 65902@debbugs.gnu.org, sbaugh@janestreet.com, jporterbugs@gmail.com
> 
> > IIUC, this kind of solution is fine by me, but the protocol of
> > accessing and using server-eval-args-left in the Lisp expressions
> > specified on the emacsclient command line should be well-documented to
> > avoid any confusion and UB.
> 
> Added a docstring and included it in NEWS.  I would have put it in the
> manual, but it seems rather niche to put in the Emacs manual and I
> didn't see a natural place to put it in the Emacs Lisp manual.

The natural place is in the Emacs user manual, in "emacsclient
Options", where --eval is described.  Where else?

> Passing arbitrary arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval
> requires complicated escaping to avoid them being parsed as Lisp (as
> seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).
> 
> This new variable server-eval-args-left allows access to the arguments
> before they are parsed as Lisp.  By removing arguments from the
> variable before they're parsed, a snippet of Lisp can consume
> arguments, as in emacsclient-mail.desktop.
> 
> org-protocol might be able to use this as well, which might allow it
> to drop its current advice on server-visit-files.

The right place to keep this information is in the manual and the doc
strings, not just in the Git commit log message.

> +(defvar server-eval-args-left nil
> +  "List of eval args not yet processed.
> +
> +When the server receives a request to eval one or more strings,
> +it stores them in this variable.  Then, until this variable is
> +nil, it `pop's a string from this variable and evaluates it with
> +`server-eval-and-print'.  Adding or removing strings from this
> +variable during this process will affect what is evaluated.

This describes the implementation rather than the intended usage.

> +This allows an expression passed to \"emacsclient --eval\" to
> +consume one or more subsequent arguments before they're parsed or
> +evaluated, with (pop server-eval-args-left).  This is useful if
> +those arguments are arbitrary strings which should not be
> +evaluated.

This describes a way of using this, but without the important part:
that any processed argument _must_ be popped, or it will be evaluated
again.  See the doc string of command-line-functions for what I have
in mind.

All in all, I think this should be rewritten in terms of how to use
this, and the result moved to the Emacs manual, leaving just the
minimum here.

> +See also `command-line-args-left' for a similar variable which
> +works for command line invocations of \"emacs\".")

This "see also" is not useful, because the doc string of
command-line-args-left is minimal and doesn't add any information
(which is okay, since that variable is basically meant for internal
Emacs handling of command-line arguments, unlike this one).

> --- a/lisp/startup.el
> +++ b/lisp/startup.el
> @@ -120,7 +120,10 @@ command-switch-alist
>      "List of command-line args not yet processed.
>  This is a convenience alias, so that one can write (pop argv)
>  inside of --eval command line arguments in order to access
> -following arguments."))
> +following arguments.
> +
> +See also `server-eval-args-left' for a similar variable which
> +works for invocations of \"emacsclient --eval\"."))

And neither is this, because the use cases of the two variables are
almost completely unrelated.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 4293 bytes --]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> From: sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Sat, 23 Sep 2023 20:24:07 +0000 (UTC)
>> Cc: 65902@debbugs.gnu.org, sbaugh@janestreet.com, jporterbugs@gmail.com
>> 
>> > IIUC, this kind of solution is fine by me, but the protocol of
>> > accessing and using server-eval-args-left in the Lisp expressions
>> > specified on the emacsclient command line should be well-documented to
>> > avoid any confusion and UB.
>> 
>> Added a docstring and included it in NEWS.  I would have put it in the
>> manual, but it seems rather niche to put in the Emacs manual and I
>> didn't see a natural place to put it in the Emacs Lisp manual.
>
> The natural place is in the Emacs user manual, in "emacsclient
> Options", where --eval is described.  Where else?

Ah true, obvious, I added it there.

>> Passing arbitrary arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval
>> requires complicated escaping to avoid them being parsed as Lisp (as
>> seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).
>> 
>> This new variable server-eval-args-left allows access to the arguments
>> before they are parsed as Lisp.  By removing arguments from the
>> variable before they're parsed, a snippet of Lisp can consume
>> arguments, as in emacsclient-mail.desktop.
>> 
>> org-protocol might be able to use this as well, which might allow it
>> to drop its current advice on server-visit-files.
>
> The right place to keep this information is in the manual and the doc
> strings, not just in the Git commit log message.

Done.

>> +(defvar server-eval-args-left nil
>> +  "List of eval args not yet processed.
>> +
>> +When the server receives a request to eval one or more strings,
>> +it stores them in this variable.  Then, until this variable is
>> +nil, it `pop's a string from this variable and evaluates it with
>> +`server-eval-and-print'.  Adding or removing strings from this
>> +variable during this process will affect what is evaluated.
>
> This describes the implementation rather than the intended usage.

Fixed.

>> +This allows an expression passed to \"emacsclient --eval\" to
>> +consume one or more subsequent arguments before they're parsed or
>> +evaluated, with (pop server-eval-args-left).  This is useful if
>> +those arguments are arbitrary strings which should not be
>> +evaluated.
>
> This describes a way of using this, but without the important part:
> that any processed argument _must_ be popped, or it will be evaluated
> again.  See the doc string of command-line-functions for what I have
> in mind.
>
> All in all, I think this should be rewritten in terms of how to use
> this, and the result moved to the Emacs manual, leaving just the
> minimum here.

Done.

>> +See also `command-line-args-left' for a similar variable which
>> +works for command line invocations of \"emacs\".")
>
> This "see also" is not useful, because the doc string of
> command-line-args-left is minimal and doesn't add any information
> (which is okay, since that variable is basically meant for internal
> Emacs handling of command-line arguments, unlike this one).

Okay, fair, probably that should point at `argv' instead.

>> --- a/lisp/startup.el
>> +++ b/lisp/startup.el
>> @@ -120,7 +120,10 @@ command-switch-alist
>>      "List of command-line args not yet processed.
>>  This is a convenience alias, so that one can write (pop argv)
>>  inside of --eval command line arguments in order to access
>> -following arguments."))
>> +following arguments.
>> +
>> +See also `server-eval-args-left' for a similar variable which
>> +works for invocations of \"emacsclient --eval\"."))
>
> And neither is this, because the use cases of the two variables are
> almost completely unrelated.

The docstring of argv says:

This is a convenience alias, so that one can write (pop argv)
inside of --eval command line arguments in order to access
following arguments.

That is exactly the same way this new variable is used.

And in fact it's used for the exact same purpose in message-mailto.  The
reason "emacs" doesn't require complicated escaping is because
message-mailto does (pop command-line-args-left) internally.

I agree that argv/command-line-args-left has other use cases besides
this one.  But one of argv's use cases is the exact same use case of
server-eval-args-left.


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-server-eval-args-left-to-server.el.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 8438 bytes --]

From bd49b918e57363593660f605c3e0efc3d0155c2b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2023 21:35:50 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add server-eval-args-left to server.el

Passing arbitrary arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval
requires complicated escaping to avoid them being parsed as Lisp (as
seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).

This new variable server-eval-args-left allows access to the arguments
before they are parsed as Lisp.  By removing arguments from the
variable before they're parsed, a snippet of Lisp can consume
arguments, as in emacsclient-mail.desktop.

org-protocol might be able to use this as well, which might allow it
to drop its current advice on server-visit-files.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use server-eval-args-left. (bug#65902)
* lisp/server.el (server-eval-args-left): Add.
(server-process-filter, server-execute): Make -eval arguments
available through server-eval-args-left.
* lisp/startup.el (argv): Mention server-eval-args-left in docstring.
* etc/NEWS: Announce server-eval-args-left.
* doc/emacs/misc.texi (emacsclient Options): Document
server-eval-args-left.
---
 doc/emacs/misc.texi          |  9 +++++++++
 etc/NEWS                     | 10 ++++++++++
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  7 ++-----
 lisp/server.el               | 27 ++++++++++++++++++++-------
 lisp/startup.el              |  5 ++++-
 5 files changed, 45 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-)

diff --git a/doc/emacs/misc.texi b/doc/emacs/misc.texi
index 7a88b7ef5e0..1ce1713b01c 100644
--- a/doc/emacs/misc.texi
+++ b/doc/emacs/misc.texi
@@ -2078,6 +2078,15 @@ emacsclient Options
 @command{emacsclient} are interpreted as a list of expressions to
 evaluate, @emph{not} as a list of files to visit.
 
+@vindex server-eval-args-left
+If you have arbitrary data which you want to provide as input to one
+of your expressions, you can pass the data as another argument to
+@command{emacsclient} and use @var{server-eval-args-left} in the
+expression to access the data.  Be careful to have your expression
+remove the data from @var{server-eval-args-left} regardless of whether
+your code succeeds, such as by using @code{pop}, otherwise Emacs will
+attempt to evaluate the data as a Lisp expression.
+
 @item -f @var{server-file}
 @itemx --server-file=@var{server-file}
 Specify a server file (@pxref{TCP Emacs server}) for connecting to an
diff --git a/etc/NEWS b/etc/NEWS
index cd4c414a64c..de1d79fcb98 100644
--- a/etc/NEWS
+++ b/etc/NEWS
@@ -121,6 +121,16 @@ Anything following the symbol 'mode-line-format-right-align' in
 right-aligned to is controlled by the new user option
 'mode-line-right-align-edge'.
 
