Re: help-window-select and info-lookup-symbol

[martin rudalics <rudalics@gmx.at>]

 > Hmm.. no it wouldn't.  I wouldn't call that failing though.  One could
 > also argue that if the user switches to B and back that's a temporary
 > excursion and should have no permanent effect.  Right or Wrong depends
 > on the users expectations.  If the window was freshly created by
 > slime-display-popup-buffer the user might well expect that pressing q
 > will close it.  OTOH, some users have strange expectations; they expect
 > the exact opposite from what I would :-)

The scenario I had in mind was that (1) `display-buffer' reuses a window
as a help-window (2) in that window the user manually switches to a
buffer via `switch-to-buffer' and (3) `display-buffer' again reuses that
window as a help-window.  Typing `q' in that window now will restore the
buffer shown before (1) and not the buffer shown by (2).  In this scenario
the `switch-to-buffer' hardly counts as a "temporary excursion".

martin