* bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 @ 2016-10-15 10:42 Georges Ko 2016-10-15 12:17 ` Eli Zaretskii 0 siblings, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread From: Georges Ko @ 2016-10-15 10:42 UTC (permalink / raw) To: 24699 These characters should have a char-width of 2, for consistency? 1 | 🌡 | #x1F321 (127777) | THERMOMETER 1 | 🌢 | #x1F322 (127778) | BLACK DROPLET 1 | 🌣 | #x1F323 (127779) | WHITE SUN 1 | 🌤 | #x1F324 (127780) | WHITE SUN WITH SMALL CLOUD 1 | 🌥 | #x1F325 (127781) | WHITE SUN BEHIND CLOUD 1 | 🌦 | #x1F326 (127782) | WHITE SUN BEHIND CLOUD WITH RAIN 1 | 🌧 | #x1F327 (127783) | CLOUD WITH RAIN 1 | 🌨 | #x1F328 (127784) | CLOUD WITH SNOW 1 | 🌩 | #x1F329 (127785) | CLOUD WITH LIGHTNING 1 | 🌪 | #x1F32A (127786) | CLOUD WITH TORNADO 1 | 🌫 | #x1F32B (127787) | FOG 1 | 🌬 | #x1F32C (127788) | WIND BLOWING FACE 1 | 🌶 | #x1F336 (127798) | HOT PEPPER 1 | 🍽 | #x1F37D (127869) | FORK AND KNIFE WITH PLATE 1 | 🎔 | #x1F394 (127892) | HEART WITH TIP ON THE LEFT 1 | 🎕 | #x1F395 (127893) | BOUQUET OF FLOWERS 1 | 🎖 | #x1F396 (127894) | MILITARY MEDAL 1 | 🎗 | #x1F397 (127895) | REMINDER RIBBON 1 | 🎘 | #x1F398 (127896) | MUSICAL KEYBOARD WITH JACKS 1 | 🎙 | #x1F399 (127897) | STUDIO MICROPHONE 1 | 🎚 | #x1F39A (127898) | LEVEL SLIDER 1 | 🎛 | #x1F39B (127899) | CONTROL KNOBS 1 | 🎜 | #x1F39C (127900) | BEAMED ASCENDING MUSICAL NOTES 1 | 🎝 | #x1F39D (127901) | BEAMED DESCENDING MUSICAL NOTES 1 | 🎞 | #x1F39E (127902) | FILM FRAMES 1 | 🎟 | #x1F39F (127903) | ADMISSION TICKETS 1 | 🏔 | #x1F3D4 (127956) | SNOW CAPPED MOUNTAIN 1 | 🏕 | #x1F3D5 (127957) | CAMPING 1 | 🏖 | #x1F3D6 (127958) | BEACH WITH UMBRELLA 1 | 🏗 | #x1F3D7 (127959) | BUILDING CONSTRUCTION 1 | 🏘 | #x1F3D8 (127960) | HOUSE BUILDINGS 1 | 🏙 | #x1F3D9 (127961) | CITYSCAPE 1 | 🏚 | #x1F3DA (127962) | DERELICT HOUSE BUILDING 1 | 🏛 | #x1F3DB (127963) | CLASSICAL BUILDING 1 | 🏜 | #x1F3DC (127964) | DESERT 1 | 🏝 | #x1F3DD (127965) | DESERT ISLAND 1 | 🏞 | #x1F3DE (127966) | NATIONAL PARK 1 | 🏟 | #x1F3DF (127967) | STADIUM 1 | 🏱 | #x1F3F1 (127985) | WHITE PENNANT 1 | 🏲 | #x1F3F2 (127986) | BLACK PENNANT 1 | 🏳 | #x1F3F3 (127987) | WAVING WHITE FLAG 1 | 🏵 | #x1F3F5 (127989) | ROSETTE 1 | 🏶 | #x1F3F6 (127990) | BLACK ROSETTE 1 | 🏷 | #x1F3F7 (127991) | LABEL 1 | 🐀 | #x1F400 (128000) | RAT 1 | 🐁 | #x1F401 (128001) | MOUSE 1 | 🐂 | #x1F402 (128002) | OX 1 | 🐃 | #x1F403 (128003) | WATER BUFFALO 1 | 🐄 | #x1F404 (128004) | COW 1 | 🐅 | #x1F405 (128005) | TIGER 1 | 🐆 | #x1F406 (128006) | LEOPARD 1 | 🐇 | #x1F407 (128007) | RABBIT 1 | 🐈 | #x1F408 (128008) | CAT 1 | 🐉 | #x1F409 (128009) | DRAGON 1 | 🐊 | #x1F40A (128010) | CROCODILE 1 | 🐋 | #x1F40B (128011) | WHALE 1 | 🐌 | #x1F40C (128012) | SNAIL 1 | 🐍 | #x1F40D (128013) | SNAKE 1 | 🐎 | #x1F40E (128014) | HORSE 1 | 🐏 | #x1F40F (128015) | RAM 1 | 🐐 | #x1F410 (128016) | GOAT 1 | 🐑 | #x1F411 (128017) | SHEEP 1 | 🐒 | #x1F412 (128018) | MONKEY 1 | 🐓 | #x1F413 (128019) | ROOSTER 1 | 🐔 | #x1F414 (128020) | CHICKEN 1 | 🐕 | #x1F415 (128021) | DOG 1 | 🐖 | #x1F416 (128022) | PIG 1 | 🐗 | #x1F417 (128023) | BOAR 1 | 🐘 | #x1F418 (128024) | ELEPHANT 1 | 🐙 | #x1F419 (128025) | OCTOPUS 1 | 🐚 | #x1F41A (128026) | SPIRAL SHELL 1 | 🐛 | #x1F41B (128027) | BUG 1 | 🐜 | #x1F41C (128028) | ANT 1 | 🐝 | #x1F41D (128029) | HONEYBEE 1 | 🐞 | #x1F41E (128030) | LADY BEETLE 1 | 🐟 | #x1F41F (128031) | FISH 1 | 🐠 | #x1F420 (128032) | TROPICAL FISH 1 | 🐡 | #x1F421 (128033) | BLOWFISH 1 | 🐢 | #x1F422 (128034) | TURTLE 1 | 🐣 | #x1F423 (128035) | HATCHING CHICK 1 | 🐤 | #x1F424 (128036) | BABY CHICK 1 | 🐥 | #x1F425 (128037) | FRONT-FACING BABY CHICK 1 | 🐦 | #x1F426 (128038) | BIRD 1 | 🐧 | #x1F427 (128039) | PENGUIN 1 | 🐨 | #x1F428 (128040) | KOALA 1 | 🐩 | #x1F429 (128041) | POODLE 1 | 🐪 | #x1F42A (128042) | DROMEDARY CAMEL 1 | 🐫 | #x1F42B (128043) | BACTRIAN CAMEL 1 | 🐬 | #x1F42C (128044) | DOLPHIN 1 | 🐭 | #x1F42D (128045) | MOUSE FACE 1 | 🐮 | #x1F42E (128046) | COW FACE 1 | 🐯 | #x1F42F (128047) | TIGER FACE 1 | 🐰 | #x1F430 (128048) | RABBIT FACE 1 | 🐱 | #x1F431 (128049) | CAT FACE 1 | 🐲 | #x1F432 (128050) | DRAGON FACE 1 | 🐳 | #x1F433 (128051) | SPOUTING WHALE 1 | 🐴 | #x1F434 (128052) | HORSE FACE 1 | 🐵 | #x1F435 (128053) | MONKEY FACE 1 | 🐶 | #x1F436 (128054) | DOG FACE 1 | 🐷 | #x1F437 (128055) | PIG FACE 1 | 🐸 | #x1F438 (128056) | FROG FACE 1 | 🐹 | #x1F439 (128057) | HAMSTER FACE 1 | 🐺 | #x1F43A (128058) | WOLF FACE 1 | 🐻 | #x1F43B (128059) | BEAR FACE 1 | 🐼 | #x1F43C (128060) | PANDA FACE 1 | 🐽 | #x1F43D (128061) | PIG NOSE 1 | 🐾 | #x1F43E (128062) | PAW PRINTS 1 | 🐿 | #x1F43F (128063) | CHIPMUNK 1 | 👁 | #x1F441 (128065) | EYE 1 | 📽 | #x1F4FD (128253) | FILM PROJECTOR 1 | 📾 | #x1F4FE (128254) | PORTABLE STEREO 1 | 🔾 | #x1F53E (128318) | LOWER RIGHT SHADOWED WHITE CIRCLE 1 | 🔿 | #x1F53F (128319) | UPPER RIGHT SHADOWED WHITE CIRCLE 1 | 🕀 | #x1F540 (128320) | CIRCLED CROSS POMMEE 1 | 🕁 | #x1F541 (128321) | CROSS POMMEE WITH HALF-CIRCLE BELOW 1 | 🕂 | #x1F542 (128322) | CROSS POMMEE 1 | 🕃 | #x1F543 (128323) | NOTCHED LEFT SEMICIRCLE WITH THREE DOTS 1 | 🕄 | #x1F544 (128324) | NOTCHED RIGHT SEMICIRCLE WITH THREE DOTS 1 | 🕅 | #x1F545 (128325) | SYMBOL FOR MARKS CHAPTER 1 | 🕆 | #x1F546 (128326) | WHITE LATIN CROSS 1 | 🕇 | #x1F547 (128327) | HEAVY LATIN CROSS 1 | 🕈 | #x1F548 (128328) | CELTIC CROSS 1 | 🕉 | #x1F549 (128329) | OM SYMBOL 1 | 🕊 | #x1F54A (128330) | DOVE OF PEACE 1 | 🕏 | #x1F54F (128335) | BOWL OF HYGIEIA 1 | 🕨 | #x1F568 (128360) | RIGHT SPEAKER 1 | 🕩 | #x1F569 (128361) | RIGHT SPEAKER WITH ONE SOUND WAVE 1 | 🕪 | #x1F56A (128362) | RIGHT SPEAKER WITH THREE SOUND WAVES 1 | 🕫 | #x1F56B (128363) | BULLHORN 1 | 🕬 | #x1F56C (128364) | BULLHORN WITH SOUND WAVES 1 | 🕭 | #x1F56D (128365) | RINGING BELL 1 | 🕮 | #x1F56E (128366) | BOOK 1 | 🕯 | #x1F56F (128367) | CANDLE 1 | 🕰 | #x1F570 (128368) | MANTELPIECE CLOCK 1 | 🕱 | #x1F571 (128369) | BLACK SKULL AND CROSSBONES 1 | 🕲 | #x1F572 (128370) | NO PIRACY 1 | 🕳 | #x1F573 (128371) | HOLE 1 | 🕴 | #x1F574 (128372) | MAN IN BUSINESS SUIT LEVITATING 1 | 🕵 | #x1F575 (128373) | SLEUTH OR SPY 1 | 🕶 | #x1F576 (128374) | DARK SUNGLASSES 1 | 🕷 | #x1F577 (128375) | SPIDER 1 | 🕸 | #x1F578 (128376) | SPIDER WEB 1 | 🕹 | #x1F579 (128377) | JOYSTICK 1 | 🕻 | #x1F57B (128379) | LEFT HAND TELEPHONE RECEIVER 1 | 🕼 | #x1F57C (128380) | TELEPHONE RECEIVER WITH PAGE 1 | 🕽 | #x1F57D (128381) | RIGHT HAND TELEPHONE RECEIVER 1 | 🕾 | #x1F57E (128382) | WHITE TOUCHTONE TELEPHONE 1 | 🕿 | #x1F57F (128383) | BLACK TOUCHTONE TELEPHONE 1 | 🖀 | #x1F580 (128384) | TELEPHONE ON TOP OF MODEM 1 | 🖁 | #x1F581 (128385) | CLAMSHELL MOBILE PHONE 1 | 🖂 | #x1F582 (128386) | BACK OF ENVELOPE 1 | 🖃 | #x1F583 (128387) | STAMPED ENVELOPE 1 | 🖄 | #x1F584 (128388) | ENVELOPE WITH LIGHTNING 1 | 🖅 | #x1F585 (128389) | FLYING ENVELOPE 1 | 🖆 | #x1F586 (128390) | PEN OVER STAMPED ENVELOPE 1 | 🖇 | #x1F587 (128391) | LINKED PAPERCLIPS 1 | 🖈 | #x1F588 (128392) | BLACK PUSHPIN 1 | 🖉 | #x1F589 (128393) | LOWER LEFT PENCIL 1 | 🖊 | #x1F58A (128394) | LOWER LEFT BALLPOINT PEN 1 | 🖋 | #x1F58B (128395) | LOWER LEFT FOUNTAIN PEN 1 | 🖌 | #x1F58C (128396) | LOWER LEFT PAINTBRUSH 1 | 🖍 | #x1F58D (128397) | LOWER LEFT CRAYON 1 | 🖎 | #x1F58E (128398) | LEFT WRITING HAND 1 | 🖏 | #x1F58F (128399) | TURNED OK HAND SIGN 1 | 🖐 | #x1F590 (128400) | RAISED HAND WITH FINGERS SPLAYED 1 | 🖑 | #x1F591 (128401) | REVERSED RAISED HAND WITH FINGERS SPLAYED 1 | 🖒 | #x1F592 (128402) | REVERSED THUMBS UP SIGN 1 | 🖓 | #x1F593 (128403) | REVERSED THUMBS DOWN SIGN 1 | 🖔 | #x1F594 (128404) | REVERSED VICTORY HAND 1 | 🖗 | #x1F597 (128407) | WHITE DOWN POINTING LEFT HAND INDEX 1 | 🖘 | #x1F598 (128408) | SIDEWAYS WHITE LEFT POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖙 | #x1F599 (128409) | SIDEWAYS WHITE RIGHT POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖚 | #x1F59A (128410) | SIDEWAYS BLACK LEFT POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖛 | #x1F59B (128411) | SIDEWAYS BLACK RIGHT POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖜 | #x1F59C (128412) | BLACK LEFT POINTING BACKHAND INDEX 1 | 🖝 | #x1F59D (128413) | BLACK RIGHT POINTING BACKHAND INDEX 1 | 🖞 | #x1F59E (128414) | SIDEWAYS WHITE UP POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖟 | #x1F59F (128415) | SIDEWAYS WHITE DOWN POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖠 | #x1F5A0 (128416) | SIDEWAYS BLACK UP POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖡 | #x1F5A1 (128417) | SIDEWAYS BLACK DOWN POINTING INDEX 1 | 🖢 | #x1F5A2 (128418) | BLACK UP POINTING BACKHAND INDEX 1 | 🖣 | #x1F5A3 (128419) | BLACK DOWN POINTING BACKHAND INDEX 1 | 🖥 | #x1F5A5 (128421) | DESKTOP COMPUTER 1 | 🖦 | #x1F5A6 (128422) | KEYBOARD AND MOUSE 1 | 🖧 | #x1F5A7 (128423) | THREE NETWORKED COMPUTERS 1 | 🖨 | #x1F5A8 (128424) | PRINTER 1 | 🖩 | #x1F5A9 (128425) | POCKET CALCULATOR 1 | 🖪 | #x1F5AA (128426) | BLACK HARD SHELL FLOPPY DISK 1 | 🖫 | #x1F5AB (128427) | WHITE HARD SHELL FLOPPY DISK 1 | 🖬 | #x1F5AC (128428) | SOFT SHELL FLOPPY DISK 1 | 🖭 | #x1F5AD (128429) | TAPE CARTRIDGE 1 | 🖮 | #x1F5AE (128430) | WIRED KEYBOARD 1 | 🖯 | #x1F5AF (128431) | ONE BUTTON MOUSE 1 | 🖰 | #x1F5B0 (128432) | TWO BUTTON MOUSE 1 | 🖱 | #x1F5B1 (128433) | THREE BUTTON MOUSE 1 | 🖲 | #x1F5B2 (128434) | TRACKBALL 1 | 🖳 | #x1F5B3 (128435) | OLD PERSONAL COMPUTER 1 | 🖴 | #x1F5B4 (128436) | HARD DISK 1 | 🖵 | #x1F5B5 (128437) | SCREEN 1 | 🖶 | #x1F5B6 (128438) | PRINTER ICON 1 | 🖷 | #x1F5B7 (128439) | FAX ICON 1 | 🖸 | #x1F5B8 (128440) | OPTICAL DISC ICON 1 | 🖹 | #x1F5B9 (128441) | DOCUMENT WITH TEXT 1 | 🖺 | #x1F5BA (128442) | DOCUMENT WITH TEXT AND PICTURE 1 | 🖻 | #x1F5BB (128443) | DOCUMENT WITH PICTURE 1 | 🖼 | #x1F5BC (128444) | FRAME WITH PICTURE 1 | 🖽 | #x1F5BD (128445) | FRAME WITH TILES 1 | 🖾 | #x1F5BE (128446) | FRAME WITH AN X 1 | 🖿 | #x1F5BF (128447) | BLACK FOLDER 1 | 🗀 | #x1F5C0 (128448) | FOLDER 1 | 🗁 | #x1F5C1 (128449) | OPEN FOLDER 1 | 🗂 | #x1F5C2 (128450) | CARD INDEX DIVIDERS 1 | 🗃 | #x1F5C3 (128451) | CARD FILE BOX 1 | 🗄 | #x1F5C4 (128452) | FILE CABINET 1 | 🗅 | #x1F5C5 (128453) | EMPTY NOTE 1 | 🗆 | #x1F5C6 (128454) | EMPTY NOTE PAGE 1 | 🗇 | #x1F5C7 (128455) | EMPTY NOTE PAD 1 | 🗈 | #x1F5C8 (128456) | NOTE 1 | 🗉 | #x1F5C9 (128457) | NOTE PAGE 1 | 🗊 | #x1F5CA (128458) | NOTE PAD 1 | 🗋 | #x1F5CB (128459) | EMPTY DOCUMENT 1 | 🗌 | #x1F5CC (128460) | EMPTY PAGE 1 | 🗍 | #x1F5CD (128461) | EMPTY PAGES 1 | 🗎 | #x1F5CE (128462) | DOCUMENT 1 | 🗏 | #x1F5CF (128463) | PAGE 1 | 🗐 | #x1F5D0 (128464) | PAGES 1 | 🗑 | #x1F5D1 (128465) | WASTEBASKET 1 | 🗒 | #x1F5D2 (128466) | SPIRAL NOTE PAD 1 | 🗓 | #x1F5D3 (128467) | SPIRAL CALENDAR PAD 1 | 🗔 | #x1F5D4 (128468) | DESKTOP WINDOW 1 | 🗕 | #x1F5D5 (128469) | MINIMIZE 1 | 🗖 | #x1F5D6 (128470) | MAXIMIZE 1 | 🗗 | #x1F5D7 (128471) | OVERLAP 1 | 🗘 | #x1F5D8 (128472) | CLOCKWISE RIGHT AND LEFT SEMICIRCLE ARROWS 1 | 🗙 | #x1F5D9 (128473) | CANCELLATION X 1 | 🗚 | #x1F5DA (128474) | INCREASE FONT SIZE SYMBOL 1 | 🗛 | #x1F5DB (128475) | DECREASE FONT SIZE SYMBOL 1 | 🗜 | #x1F5DC (128476) | COMPRESSION 1 | 🗝 | #x1F5DD (128477) | OLD KEY 1 | 🗞 | #x1F5DE (128478) | ROLLED-UP NEWSPAPER 1 | 🗟 | #x1F5DF (128479) | PAGE WITH CIRCLED TEXT 1 | 🗠 | #x1F5E0 (128480) | STOCK CHART 1 | 🗡 | #x1F5E1 (128481) | DAGGER KNIFE 1 | 🗢 | #x1F5E2 (128482) | LIPS 1 | 🗣 | #x1F5E3 (128483) | SPEAKING HEAD IN SILHOUETTE 1 | 🗤 | #x1F5E4 (128484) | THREE RAYS ABOVE 1 | 🗥 | #x1F5E5 (128485) | THREE RAYS BELOW 1 | 🗦 | #x1F5E6 (128486) | THREE RAYS LEFT 1 | 🗧 | #x1F5E7 (128487) | THREE RAYS RIGHT 1 | 🗨 | #x1F5E8 (128488) | LEFT SPEECH BUBBLE 1 | 🗩 | #x1F5E9 (128489) | RIGHT SPEECH BUBBLE 1 | 🗪 | #x1F5EA (128490) | TWO SPEECH BUBBLES 1 | 🗫 | #x1F5EB (128491) | THREE SPEECH BUBBLES 1 | 🗬 | #x1F5EC (128492) | LEFT THOUGHT BUBBLE 1 | 🗭 | #x1F5ED (128493) | RIGHT THOUGHT BUBBLE 1 | 🗮 | #x1F5EE (128494) | LEFT ANGER BUBBLE 1 | 🗯 | #x1F5EF (128495) | RIGHT ANGER BUBBLE 1 | 🗰 | #x1F5F0 (128496) | MOOD BUBBLE 1 | 🗱 | #x1F5F1 (128497) | LIGHTNING MOOD BUBBLE 1 | 🗲 | #x1F5F2 (128498) | LIGHTNING MOOD 1 | 🗳 | #x1F5F3 (128499) | BALLOT BOX WITH BALLOT 1 | 🗴 | #x1F5F4 (128500) | BALLOT SCRIPT X 1 | 🗵 | #x1F5F5 (128501) | BALLOT BOX WITH SCRIPT X 1 | 🗶 | #x1F5F6 (128502) | BALLOT BOLD SCRIPT X 1 | 🗷 | #x1F5F7 (128503) | BALLOT BOX WITH BOLD SCRIPT X 1 | 🗸 | #x1F5F8 (128504) | LIGHT CHECK MARK 1 | 🗹 | #x1F5F9 (128505) | BALLOT BOX WITH BOLD CHECK 1 | 🗺 | #x1F5FA (128506) | WORLD MAP 1 | 🙐 | #x1F650 (128592) | NORTH WEST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙑 | #x1F651 (128593) | SOUTH WEST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙒 | #x1F652 (128594) | NORTH EAST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙓 | #x1F653 (128595) | SOUTH EAST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙔 | #x1F654 (128596) | TURNED NORTH WEST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙕 | #x1F655 (128597) | TURNED SOUTH WEST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙖 | #x1F656 (128598) | TURNED NORTH EAST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙗 | #x1F657 (128599) | TURNED SOUTH EAST POINTING LEAF 1 | 🙘 | #x1F658 (128600) | NORTH WEST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙙 | #x1F659 (128601) | SOUTH WEST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙚 | #x1F65A (128602) | NORTH EAST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙛 | #x1F65B (128603) | SOUTH EAST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙜 | #x1F65C (128604) | HEAVY NORTH WEST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙝 | #x1F65D (128605) | HEAVY SOUTH WEST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙞 | #x1F65E (128606) | HEAVY NORTH EAST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙟 | #x1F65F (128607) | HEAVY SOUTH EAST POINTING VINE LEAF 1 | 🙠 | #x1F660 (128608) | NORTH WEST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙡 | #x1F661 (128609) | SOUTH WEST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙢 | #x1F662 (128610) | NORTH EAST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙣 | #x1F663 (128611) | SOUTH EAST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙤 | #x1F664 (128612) | HEAVY NORTH WEST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙥 | #x1F665 (128613) | HEAVY SOUTH WEST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙦 | #x1F666 (128614) | HEAVY NORTH EAST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙧 | #x1F667 (128615) | HEAVY SOUTH EAST POINTING BUD 1 | 🙨 | #x1F668 (128616) | HOLLOW QUILT SQUARE ORNAMENT 1 | 🙩 | #x1F669 (128617) | HOLLOW QUILT SQUARE ORNAMENT IN BLACK SQUARE 1 | 🙪 | #x1F66A (128618) | SOLID QUILT SQUARE ORNAMENT 1 | 🙫 | #x1F66B (128619) | SOLID QUILT SQUARE ORNAMENT IN BLACK SQUARE 1 | 🙬 | #x1F66C (128620) | LEFTWARDS ROCKET 1 | 🙭 | #x1F66D (128621) | UPWARDS ROCKET 1 | 🙮 | #x1F66E (128622) | RIGHTWARDS ROCKET 1 | 🙯 | #x1F66F (128623) | DOWNWARDS ROCKET 1 | 🙰 | #x1F670 (128624) | SCRIPT LIGATURE ET ORNAMENT 1 | 🙱 | #x1F671 (128625) | HEAVY SCRIPT LIGATURE ET ORNAMENT 1 | 🙲 | #x1F672 (128626) | LIGATURE OPEN ET ORNAMENT 1 | 🙳 | #x1F673 (128627) | HEAVY LIGATURE OPEN ET ORNAMENT 1 | 🙴 | #x1F674 (128628) | HEAVY AMPERSAND ORNAMENT 1 | 🙵 | #x1F675 (128629) | SWASH