+** Emacs Server and Client
+
+---
+*** 'server-eval-args-left' can be used to pop subsequent eval args
+When '--eval' is passed to emacsclient and Emacs is evaluating each
+argument, this variable is set to those which have not yet been
+evaluated.  It can be used to 'pop' arguments to prevent them from
+being evaluated, which is useful when those arguments contain
+arbitrary data.
+
 \f
 * Editing Changes in Emacs 30.1
 
diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..5962fa1764c 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,7 +13,7 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index c3325e5a24c..3970d7a7e81 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -1189,6 +1189,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		parent-id  ; Window ID for XEmbed
 		dontkill   ; t if client should not be killed.
 		commands
+		evalexprs
 		dir
 		use-current-frame
 		frame-parameters  ;parameters for newly created frame
@@ -1319,8 +1320,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((expr (pop args-left)))
                    (if coding-system
                        (setq expr (decode-coding-string expr coding-system)))
-                   (push (lambda () (server-eval-and-print expr proc))
-                         commands)
+                   (push expr evalexprs)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
@@ -1345,7 +1345,7 @@ server-process-filter
 	    ;; arguments, use an existing frame.
 	    (and nowait
 		 (not (eq tty-name 'window-system))
-		 (or files commands)
+		 (or files commands evalexprs)
 		 (setq use-current-frame t))
 
 	    (setq frame
@@ -1394,7 +1394,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((default-directory
                          (if (and dir (file-directory-p dir))
                              dir default-directory)))
-                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands
+                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands evalexprs
                                    dontkill frame tty-name)))))
 
             (when (or frame files)
@@ -1404,22 +1404,35 @@ server-process-filter
     ;; condition-case
     (t (server-return-error proc err))))
 
-(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands dontkill frame tty-name)
+(defvar server-eval-args-left nil
+  "List of eval args not yet processed.
+
+Adding or removing strings from this variable while the Emacs
+server is processing a series of eval requests will affect what
+Emacs evaluates.
+
+See also `argv' for a similar variable which works for
+invocations of \"emacs\".")
+
+(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands evalexprs dontkill frame tty-name)
   ;; This is run from timers and process-filters, i.e. "asynchronously".
   ;; But w.r.t the user, this is not really asynchronous since the timer
   ;; is run after 0s and the process-filter is run in response to the
   ;; user running `emacsclient'.  So it is OK to override the
-  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `commands' (as well as
+  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `evalexprs' (as well as
   ;; find-file-noselect via the major-mode) can run arbitrary code,
   ;; including code that needs to wait.
   (with-local-quit
     (condition-case err
         (let ((buffers (server-visit-files files proc nowait)))
           (mapc 'funcall (nreverse commands))
+          (let ((server-eval-args-left (nreverse evalexprs)))
+            (while server-eval-args-left
+              (server-eval-and-print (pop server-eval-args-left) proc)))
 	  ;; If we were told only to open a new client, obey
 	  ;; `initial-buffer-choice' if it specifies a file
           ;; or a function.
-          (unless (or files commands)
+          (unless (or files commands evalexprs)
             (let ((buf
                    (cond ((stringp initial-buffer-choice)
 			  (find-file-noselect initial-buffer-choice))
diff --git a/lisp/startup.el b/lisp/startup.el
index 7f601668369..f2c84751211 100644
--- a/lisp/startup.el
+++ b/lisp/startup.el
@@ -120,7 +120,10 @@ command-switch-alist
     "List of command-line args not yet processed.
 This is a convenience alias, so that one can write (pop argv)
 inside of --eval command line arguments in order to access
-following arguments."))
+following arguments.
+
+See also `server-eval-args-left' for a similar variable which
+works for invocations of \"emacsclient --eval\"."))
 (internal-make-var-non-special 'argv)
 
 (defvar command-line-args-left nil
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

Any remaining concerns about this patch?  It would be nice to install
it.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Sat, 21 Oct 2023 15:20:13 +0000 (UTC)
> Cc: jporterbugs@gmail.com, sbaugh@janestreet.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> 
> 
> Any remaining concerns about this patch?  It would be nice to install
> it.

It no longer applies, so please rebase and repost.  TIA.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 346 bytes --]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> From: sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Sat, 21 Oct 2023 15:20:13 +0000 (UTC)
>> Cc: jporterbugs@gmail.com, sbaugh@janestreet.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> 
>> 
>> Any remaining concerns about this patch?  It would be nice to install
>> it.
>
> It no longer applies, so please rebase and repost.  TIA.

Rebased


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-server-eval-args-left-to-server.el.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 8438 bytes --]

From bd49b918e57363593660f605c3e0efc3d0155c2b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2023 21:35:50 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add server-eval-args-left to server.el

Passing arbitrary arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval
requires complicated escaping to avoid them being parsed as Lisp (as
seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).

This new variable server-eval-args-left allows access to the arguments
before they are parsed as Lisp.  By removing arguments from the
variable before they're parsed, a snippet of Lisp can consume
arguments, as in emacsclient-mail.desktop.

org-protocol might be able to use this as well, which might allow it
to drop its current advice on server-visit-files.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use server-eval-args-left. (bug#65902)
* lisp/server.el (server-eval-args-left): Add.
(server-process-filter, server-execute): Make -eval arguments
available through server-eval-args-left.
* lisp/startup.el (argv): Mention server-eval-args-left in docstring.
* etc/NEWS: Announce server-eval-args-left.
* doc/emacs/misc.texi (emacsclient Options): Document
server-eval-args-left.
---
 doc/emacs/misc.texi          |  9 +++++++++
 etc/NEWS                     | 10 ++++++++++
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  7 ++-----
 lisp/server.el               | 27 ++++++++++++++++++++-------
 lisp/startup.el              |  5 ++++-
 5 files changed, 45 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-)

diff --git a/doc/emacs/misc.texi b/doc/emacs/misc.texi
index 7a88b7ef5e0..1ce1713b01c 100644
--- a/doc/emacs/misc.texi
+++ b/doc/emacs/misc.texi
@@ -2078,6 +2078,15 @@ emacsclient Options
 @command{emacsclient} are interpreted as a list of expressions to
 evaluate, @emph{not} as a list of files to visit.
 
+@vindex server-eval-args-left
+If you have arbitrary data which you want to provide as input to one
+of your expressions, you can pass the data as another argument to
+@command{emacsclient} and use @var{server-eval-args-left} in the
+expression to access the data.  Be careful to have your expression
+remove the data from @var{server-eval-args-left} regardless of whether
+your code succeeds, such as by using @code{pop}, otherwise Emacs will
+attempt to evaluate the data as a Lisp expression.
+
 @item -f @var{server-file}
 @itemx --server-file=@var{server-file}
 Specify a server file (@pxref{TCP Emacs server}) for connecting to an
diff --git a/etc/NEWS b/etc/NEWS
index cd4c414a64c..de1d79fcb98 100644
--- a/etc/NEWS
+++ b/etc/NEWS
@@ -121,6 +121,16 @@ Anything following the symbol 'mode-line-format-right-align' in
 right-aligned to is controlled by the new user option
 'mode-line-right-align-edge'.
 
+** Emacs Server and Client
+
+---
+*** 'server-eval-args-left' can be used to pop subsequent eval args
+When '--eval' is passed to emacsclient and Emacs is evaluating each
+argument, this variable is set to those which have not yet been
+evaluated.  It can be used to 'pop' arguments to prevent them from
+being evaluated, which is useful when those arguments contain
+arbitrary data.
+
 \f
 * Editing Changes in Emacs 30.1
 
diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..5962fa1764c 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,7 +13,7 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index c3325e5a24c..3970d7a7e81 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -1189,6 +1189,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		parent-id  ; Window ID for XEmbed
 		dontkill   ; t if client should not be killed.
 		commands
+		evalexprs
 		dir
 		use-current-frame
 		frame-parameters  ;parameters for newly created frame
@@ -1319,8 +1320,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((expr (pop args-left)))
                    (if coding-system
                        (setq expr (decode-coding-string expr coding-system)))
-                   (push (lambda () (server-eval-and-print expr proc))
-                         commands)
+                   (push expr evalexprs)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
@@ -1345,7 +1345,7 @@ server-process-filter
 	    ;; arguments, use an existing frame.
 	    (and nowait
 		 (not (eq tty-name 'window-system))
-		 (or files commands)
+		 (or files commands evalexprs)
 		 (setq use-current-frame t))
 
 	    (setq frame
@@ -1394,7 +1394,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((default-directory
                          (if (and dir (file-directory-p dir))
                              dir default-directory)))
-                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands
+                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands evalexprs
                                    dontkill frame tty-name)))))
 
             (when (or frame files)
@@ -1404,22 +1404,35 @@ server-process-filter
     ;; condition-case
     (t (server-return-error proc err))))
 
-(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands dontkill frame tty-name)
+(defvar server-eval-args-left nil
+  "List of eval args not yet processed.
+
+Adding or removing strings from this variable while the Emacs
+server is processing a series of eval requests will affect what
+Emacs evaluates.
+
+See also `argv' for a similar variable which works for
+invocations of \"emacs\".")
+
+(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands evalexprs dontkill frame tty-name)
   ;; This is run from timers and process-filters, i.e. "asynchronously".
   ;; But w.r.t the user, this is not really asynchronous since the timer
   ;; is run after 0s and the process-filter is run in response to the
   ;; user running `emacsclient'.  So it is OK to override the
-  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `commands' (as well as
+  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `evalexprs' (as well as
   ;; find-file-noselect via the major-mode) can run arbitrary code,
   ;; including code that needs to wait.
   (with-local-quit
     (condition-case err
         (let ((buffers (server-visit-files files proc nowait)))
           (mapc 'funcall (nreverse commands))
+          (let ((server-eval-args-left (nreverse evalexprs)))
+            (while server-eval-args-left
+              (server-eval-and-print (pop server-eval-args-left) proc)))
 	  ;; If we were told only to open a new client, obey
 	  ;; `initial-buffer-choice' if it specifies a file
           ;; or a function.
-          (unless (or files commands)
+          (unless (or files commands evalexprs)
             (let ((buf
                    (cond ((stringp initial-buffer-choice)
 			  (find-file-noselect initial-buffer-choice))
diff --git a/lisp/startup.el b/lisp/startup.el
index 7f601668369..f2c84751211 100644
--- a/lisp/startup.el
+++ b/lisp/startup.el
@@ -120,7 +120,10 @@ command-switch-alist
     "List of command-line args not yet processed.
 This is a convenience alias, so that one can write (pop argv)
 inside of --eval command line arguments in order to access
-following arguments."))
+following arguments.
+
+See also `server-eval-args-left' for a similar variable which
+works for invocations of \"emacsclient --eval\"."))
 (internal-make-var-non-special 'argv)
 
 (defvar command-line-args-left nil
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Andreas Schwab]

On Okt 22 2023, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:

> +Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u

This line is not valid according to the specs.

