Emacs Bug: universal argument & key-translation-map disables undo.

Emacs Bug: universal argument & key-translation-map disables undo.

[Xah Lee]

Emacs Bug: universal argument & key-translation-map disables undo.

This seems like a bug. Steps to reproduce:

• Start GNU Emacs 23.2 with “-Q”. (so it doesn't load any custome init
files.)

• Evaluate this: (define-key key-translation-map (kbd "M--") (kbd
"─")) (it lets you press 【Alt+-】 to insert a unicode char “BOX
DRAWINGS LIGHT HORIZONTAL” (U+2500).)

• Open a new buffer.

• Type 【C-u 30 M--】. (insert the char 30 times.)

• You get this error: universal-argument-other-key: Args out of range:
" ─", 0, 7

• Now, do Type 【C-u 30 M--】 again. This time, no problem.

• The worst problem is this: Now, when you try to undo, emacs says “No
further undo information”.

Notes: The exactly unicode char doesn't matter. The key used doesn't
seem to matter neither. Perhaps even unicode doesn't matter. The
problem seems to be using “key-translation-map” and with universal
argument.

 Xah

Re: Emacs Bug: universal argument & key-translation-map disables undo.

[Tassilo Horn]

Xah Lee <xahlee@gmail.com> writes:

Hi Xah,

> This seems like a bug. Steps to reproduce:
>
> • Start GNU Emacs 23.2 with “-Q”. (so it doesn't load any custome init
> files.)
>
> • Evaluate this: (define-key key-translation-map (kbd "M--") (kbd
> "─")) (it lets you press 【Alt+-】 to insert a unicode char “BOX
> DRAWINGS LIGHT HORIZONTAL” (U+2500).)
>
> • Open a new buffer.
>
> • Type 【C-u 30 M--】. (insert the char 30 times.)
>
> • You get this error: universal-argument-other-key: Args out of range:
> " ─", 0, 7

I can confirm that I get this error with Emacs 23.3.  However, it seems
to be already fixed in the current bzr trunk.  I'm not sure, but most
probably that fix has also been applied to the emacs-23 branch, so both
Emacs 24.1 and Emacs 23.5 should be ok when they are released.

Bye,
Tassilo

Re: Emacs Bug: universal argument & key-translation-map disables undo.

[Xah Lee]

On Apr 10, 11:36 pm, Tassilo Horn <tass...@member.fsf.org> wrote:
> Xah Lee <xah...@gmail.com> writes:
>
> Hi Xah,
>
> > This seems like a bug. Steps to reproduce:
>
> > • Start GNU Emacs 23.2 with “-Q”. (so it doesn't load any custome init
> > files.)
>
> > • Evaluate this: (define-key key-translation-map (kbd "M--") (kbd
> > "─")) (it lets you press 【Alt+-】 to insert a unicode char “BOX
> > DRAWINGS LIGHT HORIZONTAL” (U+2500).)
>
> > • Open a new buffer.
>
> > • Type 【C-u 30 M--】. (insert the char 30 times.)
>
> > • You get this error: universal-argument-other-key: Args out of range:
> > " ─", 0, 7
>
> I can confirm that I get this error with Emacs 23.3.  However, it seems
> to be already fixed in the current bzr trunk.  I'm not sure, but most
> probably that fix has also been applied to the emacs-23 branch, so both
> Emacs 24.1 and Emacs 23.5 should be ok when they are released.
>
> Bye,
> Tassilo

hi Tassilo,

that's interesting. Any idea what's the problem?

 Xah

Re: Emacs Bug: universal argument & key-translation-map disables undo.

[Tassilo Horn]

Xah Lee <xahlee@gmail.com> writes:

Hi Xah,

>> I can confirm that I get this error with Emacs 23.3.  However, it
>> seems to be already fixed in the current bzr trunk.  I'm not sure,
>> but most probably that fix has also been applied to the emacs-23
>> branch, so both Emacs 24.1 and Emacs 23.5 should be ok when they are
>> released.
>
> that's interesting. Any idea what's the problem?

Not really.  I grepped the ChangeLog and the bzr log for "translation"
and "universal", but I did not check the relevant diffs (lack of time).

Bye,
Tassilo