Re: multipage html output

[Orm Finnendahl <orm.finnendahl@selma.hfmdk-frankfurt.de>]

Hi,

 thanks for the quick response!

Am Dienstag, den 23. Juli 2024 um 10:24:54 Uhr (+0000) schrieb Ihor
Radchenko:
> I will first focus on reviewing changes to ox.el.
> 
> > ox.el
> > 
> > - added `org-export-collect-tree-info', and
> 
> And it is not used anywhere... What is the purpose?

That was not cleaned up from a previous stage. Removed, thanks!

> 
> >   org-export-transcode-headline, extracted from `org-export-as'
> 
> How does it have anything to do with "headline"? Maybe `org-export-transcode-page'?

changed.

>  
> > - added :multipage case to `org-export-as', calling :process-multipage
> >   callback submitted in info. In the multipage case, org-export-as
> >   returns nil relying on :process-multipage to do the exporting, while
> >   in the single page case it returns the transcoded string to the
> >   caller from the backend.
> 
> Does it mean that you do not want page splitting to be controlled
> globally, in ox.el, as we discussed?

Not for now (I mention that later in the mail when I talk about
section-filenames and future generalizations, where this definitely
has to be done). In the html multipage export are many peculiarities
which don't apply to other backends, so ox.el wouldn't be the place
for it, so we will need some callback mechanism anyway.

Right now this gets accomplished with a small branch in org-export-as
in order to change as little as possible. It'll be easy to change if
we find a good way to get this done using a more general approach. But
I'm open for suggestions, if you have an idea how to already do it
now.

> This looks reasonable. Maybe even as a separate patch we can merge
> earlier.

Sure.

>  
> > - changed that `org-export-numbered-headline-p' always returns t for
> >   headlines in the multipage case to ensure headline numbering is
> >   collected.
> 
> >   NOTE: The single-page case will be handled like before, but it might
> >   be a better idea to change the behaviour and do it the same way as
> >   in the multipage case: Always collect the headline-numbering and
> >   only decide at the transcoding stage whether the headline should be
> >   numbered in the output.
> 
> Why? What if one wants headlines to be not numbered?

Just set num:nil in the options. As mentioned, I think printing
headline numbers should get handled in the transcoding stage of the
backend and not before. Multipage export behind the scenes is
completely dependant on headline numbering, even if headlines aren't
displayed, so the code in ox.el first proceeds, as if headline
numbering is turned on and moves the check for headline numbering to
the transcoding stage. I didn't change the behaviour in the
single-page html situation. Although I think that it might make sense
that headline-numbering in general only gets checked at the
transcoding stage that would affect all backends, so I didn't change
anything.

Thanks also for the info regarding how to contribute. It'd be nice if
you could gibe me a go in case you approve the proposal.

--
Orm