-- 
Andreas Schwab, schwab@linux-m68k.org
GPG Key fingerprint = 7578 EB47 D4E5 4D69 2510  2552 DF73 E780 A9DA AEC1
"And now for something completely different."

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org> writes:

> On Okt 22 2023, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
>
>> +Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
>
> This line is not valid according to the specs.

Is that because of the single quotes surrounding spaces?  Are quoted
strings not permitted?

Would the following be valid:

Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto)' %u

or perhaps

Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval (message-mailto) %u

That's easily achievable.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Andreas Schwab]

All of them contain unquoted occurences of reserved characters.

-- 
Andreas Schwab, schwab@linux-m68k.org
GPG Key fingerprint = 7578 EB47 D4E5 4D69 2510  2552 DF73 E780 A9DA AEC1
"And now for something completely different."

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Jim Porter]

On 10/22/2023 12:53 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
> Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org> writes:
> 
>> On Okt 22 2023, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
>>
>>> +Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
>>
>> This line is not valid according to the specs.
> 
> Is that because of the single quotes surrounding spaces?  Are quoted
> strings not permitted?

According to the spec[1], you should use double quotes instead:

> Quoting must be done by enclosing the argument between double quotes and escaping the double quote character, backtick character ("`"), dollar sign ("$") and backslash character ("\") by preceding it with an additional backslash character.

Otherwise, I think what you have above is ok.

[1] 
https://specifications.freedesktop.org/desktop-entry-spec/latest/ar01s07.html

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 940 bytes --]

Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com> writes:
> On 10/22/2023 12:53 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
>> Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org> writes:
>> 
>>> On Okt 22 2023, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
>>>
>>>> +Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u
>>>
>>> This line is not valid according to the specs.
>> Is that because of the single quotes surrounding spaces?  Are quoted
>> strings not permitted?
>
> According to the spec[1], you should use double quotes instead:
>
>> Quoting must be done by enclosing the argument between double quotes and escaping the double quote character, backtick character ("`"), dollar sign ("$") and backslash character ("\") by preceding it with an additional backslash character.
>
> Otherwise, I think what you have above is ok.
>
> [1]
> https://specifications.freedesktop.org/desktop-entry-spec/latest/ar01s07.html

Thanks.  OK, spec-compliant version:


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-server-eval-args-left-to-server.el.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 8466 bytes --]

From 59d780f3297134d97cd39a8a4b0fb722d3d42765 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Thu, 21 Sep 2023 21:35:50 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add server-eval-args-left to server.el

Passing arbitrary arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval
requires complicated escaping to avoid them being parsed as Lisp (as
seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).

This new variable server-eval-args-left allows access to the arguments
before they are parsed as Lisp.  By removing arguments from the
variable before they're parsed, a snippet of Lisp can consume
arguments, as in emacsclient-mail.desktop.

org-protocol might be able to use this as well, which might allow it
to drop its current advice on server-visit-files.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use server-eval-args-left. (bug#65902)
* lisp/server.el (server-eval-args-left): Add.
(server-process-filter, server-execute): Make -eval arguments
available through server-eval-args-left.
* lisp/startup.el (argv): Mention server-eval-args-left in docstring.
* etc/NEWS: Announce server-eval-args-left.
* doc/emacs/misc.texi (emacsclient Options): Document
server-eval-args-left.
---
 doc/emacs/misc.texi          |  9 +++++++++
 etc/NEWS                     | 10 ++++++++++
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  7 ++-----
 lisp/server.el               | 27 ++++++++++++++++++++-------
 lisp/startup.el              |  5 ++++-
 5 files changed, 45 insertions(+), 13 deletions(-)

diff --git a/doc/emacs/misc.texi b/doc/emacs/misc.texi
index d7168fa1ca0..9c7c5dcd5da 100644
--- a/doc/emacs/misc.texi
+++ b/doc/emacs/misc.texi
@@ -2078,6 +2078,15 @@ emacsclient Options
 @command{emacsclient} are interpreted as a list of expressions to
 evaluate, @emph{not} as a list of files to visit.
 
+@vindex server-eval-args-left
+If you have arbitrary data which you want to provide as input to one
+of your expressions, you can pass the data as another argument to
+@command{emacsclient} and use @var{server-eval-args-left} in the
+expression to access the data.  Be careful to have your expression
+remove the data from @var{server-eval-args-left} regardless of whether
+your code succeeds, such as by using @code{pop}, otherwise Emacs will
+attempt to evaluate the data as a Lisp expression.
+
 @item -f @var{server-file}
 @itemx --server-file=@var{server-file}
 Specify a server file (@pxref{TCP Emacs server}) for connecting to an
diff --git a/etc/NEWS b/etc/NEWS
index e6c47660522..75da416c5f3 100644
--- a/etc/NEWS
+++ b/etc/NEWS
@@ -212,6 +212,16 @@ to enter the file you want to modify.
 It can be used to customize the look of the appointment notification
 displayed on the mode line when 'appt-display-mode-line' is non-nil.
 
+** Emacs Server and Client
+
+---
+*** 'server-eval-args-left' can be used to pop subsequent eval args
+When '--eval' is passed to emacsclient and Emacs is evaluating each
+argument, this variable is set to those which have not yet been
+evaluated.  It can be used to 'pop' arguments to prevent them from
+being evaluated, which is useful when those arguments contain
+arbitrary data.
+
 \f
 * Editing Changes in Emacs 30.1
 
diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..4f7f00ebefd 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval "(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))" %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,7 +13,7 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval "(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))" %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index ce68e9aebc9..a2671165bfc 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -1199,6 +1199,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		parent-id  ; Window ID for XEmbed
 		dontkill   ; t if client should not be killed.
 		commands
+		evalexprs
 		dir
 		use-current-frame
 		frame-parameters  ;parameters for newly created frame
@@ -1332,8 +1333,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((expr (pop args-left)))
                    (if coding-system
                        (setq expr (decode-coding-string expr coding-system)))
-                   (push (lambda () (server-eval-and-print expr proc))
-                         commands)
+                   (push expr evalexprs)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
@@ -1358,7 +1358,7 @@ server-process-filter
 	    ;; arguments, use an existing frame.
 	    (and nowait
 		 (not (eq tty-name 'window-system))
-		 (or files commands)
+		 (or files commands evalexprs)
 		 (setq use-current-frame t))
 
 	    (setq frame
@@ -1407,7 +1407,7 @@ server-process-filter
                  (let ((default-directory
                          (if (and dir (file-directory-p dir))
                              dir default-directory)))
-                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands
+                   (server-execute proc files nowait commands evalexprs
                                    dontkill frame tty-name)))))
 
             (when (or frame files)
@@ -1417,22 +1417,35 @@ server-process-filter
     ;; condition-case
     (t (server-return-error proc err))))
 
-(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands dontkill frame tty-name)
+(defvar server-eval-args-left nil
+  "List of eval args not yet processed.
+
+Adding or removing strings from this variable while the Emacs
+server is processing a series of eval requests will affect what
+Emacs evaluates.
+
+See also `argv' for a similar variable which works for
+invocations of \"emacs\".")
+
+(defun server-execute (proc files nowait commands evalexprs dontkill frame tty-name)
   ;; This is run from timers and process-filters, i.e. "asynchronously".
   ;; But w.r.t the user, this is not really asynchronous since the timer
   ;; is run after 0s and the process-filter is run in response to the
   ;; user running `emacsclient'.  So it is OK to override the
-  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `commands' (as well as
+  ;; inhibit-quit flag, which is good since `evalexprs' (as well as
   ;; find-file-noselect via the major-mode) can run arbitrary code,
   ;; including code that needs to wait.
   (with-local-quit
     (condition-case err
         (let ((buffers (server-visit-files files proc nowait)))
           (mapc 'funcall (nreverse commands))
+          (let ((server-eval-args-left (nreverse evalexprs)))
+            (while server-eval-args-left
+              (server-eval-and-print (pop server-eval-args-left) proc)))
 	  ;; If we were told only to open a new client, obey
 	  ;; `initial-buffer-choice' if it specifies a file
           ;; or a function.
-          (unless (or files commands)
+          (unless (or files commands evalexprs)
             (let ((buf
                    (cond ((stringp initial-buffer-choice)
 			  (find-file-noselect initial-buffer-choice))
diff --git a/lisp/startup.el b/lisp/startup.el
index 6329e3ea8d0..37843eab176 100644
--- a/lisp/startup.el
+++ b/lisp/startup.el
@@ -120,7 +120,10 @@ command-switch-alist
     "List of command-line args not yet processed.
 This is a convenience alias, so that one can write (pop argv)
 inside of --eval command line arguments in order to access
-following arguments."))
+following arguments.
+
+See also `server-eval-args-left' for a similar variable which
+works for invocations of \"emacsclient --eval\"."))
 (internal-make-var-non-special 'argv)
 
 (defvar command-line-args-left nil
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Tue, 24 Oct 2023 16:27:33 +0000 (UTC)
> Cc: Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org>, sbaugh@janestreet.com,
> 	Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org>, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> 
> Thanks.  OK, spec-compliant version:

Thanks, installed on master, and closing the bug.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Jim Porter]

On 10/21/2023 8:20 AM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
> 
> Any remaining concerns about this patch?  It would be nice to install
> it.

