Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Shyam Nath]

🖖 Hello World,



Goto `emacs -Q -nw`, type ";\r", or ";\n", and it indents the semicolon (alot); how do I stop this?



LIVE LONG AND PROSPER \V/,
AGENT S.
🕴
Migrating Infestive Bugs !!

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Eli Zaretskii]

> Date: Wed, 11 Sep 2019 03:36:59 +1000
> From: Shyam Nath <shyam@shyam.id.au>
> 
> Goto `emacs -Q -nw`, type ";\r", or ";\n", and it indents the semicolon (alot); how do I stop this?

Disable electric-indent-mode.

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Noam Postavsky]

On Tue, 10 Sep 2019 at 14:04, Shyam Nath <shyam@shyam.id.au> wrote:
> Goto `emacs -Q -nw`, type ";\r", or ";\n", and it indents the semicolon (alot); how do I stop this?

Type ";;\n" instead.

See (info "(elisp) Comment Tips")

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Shyam Nath]

🖖 Hello Noam,



Sorry, I didn't see this; thanks for the tips!



LIVE LONG AND PROSPER \V/,
AGENT S.
🕴
Migrating Infestive Bugs !!



---- On Wed, 11 Sep 2019 04:22:41 +1000 Noam Postavsky <npostavs@gmail.com> wrote ----


On Tue, 10 Sep 2019 at 14:04, Shyam Nath <mailto:shyam@shyam.id.au> wrote: 
> Goto `emacs -Q -nw`, type ";\r", or ";\n", and it indents the semicolon (alot); how do I stop this? 
 
Type ";;\n" instead. 
 
See (info "(elisp) Comment Tips")

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Shyam Nath]

PS:



I just figured it out; it's the Elisp way!



/^;[^;]/ is not the Elisp way ∵ *scratch* only has /^;;/, and there's some esoteric law about /[^;];[^;]/ only being inlined after an instruction, reminiscent of the syntax of C; 'tis the UNIX way, reminding us the Elisp Machine Accumulates C Supplements.



So `(setq electric-indent-mode nil)` disables it, and I thought it also disables all tabbing; this seems disabled in Elisp, but not plain text files, and http://ergoemacs.org/emacs/emacs_tabs_space_indentation_setup.html patches it. The documentation for electric-indent-mode says "If called from Lisp, enable the mode if ARG is omitted or nil.", but nil disables it; /implementation|typographical/ bug. Someone at #emacs mentioned electric-indent-mode, but my browser crashed, and webchat doesn't have private logging (into
 web storage on the client side; please make this happen, but I won't 
need it when I learn ERC; which hopefully shouldn't be long from now).



Anyway, this is probably a bug; goto `emacs -Q -nw`, type ";\t", and it indents the semicolon (alot); how do I stop this?



---- On Wed, 11 Sep 2019 03:36:59 +1000 Shyam Nath <shyam@shyam.id.au> wrote ----



🖖 Hello World,



Goto `emacs -Q -nw`, type ";\r", or ";\n", and it indents the semicolon (alot); how do I stop this?



LIVE LONG AND PROSPER \V/,
AGENT S.
🕴
Migrating Infestive Bugs !!

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Noam Postavsky]

On Tue, 10 Sep 2019 at 14:42, Shyam Nath <shyam@shyam.id.au> wrote:

> So `(setq electric-indent-mode nil)` disables it, and I thought it also disables all tabbing; this seems disabled in Elisp, but not plain text files, and http://ergoemacs.org/emacs/emacs_tabs_space_indentation_setup.html patches it. The documentation for electric-indent-mode says "If called from Lisp, enable the mode if ARG is omitted or nil.", but nil disables it; /implementation|typographical/ bug.

The documentation you refer to is about the function, i.e.,
`(electric-indent-mode)` or `(electric-indent-mode nil)` will enable
the mode. Use `(electric-indent-mode -1)` to disable it.

Using setq on the variable won't do the right thing, as mentioned in
its documentation:

Setting this variable directly does not take effect;
either customize it (see the info node ‘Easy Customization’)
or call the function ‘electric-indent-mode’.

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Shyam Nath]

🖖 Hello Noam,



Thanks, I've changed it in my init.el file, but the way I was doing it before also worked; `C-h f electric-indent-mode` in 26.1 doesn't include any of that for me.



LIVE LONG AND PROSPER \V/,
AGENT S.
🕴
Migrating Infestive Bugs !!



---- On Wed, 11 Sep 2019 05:10:52 +1000 Noam Postavsky <npostavs@gmail.com> wrote ----


On Tue, 10 Sep 2019 at 14:42, Shyam Nath <mailto:shyam@shyam.id.au> wrote: 
 
> So `(setq electric-indent-mode nil)` disables it, and I thought it also disables all tabbing; this seems disabled in Elisp, but not plain text files, and http://ergoemacs.org/emacs/emacs_tabs_space_indentation_setup.html patches it. The documentation for electric-indent-mode says "If called from Lisp, enable the mode if ARG is omitted or nil.", but nil disables it; /implementation|typographical/ bug. 
 
The documentation you refer to is about the function, i.e., 
`(electric-indent-mode)` or `(electric-indent-mode nil)` will enable 
the mode. Use `(electric-indent-mode -1)` to disable it. 
 
Using setq on the variable won't do the right thing, as mentioned in 
its documentation: 
 
Setting this variable directly does not take effect; 
either customize it (see the info node ‘Easy Customization’) 
or call the function ‘electric-indent-mode’.

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[Noam Postavsky]

On Tue, 10 Sep 2019 at 15:43, Shyam Nath <shyam@shyam.id.au> wrote:

> Thanks, I've changed it in my init.el file, but the way I was doing it before also worked;

I thought you said "this seems disabled in Elisp, but not plain text files".

> `C-h f electric-indent-mode` in 26.1 doesn't include any of that for me.

Try `C-h v electric-indent-mode` to see the variable documentation, or
`C-h o electric-indent-mode` to see both.

Re: Is this a bug, the esoteric Elisp way?

[shyam]

🖖 Hello Noam,



I meant all tabbing is disabled in Elisp, but not plain text files; thanks for the *Help*.



LIVE LONG AND PROSPER \V/,
AGENT S.
🕴
Migrating Infestive Bugs !!



---- On Wed, 11 Sep 2019 05:48:43 +1000 Noam Postavsky <npostavs@gmail.com> wrote ----


On Tue, 10 Sep 2019 at 15:43, Shyam Nath <mailto:shyam@shyam.id.au> wrote: 
 
> Thanks, I've changed it in my init.el file, but the way I was doing it before also worked; 
 
I thought you said "this seems disabled in Elisp, but not plain text files". 
 
> `C-h f electric-indent-mode` in 26.1 doesn't include any of that for me. 
 
Try `C-h v electric-indent-mode` to see the variable documentation, or 
`C-h o electric-indent-mode` to see both.