Re: garbace collection of point-markers

["Stefan Monnier <foo@acm.com>" <monnier+gnu.emacs.help/news/@flint.cs.yale.edu>]

>>>>> "Barry" == Barry Margolin <barmar@genuity.net> writes:
> Your test seems to show that the markers are *not* cleaned up by the GC.

They definitely should.  If they're not, it's a bug.
In the example posted by Pascal, it might simply be that the marker
is still referenced from the stack (more specifically, from a stack slot
which is actually dead, but the GC doesn't know it).

> Buffers keep track of the markers that point to them (so that they can be
> updated when the buffer is modified), and that keeps them from becoming
> garbage until the buffer is killed.  This would be an ideal application for
> "weak" references if Emacs Lisp had them, but AFAIK it doesn't.

Markers have been handled "weakly" for a long time and Emacs-21
additionally introduced weak hash tables.  So, AFAIK it does ;-)


        Stefan