 From my perspective, I'm happy with this change. Thanks for all the 
effort on seeing this through.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Stefan Kangas]

sbaugh@catern.com writes:

> diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
> index 0a2420ddead..5962fa1764c 100644
> --- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
> +++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
> @@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
>  [Desktop Entry]
>  Categories=Network;Email;
>  Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
> -# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
> -# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
> -# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
> -Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
> +Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --eval '(message-mailto (pop server-eval-args-left))' %u

As Spencer pointed out upthread, the mailto: links come from untrusted
sources (e.g. websites).  Escaping is infamous for being hard to get
right, and for that reason is a popular attack vector among bad actors.

I think it would be good if we could reduce the amount of stuff we have
to remember escaping here, or even better if we didn't need to escape
anything at all.  It's analogous to the case `shell-command-to-string'
(which uses a shell) vs `call-process' (which doesn't).

To my mind, this speaks in favor of some type of change in this
direction.  My two cents.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Stefan Kangas <stefankangas@gmail.com>
> Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 00:05:20 -0700
> Cc: 65902@debbugs.gnu.org, Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@janestreet.com>, jporterbugs@gmail.com
> 
> I think it would be good if we could reduce the amount of stuff we have
> to remember escaping here, or even better if we didn't need to escape
> anything at all.

We cannot avoid some escaping because the command is invoked through
"sh -c".  This is not our decision, this is the decision of
freedesktop.org, and we have no control on what they decide, even if
we think the decision is not the best one.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Andreas Schwab]

On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:

> We cannot avoid some escaping because the command is invoked through
> "sh -c".  This is not our decision, this is the decision of
> freedesktop.org,

That's not true.  The Exec line is _not_ passed to the shell, but is
processed by a specialized parser and then executed directly.

-- 
Andreas Schwab, schwab@linux-m68k.org
GPG Key fingerprint = 7578 EB47 D4E5 4D69 2510  2552 DF73 E780 A9DA AEC1
"And now for something completely different."

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org>
> Cc: Stefan Kangas <stefankangas@gmail.com>,  jporterbugs@gmail.com,
>   sbaugh@catern.com,  sbaugh@janestreet.com,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 11:29:06 +0200
> 
> On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
> 
> > We cannot avoid some escaping because the command is invoked through
> > "sh -c".  This is not our decision, this is the decision of
> > freedesktop.org,
> 
> That's not true.  The Exec line is _not_ passed to the shell, but is
> processed by a specialized parser and then executed directly.

Then why is "sh -c" being used?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Andreas Schwab]

On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:

> Then why is "sh -c" being used?

This is self-inflicted pain, because emacsclient does not support
passing arbitrary arguments to emacs.

-- 
Andreas Schwab, schwab@linux-m68k.org
GPG Key fingerprint = 7578 EB47 D4E5 4D69 2510  2552 DF73 E780 A9DA AEC1
"And now for something completely different."

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org>
> Cc: stefankangas@gmail.com,  jporterbugs@gmail.com,  sbaugh@catern.com,
>   sbaugh@janestreet.com,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 14:37:53 +0200
> 
> On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
> 
> > Then why is "sh -c" being used?
> 
> This is self-inflicted pain, because emacsclient does not support
> passing arbitrary arguments to emacs.

What do you mean by "arbitrary arguments"? what kind of arguments need
to be passed here that are not currently supported?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Andreas Schwab]

On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:

> What do you mean by "arbitrary arguments"? what kind of arguments need
> to be passed here that are not currently supported?

%u

-- 
Andreas Schwab, schwab@linux-m68k.org
GPG Key fingerprint = 7578 EB47 D4E5 4D69 2510  2552 DF73 E780 A9DA AEC1
"And now for something completely different."

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org>
> Cc: stefankangas@gmail.com,  jporterbugs@gmail.com,  sbaugh@catern.com,
>   sbaugh@janestreet.com,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 15:23:51 +0200
> 
> On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
> 
> > What do you mean by "arbitrary arguments"? what kind of arguments need
> > to be passed here that are not currently supported?
> 
> %u

This contradicts what I see in the *desktop files.  They use shell
commands and features.  See, for example, emacsclient.desktop and
emacsclient-mail.desktop.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Andreas Schwab]

On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:

>> From: Andreas Schwab <schwab@linux-m68k.org>
>> Cc: stefankangas@gmail.com,  jporterbugs@gmail.com,  sbaugh@catern.com,
>>   sbaugh@janestreet.com,  65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 15:23:51 +0200
>> 
>> On Sep 22 2023, Eli Zaretskii wrote:
>> 
>> > What do you mean by "arbitrary arguments"? what kind of arguments need
>> > to be passed here that are not currently supported?
>> 
>> %u
>
> This contradicts what I see in the *desktop files.  They use shell
> commands and features.

That's the self-inflicted pain.

-- 
Andreas Schwab, schwab@linux-m68k.org
GPG Key fingerprint = 7578 EB47 D4E5 4D69 2510  2552 DF73 E780 A9DA AEC1
"And now for something completely different."

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

The emacsclient-mail.desktop file fails on my system with the following
error:
"$1": -c: line 2: unexpected EOF while looking for matching `)'

My subsequent mail will fix this also vastly simplify
emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new feature to emacsclient to avoid
the need for complex escaping.


In GNU Emacs 29.0.92 (build 68, x86_64-pc-linux-gnu, X toolkit, cairo
 version 1.16.0, Xaw3d scroll bars) of 2023-07-15 built on earth
Repository revision: 36d3460f9f6064c03fd88e0c969c8e4f4d645235
Repository branch: emacs-29
Windowing system distributor 'The X.Org Foundation', version 11.0.12101008
System Description: NixOS 23.05 (Stoat)

Configured using:
 'configure --cache-file=config.cache --with-x-toolkit=lucid
 --with-tree-sitter --with-xinput2 CC=gcc PKG_CONFIG=pkg-config
 PKG_CONFIG_PATH=/nix/store/s3r15m8wbl4wqk4khqlf41ikryhjm1bi-file-5.44-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/f9jbn419h46c78z1pi49yn9a8742b0ql-gnutls-3.8.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/knq0pv08wm4dins7m4jh0n7cv7pjvdjr-nettle-3.9.1-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/dy8p07vrrhdgpnl45xz9c0k0didbikdh-gmp-with-cxx-6.2.1-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/6hkdabzyqhyq5ypq4c9b2cibr1d1zg1s-harfbuzz-7.3.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/hyns944pqgblw4icskylvlpm5krmfvcr-graphite2-1.3.14-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/08cdp9vgvy023ysfa2y01gzsm2jv6phx-jansson-2.14/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/nqlbk40lh7igs61l77dwgdkn8dc2akcm-libxml2-2.10.4-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/b3axl73v3yvqqx7g47njqb5wzxvm280p-zlib-1.2.13-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/3f2rc4inlcxmq11718qmz94v2rpybw70-ncurses-6.4-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/bxy745kyb1fwhpfkiaaz3wgvpkpvwcpq-dbus-1.14.8-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/9714v7c4cgpm4yqcyqk6n9xw9iq3a1bs-expat-2.5.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/zzi7pcadidqh798yddxv6pwdbwpkikma-libselinux-3.3-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/w14j7y5nl14vy4ikcivss35jmrqq3fxj-libotf-0.9.16-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/arhk7hsch4scyv6m24fw03yq6wq5wbbx-m17n-lib-1.8.2/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/1jbbrny8xcjb68lb5m30cvxycfkyhvsv-sqlite-3.42.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/5vx779yqkxaysv48gicwlgv0ippbrhc4-systemd-253.5-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/5vx779yqkxaysv48gicwlgv0ippbrhc4-systemd-253.5-dev/share/pkgconfig:/nix/store/djifahvk3qp06ssqxv6gy1ixdnnypr9s-tree-sitter-0.20.8/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/74aasy1d2r5y27zn68cs1rxwy1llzn05-libwebp-1.3.0/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/8sk7bp89iwb4gw96fq6xakb6lcy2x52n-Xaw3d-1.6.3/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/ppvb3ha8148am3ajnzxnm6i3ri38c01n-libXmu-1.1.3-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/jyxf8cjbj3nzh00x48nfram79i63chdi-libX11-1.8.6-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/zk9v0nr5zdfi1ybkhcfifmxsng7hfl23-xorgproto-2021.5/share/pkgconfig:/nix/store/3q1k18v8aa6mxs538bha4ry0mp3m321l-libxcb-1.14-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/hcscz68zvfk1skyb25wrnha959f6hhrc-libXt-1.2.1-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/kl55wj6qc3v481jsgvzm5w2csnhm84zf-libSM-1.2.3-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/s3f67kvsn55rxp2rc98xv0hkq364yci1-libICE-1.0.10-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/rsw4ri8025jgln8vpsrmg82bzgbcw3zr-cairo-1.16.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/jir0rqbcy0d9qr9kf5cwf2yphql4ykyw-fontconfig-2.14.2-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/n2g3xblaz1k4civv1z6hhm1nsmp3m17p-freetype-2.13.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/isbmyzm2shmp0wsjr4cy45v2i58h2zvw-bzip2-1.0.8-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/bl2qwy78jr2sqm260imgxmd5dzhjqvag-brotli-1.0.9-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/z96jh9ag5b3565lwwb5chjb9bfp5i2qv-libpng-apng-1.6.39-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/jjd4z18grhky6lh8n463v648nnf5628b-pixman-0.42.2/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/qd14wrazwcspjv3q65vgh35pl7b8nifq-libXext-1.3.4-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/gj8i21xx87ip9b971j2d1m0rmrzyhbir-libXau-1.0.9-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/4gpinwwdqhi927xkrfpr1hvdd56baxgk-libXrender-0.9.10-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/d1jbygs6hcn6dysk706i9zf07yd18wmr-xcb-util-0.4.1-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/hdc4ika0mb1cv0cf6dchwxbr004rc50i-glib-2.76.3-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/wxyh848a6xcqy2v8727vcwspri53pqwi-libffi-3.4.4-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/42jx72681qzliic0xsjhvx24cil2gapk-libGL-1.6.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/b9lmdkxpvgkj6zc956fvhshzisqpi767-libglvnd-1.6.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/gff29sbhg1gcw969mpm5rb693kj5v18w-libXaw-1.0.14-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/776xijk8rsb1b4c0dsxwq0k82bvm7mm9-libXpm-3.5.15-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/qizdmm43xi65mdngal8bpbpqcdc8290d-libjpeg-turbo-2.1.5.1-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/db7ix62fx4nvr9j1fjdvnznl2npff4pr-librsvg-2.55.1-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/q0hg0951w1dv9y40m9ggln8phwil6lxc-gdk-pixbuf-2.42.10-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/34rr5nvgljsc4bi3mxjxg8abmjr1f7hn-libtiff-4.5.0-dev/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/zwkr4kjcjs213pw9mhzi46bzlw6qwxzq-libdeflate-1.18/lib/pkgconfig:/nix/store/6na552yzwml88j8g5vqf5h9ir3vw8myi-xz-5.4.3-dev/lib/pkgconfig
 CXX=g++'