AMPERSAND ORNAMENT 1 | 🙶 | #x1F676 (128630) | SANS-SERIF HEAVY DOUBLE TURNED COMMA QUOTATION MARK ORNAMENT 1 | 🙷 | #x1F677 (128631) | SANS-SERIF HEAVY DOUBLE COMMA QUOTATION MARK ORNAMENT 1 | 🙸 | #x1F678 (128632) | SANS-SERIF HEAVY LOW DOUBLE COMMA QUOTATION MARK ORNAMENT 1 | 🙹 | #x1F679 (128633) | HEAVY INTERROBANG ORNAMENT 1 | 🙺 | #x1F67A (128634) | SANS-SERIF INTERROBANG ORNAMENT 1 | 🙻 | #x1F67B (128635) | HEAVY SANS-SERIF INTERROBANG ORNAMENT 1 | 🙼 | #x1F67C (128636) | VERY HEAVY SOLIDUS 1 | 🙽 | #x1F67D (128637) | VERY HEAVY REVERSE SOLIDUS 1 | 🙾 | #x1F67E (128638) | CHECKER BOARD 1 | 🙿 | #x1F67F (128639) | REVERSE CHECKER BOARD 1 | 🛆 | #x1F6C6 (128710) | TRIANGLE WITH ROUNDED CORNERS 1 | 🛇 | #x1F6C7 (128711) | PROHIBITED SIGN 1 | 🛈 | #x1F6C8 (128712) | CIRCLED INFORMATION SOURCE 1 | 🛉 | #x1F6C9 (128713) | BOYS SYMBOL 1 | 🛊 | #x1F6CA (128714) | GIRLS SYMBOL 1 | 🛋 | #x1F6CB (128715) | COUCH AND LAMP 1 | 🛍 | #x1F6CD (128717) | SHOPPING BAGS 1 | 🛎 | #x1F6CE (128718) | BELLHOP BELL 1 | 🛏 | #x1F6CF (128719) | BED 1 | 🛠 | #x1F6E0 (128736) | HAMMER AND WRENCH 1 | 🛡 | #x1F6E1 (128737) | SHIELD 1 | 🛢 | #x1F6E2 (128738) | OIL DRUM 1 | 🛣 | #x1F6E3 (128739) | MOTORWAY 1 | 🛤 | #x1F6E4 (128740) | RAILWAY TRACK 1 | 🛥 | #x1F6E5 (128741) | MOTOR BOAT 1 | 🛦 | #x1F6E6 (128742) | UP-POINTING MILITARY AIRPLANE 1 | 🛧 | #x1F6E7 (128743) | UP-POINTING AIRPLANE 1 | 🛨 | #x1F6E8 (128744) | UP-POINTING SMALL AIRPLANE 1 | 🛩 | #x1F6E9 (128745) | SMALL AIRPLANE 1 | 🛪 | #x1F6EA (128746) | NORTHEAST-POINTING AIRPLANE 1 | 🛰 | #x1F6F0 (128752) | SATELLITE 1 | 🛱 | #x1F6F1 (128753) | ONCOMING FIRE ENGINE 1 | 🛲 | #x1F6F2 (128754) | DIESEL LOCOMOTIVE 1 | 🛳 | #x1F6F3 (128755) | PASSENGER SHIP How about those two sets below? 1 | 🜀 | #x1F700 (128768) | ALCHEMICAL SYMBOL FOR QUINTESSENCE to 1 | 🝳 | #x1F773 (128883) | ALCHEMICAL SYMBOL FOR HALF OUNCE and 1 | 🞀 | #x1F780 (128896) | BLACK LEFT-POINTING ISOSCELES RIGHT TRIANGLE to 1 | 🢭 | #x1F8AD (129197) | WHITE ARROW SHAFT WIDTH TWO THIRDS Georges -- Georges Ko gko@gko.net 2016-10-15 ^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread
* bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 2016-10-15 10:42 bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 Georges Ko @ 2016-10-15 12:17 ` Eli Zaretskii 2016-10-15 14:31 ` Georges Ko 0 siblings, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread From: Eli Zaretskii @ 2016-10-15 12:17 UTC (permalink / raw) To: Georges Ko; +Cc: 24699 > From: Georges Ko <gko@gko.net> > Date: Sat, 15 Oct 2016 18:42:34 +0800 > > These characters should have a char-width of 2, for consistency? I'm not sure what consistency you have in mind. We use the data in the Unicode file EastAsianWidth.txt to determine which characters should have a char-width of 2. The characters you mention are not East-Asian characters, and therefore do not get 2 as their width. And at least some of them, e.g. U+1F5A0, are of the same width on my screen as Latin letters, so 2 would be wrong for them. Can you tell what practical problem in Emacs are you trying to solve? ^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread
* bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 2016-10-15 12:17 ` Eli Zaretskii @ 2016-10-15 14:31 ` Georges Ko 2016-10-15 15:05 ` Eli Zaretskii 0 siblings, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread From: Georges Ko @ 2016-10-15 14:31 UTC (permalink / raw) To: 24699 Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes: >> These characters should have a char-width of 2, for consistency? > > I'm not sure what consistency you have in mind. By consistency, I meant consistency with the characters of the same "type", and by that I mean in the same code point block. > We use the data in the Unicode file EastAsianWidth.txt to determine > which characters should have a char-width of 2. The characters you > mention are not East-Asian characters, and therefore do not get 2 as > their width. And at least some of them, e.g. U+1F5A0, are of the same > width on my screen as Latin letters, so 2 would be wrong for them. Oh OK, that explains the widths, but some are of width 2 (see output at the end of this post). I checked this EastAsianWidth.txt in http://www.unicode.org/Public/UCD/latest/ucd/EastAsianWidth.txt: MAPLE LEAF (#x1F341) and BEAR FACE (#x1F43B) are listed: 1F337..1F37C;W # So [70] TULIP..BABY BOTTLE 1F400..1F43E;W # So [63] RAT..PAW PRINTS So BEAR FACE and MAPLE LEAF should be of the same width, but they are not in Emacs: (char-width ?🍁) => 2 (char-width ?🐻) => 1 Could the EastAsianWidth.txt (not found in Emacs sources) used to generate was an old version? Is the generated output in characters.el starting from this line? ;; 2: East Asian Wide and Full-width characters. (let ((l '((#x1100 . #x115F) . . . See below the discrepancies between EastAsianWidth.txt data (from URL) and actual char-width at the end of this post, just for this block, which match the 63 RAT to RAW PRINTS code points. > Can you tell what practical problem in Emacs are you trying to solve? A side effect of having non-consistent char-width is badly aligned org-mode tables. A table with a MAPLE LEAF (width=2) and a BEAR FACE (width=1) is aligned like this by org-mode: | Char | Name | |------+------------| | 🍁 | MAPLE LEAF | | 🐻 | BEAR FACE | 2 and 3 spaces after MAPLE LEAF and BEAR FACE due to char-width difference, so I have to add things like this to mitigate that: (set-char-table-range char-width-table '(?🐻 . ?🐻) 2) Block Miscellaneous Symbols and Pictographs: E = EastAsianWidth.txt (2=W, 1=N) and W = (char-width c) E | W | Char | Code Point | Name --+---+-------+------------------+------------------------------- 2 | 1 | 🐀 | #x1F400 (128000) | RAT 2 | 1 | 🐁 | #x1F401 (128001) | MOUSE 2 | 1 | 🐂 | #x1F402 (128002) | OX 2 | 1 | 🐃 | #x1F403 (128003) | WATER BUFFALO 2 | 1 | 🐄 | #x1F404 (128004) | COW 2 | 1 | 🐅 | #x1F405 (128005) | TIGER 2 | 1 | 🐆 | #x1F406 (128006) | LEOPARD 2 | 1 | 🐇 | #x1F407 (128007) | RABBIT 2 | 1 | 🐈 | #x1F408 (128008) | CAT 2 | 1 | 🐉 | #x1F409 (128009) | DRAGON 2 | 1 | 🐊 | #x1F40A (128010) | CROCODILE 2 | 1 | 🐋 | #x1F40B (128011) | WHALE 2 | 1 | 🐌 | #x1F40C (128012) | SNAIL 2 | 1 | 🐍 | #x1F40D (128013) | SNAKE 2 | 1 | 🐎 | #x1F40E (128014) | HORSE 2 | 1 | 🐏 | #x1F40F (128015) | RAM 2 | 1 | 🐐 | #x1F410 (128016) | GOAT 2 | 1 | 🐑 | #x1F411 (128017) | SHEEP 2 | 1 | 🐒 | #x1F412 (128018) | MONKEY 2 | 1 | 🐓 | #x1F413 (128019) | ROOSTER 2 | 1 | 🐔 | #x1F414 (128020) | CHICKEN 2 | 1 | 🐕 | #x1F415 (128021) | DOG 2 | 1 | 🐖 | #x1F416 (128022) | PIG 2 | 1 | 🐗 | #x1F417 (128023) | BOAR 2 | 1 | 🐘 | #x1F418 (128024) | ELEPHANT 2 | 1 | 🐙 | #x1F419 (128025) | OCTOPUS 2 | 1 | 🐚 | #x1F41A (128026) | SPIRAL SHELL 2 | 1 | 🐛 | #x1F41B (128027) | BUG 2 | 1 | 🐜 | #x1F41C (128028) | ANT 2 | 1 | 🐝 | #x1F41D (128029) | HONEYBEE 2 | 1 | 🐞 | #x1F41E (128030) | LADY BEETLE 2 | 1 | 🐟 | #x1F41F (128031) | FISH 2 | 1 | 🐠 | #x1F420 (128032) | TROPICAL FISH 2 | 1 | 🐡 | #x1F421 (128033) | BLOWFISH 2 | 1 | 🐢 | #x1F422 (128034) | TURTLE 2 | 1 | 🐣 | #x1F423 (128035) | HATCHING CHICK 2 | 1 | 🐤 | #x1F424 (128036) | BABY CHICK 2 | 1 | 🐥 | #x1F425 (128037) | FRONT-FACING BABY CHICK 2 | 1 | 🐦 | #x1F426 (128038) | BIRD 2 | 1 | 🐧 | #x1F427 (128039) | PENGUIN 2 | 1 | 🐨 | #x1F428 (128040) | KOALA 2 | 1 | 🐩 | #x1F429 (128041) | POODLE 2 | 1 | 🐪 | #x1F42A (128042) | DROMEDARY CAMEL 2 | 1 | 🐫 | #x1F42B (128043) | BACTRIAN CAMEL 2 | 1 | 🐬 | #x1F42C (128044) | DOLPHIN 2 | 1 | 🐭 | #x1F42D (128045) | MOUSE FACE 2 | 1 | 🐮 | #x1F42E (128046) | COW FACE 2 | 1 | 🐯 | #x1F42F (128047) | TIGER FACE 2 | 1 | 