org-capture-kill uses the kill ring

org-capture-kill uses the kill ring

[Allen Li]

org-capture-kill (C-c C-k) used to abort capturing puts the contents
of the capture buffer into the kill ring.

This is obstructive when the user wants to abort a capture, but save a
portion of the text into the kill ring to yank elsewhere.  The aborted
capture contents will replace the desired content.

Aborting capture should act transparently like killing a buffer.  It
shouldn't affect the kill ring.  If the user wants to keep the capture
contents, he can trivially run C-x h mark-whole-buffer M-w
kill-ring-save

Re: org-capture-kill uses the kill ring

[Kaushal Modi]

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 1311 bytes --]

On Thu, Oct 19, 2017 at 11:28 PM Allen Li <vianchielfaura@gmail.com> wrote:

> org-capture-kill (C-c C-k) used to abort capturing puts the contents
> of the capture buffer into the kill ring.
>
> This is obstructive when the user wants to abort a capture, but save a
> portion of the text into the kill ring to yank elsewhere.  The aborted
> capture contents will replace the desired content.
>

I believe that's a good fail-safe mechanism. Imagine the joy when you
realize that Org simply saved your incomplete capture in the event you kill
it by mistake!

FWIW, I have never needed to make use of that failsafe mechanism, nor have
I ever needed to copy something from my capture and then kill it. The use
case you mention seems to be very rare IMO.


> Aborting capture should act transparently like killing a buffer.  It
> shouldn't affect the kill ring.  If the user wants to keep the capture
> contents, he can trivially run C-x h mark-whole-buffer M-w
> kill-ring-save
>

You can always C-y M-y to yank your second-last kill, C-y M-y M-y for the
third-last kill, and so on ..

To summarize:
- Current behavior helps users lose their incomplete captures by mistake.
- In the event you want to copy something and deliberately kill the capture
buffer, you can always paste it with C-y M-y.
-- 

Kaushal Modi

[-- Attachment #2: Type: text/html, Size: 1938 bytes --]