Configured features:
CAIRO DBUS FREETYPE GIF GLIB GMP GNUTLS GPM GSETTINGS HARFBUZZ JPEG JSON
LIBOTF LIBSELINUX LIBSYSTEMD LIBXML2 M17N_FLT MODULES NOTIFY INOTIFY
PDUMPER PNG RSVG SECCOMP SOUND SQLITE3 THREADS TIFF TOOLKIT_SCROLL_BARS
TREE_SITTER WEBP X11 XAW3D XDBE XIM XPM LUCID ZLIB

Important settings:
  value of $LANG: en_US.UTF-8
  locale-coding-system: utf-8-unix

Major mode: Diff

Minor modes in effect:
  whitespace-mode: t
  envrc-global-mode: t
  envrc-mode: t
  global-git-commit-mode: t
  magit-auto-revert-mode: t
  shell-dirtrack-mode: t
  server-mode: t
  windmove-mode: t
  pixel-scroll-precision-mode: t
  savehist-mode: t
  save-place-mode: t
  tooltip-mode: t
  global-eldoc-mode: t
  show-paren-mode: t
  electric-indent-mode: t
  mouse-wheel-mode: t
  tab-bar-mode: t
  menu-bar-mode: t
  file-name-shadow-mode: t
  context-menu-mode: t
  global-font-lock-mode: t
  font-lock-mode: t
  blink-cursor-mode: t
  buffer-read-only: t
  line-number-mode: t
  indent-tabs-mode: t
  transient-mark-mode: t
  auto-composition-mode: t
  auto-encryption-mode: t
  auto-compression-mode: t

Load-path shadows:
/home/sbaugh/.emacs.d/elpa/transient-0.3.7/transient hides /home/sbaugh/src/emacs/emacs-29/lisp/transient

Features:
(shadow sort emacsbug mpv tq org-timer org-clock org org-macro
org-pcomplete org-list org-footnote org-faces org-entities ob-python
python compat ob ob-tangle org-src ob-ref ob-lob ob-table ob-exp
ob-comint ob-emacs-lisp ob-core ob-eval org-cycle org-table ol org-fold
org-fold-core org-keys oc org-loaddefs cal-menu calendar cal-loaddefs
org-version org-compat org-macs vc-src vc-sccs vc-svn vc-cvs vc-rcs gud
noutline outline debug backtrace shortdoc pcmpl-unix pcmpl-gnu misc
pulse color compile etags fileloop generator xref cc-mode cc-fonts
cc-guess cc-menus cc-cmds cc-styles cc-align cc-engine cc-vars cc-defs
bug-reference find-func cl-print help-fns radix-tree mail-extr rng-xsd
xsd-regexp rng-cmpct rng-nxml rng-valid rng-loc rng-uri rng-parse
nxml-parse rng-match rng-dt rng-util rng-pttrn nxml-ns nxml-mode
nxml-outln nxml-rap sgml-mode facemenu dom nxml-util nxml-enc xmltok
whitespace log-view vc conf-mode dabbrev tabify man mule-util jka-compr
tramp-cmds misearch multi-isearch vc-hg vc-bzr nix-mode nix-repl
nix-shell nix-store nix-log nix-instantiate nix-shebang nix-format nix
tramp-cache time-stamp tramp-sh tramp tramp-loaddefs trampver
tramp-integration tramp-compat parse-time iso8601 cus-start vc-git
vc-dispatcher dired-aux dired-x ffap sh-script smie treesit executable
project files-x face-remap exwm-randr xcb-randr exwm exwm-input
xcb-keysyms xcb-xkb exwm-manage exwm-floating xcb-cursor xcb-render
exwm-layout exwm-workspace exwm-core xcb-ewmh xcb-icccm xcb xcb-xproto
xcb-types xcb-debug lui-autopaste circe advice lui-irc-colors irc gnutls
lcs lui-logging lui-format lui tracking shorten thingatpt flyspell
ispell circe-compat agda2 envrc inheritenv page-ext magit-extras
magit-submodule magit-obsolete magit-blame magit-stash magit-reflog
magit-bisect magit-push magit-pull magit-fetch magit-clone magit-remote
magit-commit magit-sequence magit-notes magit-worktree magit-tag
magit-merge magit-branch magit-reset magit-files magit-refs magit-status
magit magit-repos magit-apply magit-wip magit-log which-func imenu
magit-diff smerge-mode diff diff-mode git-commit rx log-edit message
sendmail yank-media puny dired desktop frameset dired-loaddefs rfc822
mml mml-sec epa derived epg rfc6068 epg-config gnus-util
text-property-search time-date mm-decode mm-bodies mm-encode mail-parse
rfc2231 rfc2047 rfc2045 mm-util ietf-drums mail-prsvr mailabbrev
mail-utils gmm-utils mailheader pcvs-util add-log magit-core
magit-autorevert autorevert filenotify magit-margin magit-transient
magit-process with-editor shell pcomplete comint ansi-osc server
ansi-color magit-mode transient cl-extra edmacro kmacro help-mode
format-spec magit-git magit-section magit-utils crm dash windmove
easy-mmode pixel-scroll cua-base ring modus-vivendi-theme modus-themes
pcase cus-edit pp cus-load icons wid-edit savehist saveplace finder-inf
ace-window-autoloads auctex-autoloads tex-site avy-autoloads
circe-autoloads corfu-autoloads compat-autoloads csv-mode-autoloads
cyberpunk-theme-autoloads debbugs-autoloads eat-autoloads
envrc-autoloads exwm-autoloads ggtags-autoloads
graphviz-dot-mode-autoloads htmlize-autoloads inheritenv-autoloads
magit-autoloads git-commit-autoloads markdown-mode-autoloads
mastodon-autoloads mentor-autoloads async-autoloads mpv-autoloads
nix-mode-autoloads magit-section-autoloads dash-autoloads
notmuch-autoloads persist-autoloads request-autoloads
rust-mode-autoloads transient-autoloads url-scgi-autoloads
vundo-autoloads which-key-autoloads info with-editor-autoloads
xelb-autoloads xml-rpc-autoloads package browse-url url url-proxy
url-privacy url-expand url-methods url-history url-cookie
generate-lisp-file url-domsuf url-util mailcap url-handlers url-parse
auth-source cl-seq eieio eieio-core cl-macs password-cache json subr-x
map byte-opt gv bytecomp byte-compile url-vars cl-loaddefs cl-lib rmc
iso-transl tooltip cconv eldoc paren electric uniquify ediff-hook
vc-hooks lisp-float-type elisp-mode mwheel term/x-win x-win
term/common-win x-dnd tool-bar dnd fontset image regexp-opt fringe
tabulated-list replace newcomment text-mode lisp-mode prog-mode register
page tab-bar menu-bar rfn-eshadow isearch easymenu timer select
scroll-bar mouse jit-lock font-lock syntax font-core term/tty-colors
frame minibuffer nadvice seq simple cl-generic indonesian philippine
cham georgian utf-8-lang misc-lang vietnamese tibetan thai tai-viet lao
korean japanese eucjp-ms cp51932 hebrew greek romanian slovak czech
european ethiopic indian cyrillic chinese composite emoji-zwj charscript
charprop case-table epa-hook jka-cmpr-hook help abbrev obarray oclosure
cl-preloaded button loaddefs theme-loaddefs faces cus-face macroexp
files window text-properties overlay sha1 md5 base64 format env
code-pages mule custom widget keymap hashtable-print-readable backquote
threads dbusbind inotify dynamic-setting system-font-setting
font-render-setting cairo x-toolkit x multi-tty make-network-process
emacs)

Memory information:
((conses 16 793112 58580)
 (symbols 48 42890 0)
 (strings 32 165901 6428)
 (string-bytes 1 8295556)
 (vectors 16 90751)
 (vector-slots 8 2007121 64111)
 (floats 8 418 578)
 (intervals 56 43463 2379)
 (buffers 984 111))

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 413 bytes --]

tags 65902 + patch
quit

This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.

I expect this to also be useful in other places; the need to escape
arbitrary inputs before passing them to emacsclient is frequently
annoying.