🐰 | #x1F430 (128048) | RABBIT FACE 2 | 1 | 🐱 | #x1F431 (128049) | CAT FACE 2 | 1 | 🐲 | #x1F432 (128050) | DRAGON FACE 2 | 1 | 🐳 | #x1F433 (128051) | SPOUTING WHALE 2 | 1 | 🐴 | #x1F434 (128052) | HORSE FACE 2 | 1 | 🐵 | #x1F435 (128053) | MONKEY FACE 2 | 1 | 🐶 | #x1F436 (128054) | DOG FACE 2 | 1 | 🐷 | #x1F437 (128055) | PIG FACE 2 | 1 | 🐸 | #x1F438 (128056) | FROG FACE 2 | 1 | 🐹 | #x1F439 (128057) | HAMSTER FACE 2 | 1 | 🐺 | #x1F43A (128058) | WOLF FACE 2 | 1 | 🐻 | #x1F43B (128059) | BEAR FACE 2 | 1 | 🐼 | #x1F43C (128060) | PANDA FACE 2 | 1 | 🐽 | #x1F43D (128061) | PIG NOSE 2 | 1 | 🐾 | #x1F43E (128062) | PAW PRINTS Georges -- Georges Ko gko@gko.net 2016-10-15 ^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread
* bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 2016-10-15 14:31 ` Georges Ko @ 2016-10-15 15:05 ` Eli Zaretskii 2016-10-15 16:59 ` Georges Ko 0 siblings, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread From: Eli Zaretskii @ 2016-10-15 15:05 UTC (permalink / raw) To: Georges Ko; +Cc: 24699 > From: Georges Ko <gko@gko.net> > Date: Sat, 15 Oct 2016 22:31:24 +0800 > > By consistency, I meant consistency with the characters of the same > "type", and by that I mean in the same code point block. Not all characters of a code block have the same width attribute. > Oh OK, that explains the widths, but some are of width 2 (see output at > the end of this post). I checked this EastAsianWidth.txt in > http://www.unicode.org/Public/UCD/latest/ucd/EastAsianWidth.txt: MAPLE > LEAF (#x1F341) and BEAR FACE (#x1F43B) are listed: > > 1F337..1F37C;W # So [70] TULIP..BABY BOTTLE > 1F400..1F43E;W # So [63] RAT..PAW PRINTS > > So BEAR FACE and MAPLE LEAF should be of the same width, but they are > not in Emacs: > > (char-width ?🍁) => 2 > (char-width ?🐻) => 1 Yes, the 1F400..1F43E range was missing. I now fixed that on the emacs-25 branch, so both of the above expressions return 2. > Could the EastAsianWidth.txt (not found in Emacs sources) used to > generate was an old version? It's more probable that this range was simply omitted. > Is the generated output in characters.el starting from this line? It's not aut-generated, it was written by hand. > > Can you tell what practical problem in Emacs are you trying to solve? > > A side effect of having non-consistent char-width is badly aligned > org-mode tables. A table with a MAPLE LEAF (width=2) and a BEAR FACE > (width=1) is aligned like this by org-mode: The width attribute will only help in alignment of text if the font used for these characters is monospaced, and then if the font designers indeed kept the width according to Unicode. Most fonts that support these characters are variable-pitch fonts, so you won't have any alignment anyway, unless org-table aligns columns on the pixel level, by using the pixel size of the text. > Block Miscellaneous Symbols and Pictographs: > > E = EastAsianWidth.txt (2=W, 1=N) and W = (char-width c) > > E | W | Char | Code Point | Name > --+---+-------+------------------+------------------------------- > 2 | 1 | 🐀 | #x1F400 (128000) | RAT > 2 | 1 | 🐁 | #x1F401 (128001) | MOUSE > 2 | 1 | 🐂 | #x1F402 (128002) | OX > 2 | 1 | 🐃 | #x1F403 (128003) | WATER BUFFALO > 2 | 1 | 🐄 | #x1F404 (128004) | COW > 2 | 1 | 🐅 | #x1F405 (128005) | TIGER > 2 | 1 | 🐆 | #x1F406 (128006) | LEOPARD > 2 | 1 | 🐇 | #x1F407 (128007) | RABBIT > 2 | 1 | 🐈 | #x1F408 (128008) | CAT > 2 | 1 | 🐉 | #x1F409 (128009) | DRAGON On my display, these columns are not aligned at all, even for characters whose char-width is 2. And I don't expect them to be aligned, because the font used is Symbola, which is not monospaced. OK to close this bug now? Thanks. ^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread
* bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 2016-10-15 15:05 ` Eli Zaretskii @ 2016-10-15 16:59 ` Georges Ko 2016-10-15 17:14 ` Eli Zaretskii 0 siblings, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread From: Georges Ko @ 2016-10-15 16:59 UTC (permalink / raw) To: 24699 Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes: > Not all characters of a code block have the same width attribute. OK, understood. I'll use EastAsianWidth.txt as reference. >> (char-width ?🍁) => 2 >> (char-width ?🐻) => 1 > > Yes, the 1F400..1F43E range was missing. I now fixed that on the > emacs-25 branch, so both of the above expressions return 2. OK. >> Could the EastAsianWidth.txt (not found in Emacs sources) used to >> generate was an old version? > > It's more probable that this range was simply omitted. >> Is the generated output in characters.el starting from this line? > > It's not aut-generated, it was written by hand. Shouldn't all current char-width be checked against EastAsianWidth.txt? I'll check for discrepancies... >> A side effect of having non-consistent char-width is badly aligned >> org-mode tables. A table with a MAPLE LEAF (width=2) and a BEAR FACE >> (width=1) is aligned like this by org-mode: > > The width attribute will only help in alignment of text if the font > used for these characters is monospaced, and then if the font > designers indeed kept the width according to Unicode. Most fonts that > support these characters are variable-pitch fonts, so you won't have > any alignment anyway, unless org-table aligns columns on the pixel > level, by using the pixel size of the text. > >> E | W | Char | Code Point | Name >> --+---+-------+------------------+------------------------------- >> 2 | 1 | 🐀 | #x1F400 (128000) | RAT >> 2 | 1 | 🐁 | #x1F401 (128001) | MOUSE >> 2 | 1 | 🐂 | #x1F402 (128002) | OX > > On my display, these columns are not aligned at all, even for > characters whose char-width is 2. And I don't expect them to be > aligned, because the font used is Symbola, which is not monospaced. Segoe UI Symbol seems better in this regard, unfortunately, it has less displayable characters. > OK to close this bug now? OK. Georges -- Georges Ko gko@gko.net 2016-10-16 ^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread
* bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 2016-10-15 16:59 ` Georges Ko @ 2016-10-15 17:14 ` Eli Zaretskii 0 siblings, 0 replies; 6+ messages in thread From: Eli Zaretskii @ 2016-10-15 17:14 UTC (permalink / raw) To: Georges Ko; +Cc: 24699-done > From: Georges Ko <gko@gko.net> > Date: Sun, 16 Oct 2016 00:59:39 +0800 > > >> Is the generated output in characters.el starting from this line? > > > > It's not aut-generated, it was written by hand. > > Shouldn't all current char-width be checked against EastAsianWidth.txt? > I'll check for discrepancies... Please do, and thanks. > > OK to close this bug now? > > OK. Done. Thanks for reporting this. ^ permalink raw reply [flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread
end of thread, other threads:[~2016-10-15 17:14 UTC | newest] Thread overview: 6+ messages (download: mbox.gz follow: Atom feed -- links below jump to the message on this page -- 2016-10-15 10:42 bug#24699: Some characters should have char-width of 2 Georges Ko 2016-10-15 12:17 ` Eli Zaretskii 2016-10-15 14:31 ` Georges Ko 2016-10-15 15:05 ` Eli Zaretskii 2016-10-15 16:59 ` Georges Ko 2016-10-15 17:14 ` Eli Zaretskii
Code repositories for project(s) associated with this external index https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/emacs.git https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/emacs/org-mode.git This is an external index of several public inboxes, see mirroring instructions on how to clone and mirror all data and code used by this external index.