bug#2317: emacs silently ignores buffer file encoding?

bug#2317: emacs silently ignores buffer file encoding?

[Chong Yidong]

> (1) Start emacs -Q
> (2) Visit "/tmp/fff"
> (3) Insert the following chars: "θϑΘ"
> (4) Set the buffer file encoding to latin1 with: C-x C-m f latin-1 RET
> (5) Save the buffer: C-x C-s
>
> For me, "/tmp/fff" is saved sucessfully, with no error or prompt, using
> an encoding of utf-8 -- despite my having explicitly requested latin-1.

I think this bug may have been fixed.  ISTR seeing the same result when
I tested with your recipe a few weeks ago.  With latest CVS, however, I
get a "Select coding system" prompt.  Can you confirm?

bug#2317: emacs silently ignores buffer file encoding?

[Sven Joachim]

On 2009-03-15 17:12 +0100, Chong Yidong wrote:

>> (1) Start emacs -Q
>> (2) Visit "/tmp/fff"
>> (3) Insert the following chars: "θϑΘ"
>> (4) Set the buffer file encoding to latin1 with: C-x C-m f latin-1 RET
>> (5) Save the buffer: C-x C-s
>>
>> For me, "/tmp/fff" is saved sucessfully, with no error or prompt, using
>> an encoding of utf-8 -- despite my having explicitly requested latin-1.
>
> I think this bug may have been fixed.  ISTR seeing the same result when
> I tested with your recipe a few weeks ago.  With latest CVS, however, I
> get a "Select coding system" prompt.  Can you confirm?

This has been fixed on March 3 by Handa-san, see [1].  However, this fix
has side effects that I find very annoying: if I visit a file containing
only ASCII characters and insert non-ASCII characters into the buffer,
the "Select coding system" prompt pops up as well, although I never
asked about a specific coding system and would be completely satisfied
with Emacs silently choosing UTF-8[2] in that case.


1. http://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2009-03/msg00011.html
2. Or whatever the preferred coding system for new files happens to be.

bug#2317: emacs silently ignores buffer file encoding?

[Kenichi Handa]

In article <87hc1sy1qk.fsf@turtle.gmx.de>, Sven Joachim <svenjoac@gmx.de> writes:

> On 2009-03-15 17:12 +0100, Chong Yidong wrote:
>>> (1) Start emacs -Q
>>> (2) Visit "/tmp/fff"
>>> (3) Insert the following chars: "θϑΘ"
>>> (4) Set the buffer file encoding to latin1 with: C-x C-m f latin-1 RET
>>> (5) Save the buffer: C-x C-s
>>> 
>>> For me, "/tmp/fff" is saved sucessfully, with no error or prompt, using
>>> an encoding of utf-8 -- despite my having explicitly requested latin-1.
> >
> > I think this bug may have been fixed.  ISTR seeing the same result when
> > I tested with your recipe a few weeks ago.  With latest CVS, however, I
> > get a "Select coding system" prompt.  Can you confirm?

> This has been fixed on March 3 by Handa-san, see [1].  However, this fix
> has side effects that I find very annoying: if I visit a file containing
> only ASCII characters and insert non-ASCII characters into the buffer,
> the "Select coding system" prompt pops up as well, although I never
> asked about a specific coding system and would be completely satisfied
> with Emacs silently choosing UTF-8[2] in that case.

Oops, this is surely a bad side effect.  I've just fixed it.

---
Kenichi Handa
handa@m17n.org

bug#2317: emacs silently ignores buffer file encoding?

[Miles Bader]

(1) Start emacs -Q
(2) Visit "/tmp/fff"
(3) Insert the following chars: "θϑΘ"
(4) Set the buffer file encoding to latin1 with: C-x C-m f latin-1 RET
(5) Save the buffer: C-x C-s

For me, "/tmp/fff" is saved sucessfully, with no error or prompt, using
an encoding of utf-8 -- despite my having explicitly requested latin-1.

This doesn't seem right...

-Miles

-- 
Patience, n. A minor form of despair, disguised as a virtue.