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-funcall-to-emacsclient-to-avoid-escaping-argumen.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 7904 bytes --]

From 6c9dbda3aa5e3f1e3a5003bc0a15cf662b880d99 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Tue, 12 Sep 2023 22:20:15 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add --funcall to emacsclient to avoid escaping arguments

Passing arguments to functions through emacsclient --eval requires
complicated escaping (as seen in emacsclient-mail.desktop before this
change).  The new --funcall argument behaves like emacs -f, and just
passes the arguments as uninterpreted strings to the specified
function.  This simplifies use cases where arbitrary input needs to be
passed to emacsclient.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use --funcall. (bug#65902)
* lib-src/emacsclient.c (longopts, decode_options, main): Add support
for --funcall.
* lisp/server.el (server-funcall-and-print): Add.
(server-process-filter):  Add support for -funcall and -funcallargs
---
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  7 ++-----
 lib-src/emacsclient.c        | 36 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--
 lisp/server.el               | 34 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 3 files changed, 70 insertions(+), 7 deletions(-)

diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..fc6773a963b 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --funcall message-mailto %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,7 +13,7 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --funcall message-mailto %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
diff --git a/lib-src/emacsclient.c b/lib-src/emacsclient.c
index 698bf9b50ae..5bf6c05ef37 100644
--- a/lib-src/emacsclient.c
+++ b/lib-src/emacsclient.c
@@ -116,6 +116,9 @@ #define DEFAULT_TIMEOUT (30)
 /* True means args are expressions to be evaluated.  --eval.  */
 static bool eval;
 
+/* The function to call.  Other arguments are passed as strings.  --funcall.  */
+static char *funcall;
+
 /* True means open a new frame.  --create-frame etc.  */
 static bool create_frame;
 
@@ -169,6 +172,7 @@ #define DEFAULT_TIMEOUT (30)
   { "quiet",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'q' },
   { "suppress-output", no_argument, NULL, 'u' },
   { "eval",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'e' },
+  { "funcall",	required_argument, NULL, 'l' },
   { "help",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'H' },
   { "version",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'V' },
   { "tty",	no_argument,       NULL, 't' },
@@ -552,6 +556,10 @@ decode_options (int argc, char **argv)
 	  eval = true;
 	  break;
 
+	case 'l':
+	  funcall = optarg;
+	  break;
+
 	case 'q':
 	  quiet = true;
 	  break;
@@ -690,6 +698,7 @@ print_help_and_exit (void)
 -F ALIST, --frame-parameters=ALIST\n\
 			Set the parameters of a new frame\n\
 -e, --eval    		Evaluate the FILE arguments as ELisp expressions\n\
+-l, --funcall FUNC	Call ELisp FUNC, passing FILE arguments as strings\n\
 -n, --no-wait		Don't wait for the server to return\n\
 -w, --timeout=SECONDS	Seconds to wait before timing out\n\
 -q, --quiet		Don't display messages on success\n\
@@ -1953,7 +1962,7 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
   /* Process options.  */
   decode_options (argc, argv);
 
-  if (! (optind < argc || eval || create_frame))
+  if (! (optind < argc || eval || funcall || create_frame))
     {
       message (true, ("%s: file name or argument required\n"
 		      "Try '%s --help' for more information\n"),
@@ -1961,6 +1970,14 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
       exit (EXIT_FAILURE);
     }
 
+  if (eval && funcall)
+    {
+      message (true, ("%s: can't pass both --eval and --funcall\n"
+		      "Try '%s --help' for more information\n"),
+	       progname, progname);
+      exit (EXIT_FAILURE);
+    }
+
 #ifdef SOCKETS_IN_FILE_SYSTEM
   if (tty)
     {
@@ -2080,6 +2097,13 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
               send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
               continue;
             }
+	  else if (funcall)
+	    {
+              send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "-funcallarg ");
+              quote_argument (emacs_socket, argv[i]);
+              send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
+              continue;
+	    }
 
 	  char *p = argv[i];
 	  if (*p == '+')
@@ -2136,10 +2160,18 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
       send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
     }
 
+  if (funcall)
+    {
+      send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "-funcall ");
+      quote_argument (emacs_socket, funcall);
+      send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
+    }
+
+
   send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "\n");
 
   /* Wait for an answer. */
-  if (!eval && !tty && !nowait && !quiet && 0 <= process_grouping ())
+  if (!eval && !funcall && !tty && !nowait && !quiet && 0 <= process_grouping ())
     {
       printf ("Waiting for Emacs...");
       skiplf = false;
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index c3325e5a24c..da3319581ea 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -873,6 +873,17 @@ server-eval-and-print
                        (point-min) (point-max))))
             (server-reply-print (server-quote-arg text) proc)))))))
 
+(defun server-funcall-and-print (func args proc)
+  "Call FUNC on ARGS and send the result back to client PROC."
+  (let ((v (with-local-quit (eval (apply (intern func) args) t))))
+    (when proc
+      (with-temp-buffer
+        (let ((standard-output (current-buffer)))
+          (pp v)
+          (let ((text (buffer-substring-no-properties
+                       (point-min) (point-max))))
+            (server-reply-print (server-quote-arg text) proc)))))))
+
 (defconst server-msg-size 1024
   "Maximum size of a message sent to a client.")
 
@@ -1196,6 +1207,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		tty-type   ; string.
 		files
 		filepos
+		funcallargs
 		args-left)
 	    ;; Remove this line from STRING.
 	    (setq string (substring string (match-end 0)))
@@ -1323,6 +1335,28 @@ server-process-filter
                          commands)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
+                ;; -funcall FUNC:  Call a function on arguments.
+                ("-funcall"
+                 (if use-current-frame
+                     (setq use-current-frame 'always))
+                 (let ((func (pop args-left)))
+                   (if coding-system
+                       (setq func (decode-coding-string func coding-system)))
+                   (push (lambda () (server-funcall-and-print func funcallargs proc))
+                         commands)
+                   (setq funcallargs nil)
+                   (setq filepos nil)))
+
+                ;; -funcallarg ARG:  Add an argument for later -funcall.
+                ("-funcallarg"
+                 (if use-current-frame
+                     (setq use-current-frame 'always))
+                 (let ((arg (pop args-left)))
+                   (if coding-system
+                       (setq arg (decode-coding-string arg coding-system)))
+                   (push arg funcallargs)
+                   (setq filepos nil)))
+
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
                 ("-env"
                  (let ((var (pop args-left)))
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Jim Porter]

On 9/12/2023 7:30 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
> tags 65902 + patch
> quit
> 
> This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
> emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
> which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
> basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.

I think this is actually the same as the (very long) bug#57752, so 
thanks for working on this. (It was on my list of things to get to, but 
I just haven't had time.)

Over there, we agreed that something like your patch is wanted, albeit 
with two caveats:

1. Since "--funcall" for the regular "emacs" binary doesn't pass 
arguments to the function, how about we call this option "--apply" instead?

2. It would be great if we could get "--apply" for the regular "emacs" 
binary too, so that both programs work the same way (at least in this 
regard). Even better, if you could forward "--apply" from "emacsclient" 
to the alternate editor (which would be "emacs" 99% of the time) 
automatically. That works, in a roundabout way, for the Emacs daemon, 
but not if the alternate editor is "emacs".

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Robert Pluim]

>>>>> On Tue, 12 Sep 2023 20:46:54 -0700, Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com> said:

    Jim> On 9/12/2023 7:30 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
    >> tags 65902 + patch
    >> quit
    >> This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
    >> emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
    >> which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
    >> basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.

    Jim> I think this is actually the same as the (very long) bug#57752, so
    Jim> thanks for working on this. (It was on my list of things to get to,
    Jim> but I just haven't had time.)

57752 got bogged down in design paralysis :-)

The idea looks good to me.

    Jim> Over there, we agreed that something like your patch is wanted, albeit
    Jim> with two caveats:

    Jim> 1. Since "--funcall" for the regular "emacs" binary doesn't pass
    Jim> arguments to the function, how about we call this option "--apply"
    Jim> instead?

Yes, that sounds right.

    Jim> 2. It would be great if we could get "--apply" for the regular "emacs"
    Jim> binary too, so that both programs work the same way (at least in this
    Jim> regard). Even better, if you could forward "--apply" from
    Jim> "emacsclient" to the alternate editor (which would be "emacs" 99% of
    Jim> the time) automatically. That works, in a roundabout way, for the
    Jim> Emacs daemon, but not if the alternate editor is "emacs".

Consistency would be good here.

Robert
-- 

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> Cc: sbaugh@catern.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> From: Robert Pluim <rpluim@gmail.com>
> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 10:00:00 +0200
> 
> >>>>> On Tue, 12 Sep 2023 20:46:54 -0700, Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com> said:
> 
>     Jim> On 9/12/2023 7:30 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
>     >> tags 65902 + patch
>     >> quit
>     >> This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
>     >> emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
>     >> which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
>     >> basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.
> 
>     Jim> I think this is actually the same as the (very long) bug#57752, so
>     Jim> thanks for working on this. (It was on my list of things to get to,
>     Jim> but I just haven't had time.)
> 
> 57752 got bogged down in design paralysis :-)

And where do you think we will get here, if we retrace all the
arguments and counter-arguments voiced there?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Robert Pluim]

>>>>> On Wed, 13 Sep 2023 16:06:07 +0300, Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> said:

    >> Cc: sbaugh@catern.com, 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
    >> From: Robert Pluim <rpluim@gmail.com>
    >> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 10:00:00 +0200
    >> 
    >> >>>>> On Tue, 12 Sep 2023 20:46:54 -0700, Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com> said:
    >> 
    Jim> On 9/12/2023 7:30 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
    >> >> tags 65902 + patch
    >> >> quit
    >> >> This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
    >> >> emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
    >> >> which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
    >> >> basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.
    >> 
    Jim> I think this is actually the same as the (very long) bug#57752, so
    Jim> thanks for working on this. (It was on my list of things to get to,
    Jim> but I just haven't had time.)
    >> 
    >> 57752 got bogged down in design paralysis :-)

    Eli> And where do you think we will get here, if we retrace all the
    Eli> arguments and counter-arguments voiced there?

