bug#71049: async-shell-command ends with "Process *Async Shell Command* finished" when remote "direct-async-process"

[Michael Albinus via "Bug reports for GNU Emacs, the Swiss army knife of text editors" <bug-gnu-emacs@gnu.org>]

Dmitry Gutov <dmitry@gutov.dev> writes:

> Hi Michael,

Hi Dmitry,

>> I've puzzled the appended patch together. It does the following:
>> - Obey 'tramp-histfile-override' also for direct async processes.
>
> Thank you.

So that's consensus.

>> - Use 'tramp-histfile-override' in 'shell-mode', whether the remote
>>    history file shall be read. A value of t suppresses this.
>> - Support connection-local setting of 'tramp-histfile-override' in
>>    'shell'. Use something like
>> --8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
>>    (connection-local-set-profile-variables
>>     'remote-tramp-histfile-override '((tramp-histfile-override . nil)))
>>    (connection-local-set-profiles
>>     '(:application tramp :machine "remotehost")
>>     'remote-tramp-histfile-override)
>> --8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---
>> - Support connection-local setting of 'tramp-histfile-override' in
>>    'shell-command'. In order to distinguish this from the setting for
>>    'shell', another :application is used ('shell-command' instead of
>>    'tramp'). Use something like
>> --8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
>>    (connection-local-set-profile-variables
>>     'another-tramp-histfile-override '((tramp-histfile-override . t)))
>>    (connection-local-set-profiles
>>     '(:application shell-command :machine "remotehost")
>>     'another-tramp-histfile-override)
>> --8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---
>> It is recommended to set 'tramp-histfile-override' to t for
>> asynchronous processes. Comments?
>
> It seems like more work, and more code, to get to the same
> result.

For whom? The changes in Emacs are small.

A user doesn't need connection-local variables. Only in case, she wants
different settings for different applications, like shell and
shell-command. Otherwise, a global setting of tramp-histfile-override
would be sufficient.

> Also, it would not get the OOtB improvement for the "not M-x
> shell" case - IIUC the user would have to create a new profile to
> enact the distinction. That's a relatively complex thing to do.

No. Only if *different* values for *different* applications are
needed. And the other places in Emacs, which use shell-mode, wouldn't
profit (yet) from connection-local variables, but they would profit from
tramp-histfile-override setting in general. This is an improvement to
the status quo.

If we believe that tramp-histfile-override shall be set to t for remote
shell-command by default, I could add this. But this isn't my decision.

> So... it's not up to me, and the problem doesn't touch me too deeply,
> but I think my solution for the second part is preferable.

You mean shell-no-start-prog.diff? That hard-codes a different behavior
in shell-mode, and I'm not so familiar with shell-mode and comint that I
can exclude collateral damages.

> Maybe Eli will want to make that choice now.

Let's see.

> Thanks,
> Dmitry

Best regards, Michael.