I was not intending to do that, I was intending to advocate for
Spencerʼs work to go in pretty much as-is (modulo calling it '--apply'
rather than '--funcall').

Robert
-- 

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> Date: Tue, 12 Sep 2023 20:46:54 -0700
> From: Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com>
> 
> On 9/12/2023 7:30 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
> > tags 65902 + patch
> > quit
> > 
> > This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
> > emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
> > which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
> > basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.
> 
> I think this is actually the same as the (very long) bug#57752, so 
> thanks for working on this. (It was on my list of things to get to, but 
> I just haven't had time.)
> 
> Over there, we agreed that something like your patch is wanted, albeit 
> with two caveats:
> 
> 1. Since "--funcall" for the regular "emacs" binary doesn't pass 
> arguments to the function, how about we call this option "--apply" instead?
> 
> 2. It would be great if we could get "--apply" for the regular "emacs" 
> binary too, so that both programs work the same way (at least in this 
> regard). Even better, if you could forward "--apply" from "emacsclient" 
> to the alternate editor (which would be "emacs" 99% of the time) 
> automatically. That works, in a roundabout way, for the Emacs daemon, 
> but not if the alternate editor is "emacs".

This is how that bug's discussion started.  Are we going to have it
all one more time?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1750 bytes --]

Jim Porter <jporterbugs@gmail.com> writes:

> On 9/12/2023 7:30 PM, sbaugh@catern.com wrote:
>> tags 65902 + patch
>> quit
>> This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
>> emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
>> which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
>> basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.
>
> I think this is actually the same as the (very long) bug#57752, so
> thanks for working on this. (It was on my list of things to get to,
> but I just haven't had time.)
>
> Over there, we agreed that something like your patch is wanted, albeit
> with two caveats:
>
> 1. Since "--funcall" for the regular "emacs" binary doesn't pass
> arguments to the function, how about we call this option "--apply"
> instead?

Ah, for some reason I thought --funcall passed arguments.  Done in
attached patch.

> 2. It would be great if we could get "--apply" for the regular "emacs"
> binary too, so that both programs work the same way (at least in this
> regard).

Done.

Although the behavior is slightly different: emacs --apply calls the
function with subsequent FILE arguments, and emacsclient --apply calls
the function with all FILE arguments.  The "subsequent FILE arguments"
behavior is probably better, but I don't know a way to do that with
getopt (which emacsclient uses).

> Even better, if you could forward "--apply" from
> "emacsclient" to the alternate editor (which would be "emacs" 99% of
> the time) automatically. That works, in a roundabout way, for the
> Emacs daemon, but not if the alternate editor is "emacs".

This happens automatically anyway: When emacsclient starts the daemon,
it sends the --apply request.  I think that's exactly what you'd want.


[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #2: 0001-Add-apply-argument-to-avoid-escaping-arguments.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 12161 bytes --]

From 4881017055ea6831ee7fe2d722eb79856946d907 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001
From: Spencer Baugh <sbaugh@catern.com>
Date: Tue, 12 Sep 2023 22:20:15 -0400
Subject: [PATCH] Add --apply argument to avoid escaping arguments

Passing arguments to functions through emacs --eval or emacsclient
--eval requires complicated escaping (as seen in
emacsclient-mail.desktop before this change).

The new --apply argument for both emacs and emacsclient passes command
line arguments as uninterpreted strings to the specified function.
This simplifies use cases where arbitrary input needs to be passed to
Emacs.

Note that there's a minor difference in behavior between emacs --apply
and emacsclient --apply: emacs --apply func calls func with only
command line arguments occuring after --apply, emacsclient --apply
func calls func with all command line arguments, even those which
occurred before --apply.  This is hard to avoid since emacsclient uses
getopt instead of fancier custom Lisp argument parsing in Emacs.

* etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop: Use --apply. (bug#65902)
* lib-src/emacsclient.c (longopts, decode_options, main): Add support
for --apply.
* lisp/server.el (server-apply-and-print): Add.
(server-process-filter): Add support for -apply and -applyargs
* lisp/startup.el (command-line-1): Add support for --apply.
* src/emacs.c (usage_message, standard_args): Add support for --apply.
---
 etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop |  9 +++------
 lib-src/emacsclient.c        | 36 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++--
 lisp/server.el               | 34 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 lisp/startup.el              | 18 +++++++++++++++---
 src/emacs.c                  |  3 +++
 5 files changed, 89 insertions(+), 11 deletions(-)

diff --git a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
index 0a2420ddead..750fcddacdc 100644
--- a/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
+++ b/etc/emacsclient-mail.desktop
@@ -1,10 +1,7 @@
 [Desktop Entry]
 Categories=Network;Email;
 Comment=GNU Emacs is an extensible, customizable text editor - and more
-# We want to pass the following commands to the shell wrapper:
-# u=$(echo "$1" | sed 's/[\"]/\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display="$DISPLAY" --eval "(message-mailto \"$u\")"
-# Special chars '"', '$', and '\' must be escaped as '\\"', '\\$', and '\\\\'.
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --display=\\"\\$DISPLAY\\" --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --apply message-mailto -- %u
 Icon=emacs
 Name=Emacs (Mail, Client)
 MimeType=x-scheme-handler/mailto;
@@ -16,8 +13,8 @@ Actions=new-window;new-instance;
 
 [Desktop Action new-window]
 Name=New Window
-Exec=sh -c "u=\\$(echo \\"\\$1\\" | sed 's/[\\\\\\"]/\\\\\\\\&/g'); exec emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --eval \\"(message-mailto \\\\\\"\\$u\\\\\\")\\"" sh %u
+Exec=emacsclient --alternate-editor= --create-frame --apply message-mailto -- %u
 
 [Desktop Action new-instance]
 Name=New Instance
-Exec=emacs -f message-mailto %u
+Exec=emacs --apply message-mailto -- %u
diff --git a/lib-src/emacsclient.c b/lib-src/emacsclient.c
index 698bf9b50ae..159c22d1ae9 100644
--- a/lib-src/emacsclient.c
+++ b/lib-src/emacsclient.c
@@ -116,6 +116,9 @@ #define DEFAULT_TIMEOUT (30)
 /* True means args are expressions to be evaluated.  --eval.  */
 static bool eval;
 
+/* The function to call.  Other arguments are passed as strings.  --apply.  */
+static char *apply;
+
 /* True means open a new frame.  --create-frame etc.  */
 static bool create_frame;
 
@@ -169,6 +172,7 @@ #define DEFAULT_TIMEOUT (30)
   { "quiet",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'q' },
   { "suppress-output", no_argument, NULL, 'u' },
   { "eval",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'e' },
+  { "apply",	required_argument, NULL, 'y' },
   { "help",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'H' },
   { "version",	no_argument,	   NULL, 'V' },
   { "tty",	no_argument,       NULL, 't' },
@@ -552,6 +556,10 @@ decode_options (int argc, char **argv)
 	  eval = true;
 	  break;
 
+	case 'y':
+	  apply = optarg;
+	  break;
+
 	case 'q':
 	  quiet = true;
 	  break;
@@ -690,6 +698,7 @@ print_help_and_exit (void)
 -F ALIST, --frame-parameters=ALIST\n\
 			Set the parameters of a new frame\n\
 -e, --eval    		Evaluate the FILE arguments as ELisp expressions\n\
+-y, --apply FUNC	Call ELisp FUNC, passing all FILE arguments as strings\n\
 -n, --no-wait		Don't wait for the server to return\n\
 -w, --timeout=SECONDS	Seconds to wait before timing out\n\
 -q, --quiet		Don't display messages on success\n\
@@ -1953,7 +1962,7 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
   /* Process options.  */
   decode_options (argc, argv);
 
-  if (! (optind < argc || eval || create_frame))
+  if (! (optind < argc || eval || apply || create_frame))
     {
       message (true, ("%s: file name or argument required\n"
 		      "Try '%s --help' for more information\n"),
@@ -1961,6 +1970,14 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
       exit (EXIT_FAILURE);
     }
 
+  if (eval && apply)
+    {
+      message (true, ("%s: can't pass both --eval and --apply\n"
+		      "Try '%s --help' for more information\n"),
+	       progname, progname);
+      exit (EXIT_FAILURE);
+    }
+
 #ifdef SOCKETS_IN_FILE_SYSTEM
   if (tty)
     {
@@ -2080,6 +2097,13 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
               send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
               continue;
             }
+	  else if (apply)
+	    {
+              send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "-applyarg ");
+              quote_argument (emacs_socket, argv[i]);
+              send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
+              continue;
+	    }
 
 	  char *p = argv[i];
 	  if (*p == '+')
@@ -2136,10 +2160,18 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
       send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
     }
 
+  if (apply)
+    {
+      send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "-apply ");
+      quote_argument (emacs_socket, apply);
+      send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, " ");
+    }
+
+
   send_to_emacs (emacs_socket, "\n");
 
   /* Wait for an answer. */
-  if (!eval && !tty && !nowait && !quiet && 0 <= process_grouping ())
+  if (!eval && !apply && !tty && !nowait && !quiet && 0 <= process_grouping ())
     {
       printf ("Waiting for Emacs...");
       skiplf = false;
diff --git a/lisp/server.el b/lisp/server.el
index c3325e5a24c..5981e90625d 100644
--- a/lisp/server.el
+++ b/lisp/server.el
@@ -873,6 +873,17 @@ server-eval-and-print
                        (point-min) (point-max))))
             (server-reply-print (server-quote-arg text) proc)))))))
 
+(defun server-apply-and-print (func args proc)
+  "Call FUNC on ARGS and send the result back to client PROC."
+  (let ((v (with-local-quit (eval (apply (intern func) args) t))))
+    (when proc
+      (with-temp-buffer
+        (let ((standard-output (current-buffer)))
+          (pp v)
+          (let ((text (buffer-substring-no-properties
+                       (point-min) (point-max))))
+            (server-reply-print (server-quote-arg text) proc)))))))
+
 (defconst server-msg-size 1024
   "Maximum size of a message sent to a client.")
 
@@ -1196,6 +1207,7 @@ server-process-filter
 		tty-type   ; string.
 		files
 		filepos
+		applyargs
 		args-left)
 	    ;; Remove this line from STRING.
 	    (setq string (substring string (match-end 0)))
@@ -1323,6 +1335,28 @@ server-process-filter
                          commands)
                    (setq filepos nil)))
 
+                ;; -apply FUNC:  Call a function on arguments.
+                ("-apply"
+                 (if use-current-frame
+                     (setq use-current-frame 'always))
+                 (let ((func (pop args-left)))
+                   (if coding-system
+                       (setq func (decode-coding-string func coding-system)))
+                   (push (lambda () (server-apply-and-print func applyargs proc))
+                         commands)
+                   (setq applyargs nil)
+                   (setq filepos nil)))
+
+                ;; -applyarg ARG:  Add an argument for later -apply.
+                ("-applyarg"
+                 (if use-current-frame
+                     (setq use-current-frame 'always))
+                 (let ((arg (pop args-left)))
+                   (if coding-system
+                       (setq arg (decode-coding-string arg coding-system)))
+                   (push arg applyargs)
+                   (setq filepos nil)))
+
                 ;; -env NAME=VALUE:  An environment variable.
                 ("-env"
                  (let ((var (pop args-left)))
diff --git a/lisp/startup.el b/lisp/startup.el
index 7f601668369..bb8da76bdf1 100644
--- a/lisp/startup.el
+++ b/lisp/startup.el
@@ -2531,10 +2531,11 @@ command-line-1
                ;; straight away upon any --directory/-L option.
                splice
                just-files ;; t if this follows the magic -- option.
+               applysym applyargs ;; function and arguments for --apply
                ;; This includes our standard options' long versions
                ;; and long versions of what's on command-switch-alist.
                (longopts
-                (append '("--funcall" "--load" "--insert" "--kill"
+                (append '("--funcall" "--apply" "--load" "--insert" "--kill"
                           "--dump-file" "--seccomp"
                           "--directory" "--eval" "--execute" "--no-splash"
                           "--find-file" "--visit" "--file" "--no-desktop")
@@ -2632,6 +2633,11 @@ command-line-1
                          (command-execute tem)
                        (funcall tem)))
 
+                    ((member argi '("-y" "-apply"))
+                     (setq inhibit-startup-screen t)
+                     ;; Subsequent file args will be accumulated into applyargs.
+                     (setq applysym (intern (or argval (pop command-line-args-left)))))
+
                     ((member argi '("-eval" "-execute"))
                      (setq inhibit-startup-screen t)
                      (let* ((str-expr (or argval (pop command-line-args-left)))
@@ -2763,13 +2769,19 @@ command-line-1
                          ;; screen for -nw?
                          (unless initial-window-system
                            (setq inhibit-startup-screen t))
-                         (funcall process-file-arg orig-argi)))))
+                         (if applysym
+                             (push orig-argi applyargs)
+                           (funcall process-file-arg orig-argi))))))
 
               ;; In unusual circumstances, the execution of Lisp code due
               ;; to command-line options can cause the last visible frame
               ;; to be deleted.  In this case, kill emacs to avoid an
               ;; abort later.
-              (unless (frame-live-p (selected-frame)) (kill-emacs nil)))))))
+              (unless (frame-live-p (selected-frame)) (kill-emacs nil))))
+
+          ;; Call the function specified with --apply, if any.
+          (when applysym
+            (apply applysym (nreverse applyargs))))))
 
     (when (eq initial-buffer-choice t)
       ;; When `initial-buffer-choice' equals t make sure that *scratch*
diff --git a/src/emacs.c b/src/emacs.c
index 80a013b68df..8de40936250 100644
--- a/src/emacs.c
+++ b/src/emacs.c
@@ -323,6 +323,8 @@ #define MAIN_PROGRAM
 --file FILE             visit FILE\n\
 --find-file FILE        visit FILE\n\
 --funcall, -f FUNC      call Emacs Lisp function FUNC with no arguments\n\
+--apply, -y FUNC        call Emacs Lisp function FUNC, passing\n\
+                          subsequent positional FILE arguments as strings\n\
 --insert FILE           insert contents of FILE into current buffer\n\
 --kill                  exit without asking for confirmation\n\
 --load, -l FILE         load Emacs Lisp FILE using the load function\n\
@@ -2648,6 +2650,7 @@ main (int argc, char **argv)
      option.  In any case, this is entirely an internal option.  */
   { "-scriptload", NULL, 0, 1 },
   { "-f", "--funcall", 0, 1 },
+  { "-y", "--apply", 0, 1 },
   { "-funcall", 0, 0, 1 },
   { "-eval", "--eval", 0, 1 },
   { "-execute", "--execute", 0, 1 },
-- 
2.41.0

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 02:30:08 +0000 (UTC)
> 
> This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
> emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
> which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
> basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.
> 
> I expect this to also be useful in other places; the need to escape
> arbitrary inputs before passing them to emacsclient is frequently
> annoying.

Is quoting the only issue with --eval?  If so, why not have a variant
of --eval that quotes the argument by itself, like you do in the
patch, i.e. by using quote_argument, instead of inventing yet another
weird option with its own small DSL and extra-special rules of how to
write the command line with it?

More generally, I cannot say I'm happy that we basically are
reiterating everything that was said in bug#57752 instead of picking
up where it left off.  Why is it useful to have another discussion
like that one (which will probably end up at the same impasse)?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[sbaugh]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> From: sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 02:30:08 +0000 (UTC)
>> 
>> This patch avoids the complicated scripting needed for
>> emacsclient-mail.desktop by adding a new flag to emacsclient, --funcall,
>> which mirrors emacs --funcall and allows emacsclient-mail.desktop to be
>> basically the same as emacs-mail.desktop.
>> 
>> I expect this to also be useful in other places; the need to escape
>> arbitrary inputs before passing them to emacsclient is frequently
>> annoying.
>
> Is quoting the only issue with --eval?  If so, why not have a variant
> of --eval that quotes the argument by itself, like you do in the
> patch, i.e. by using quote_argument, instead of inventing yet another
> weird option with its own small DSL and extra-special rules of how to
> write the command line with it?

I am not sure what you're suggesting.  Can you show how the equivalent
of:

emacsclient --apply message-mailto -- %u

would work with that design?

> More generally, I cannot say I'm happy that we basically are
> reiterating everything that was said in bug#57752 instead of picking
> up where it left off.  Why is it useful to have another discussion
> like that one (which will probably end up at the same impasse)?

I admit I didn't see that bug until now, but the way in which this is
different is that I have now read the discussion, incorporated all the
advice, and I'm actually implementing it :)

Probably these bugs could/should be merged though.

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: sbaugh@catern.com
> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 13:01:52 +0000 (UTC)
> Cc: 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
> 
> Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
> 
> > Is quoting the only issue with --eval?  If so, why not have a variant
> > of --eval that quotes the argument by itself, like you do in the
> > patch, i.e. by using quote_argument, instead of inventing yet another
> > weird option with its own small DSL and extra-special rules of how to
> > write the command line with it?
> 
> I am not sure what you're suggesting.  Can you show how the equivalent
> of:
> 
> emacsclient --apply message-mailto -- %u
> 
> would work with that design?

  emacsclient --qeval '(message-mailto %u)'

> > More generally, I cannot say I'm happy that we basically are
> > reiterating everything that was said in bug#57752 instead of picking
> > up where it left off.  Why is it useful to have another discussion
> > like that one (which will probably end up at the same impasse)?
> 
> I admit I didn't see that bug until now, but the way in which this is
> different is that I have now read the discussion, incorporated all the
> advice, and I'm actually implementing it :)

You are well under way to reach the same final point we ended up
there, because both the arguments people voice here and your
responses/reactions are the same as we saw there.  For example, we
already have an additional option to Emacs, although the original
problem had nothing to do with Emacs itself.

Let's not do that this time, okay?

bug#65902: 29.0.92; emacsclient-mail.desktop fails due to complicated escaping

[Björn Bidar via Bug reports for GNU Emacs, the Swiss army knife of text editors]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

>> From: sbaugh@catern.com
>> Date: Wed, 13 Sep 2023 13:01:52 +0000 (UTC)
>> Cc: 65902@debbugs.gnu.org
>> 
>> Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:
>> 
>> > Is quoting the only issue with --eval?  If so, why not have a variant
>> > of --eval that quotes the argument by itself, like you do in the
>> > patch, i.e. by using quote_argument, instead of inventing yet another
>> > weird option with its own small DSL and extra-special rules of how to
>> > write the command line with it?
>> 
>> I am not sure what you're suggesting.  Can you show how the equivalent
>> of:
>> 
>> emacsclient --apply message-mailto -- %u
>> 
>> would work with that design?
>
>   emacsclient --qeval '(message-mailto %u)'
>
Try desktop-file-validate. ' is a reserved character.

I have a desktop file for a similar use case, I validated that desktop
file using desktop-file-validate and got the following output:
emacs-gnus.desktop: error: value "emacsclient  --create-frame --eval '(gnus)'" for key "Exec" in group "Desktop Entry" contains a reserved character ''' outside of a quote