Bug or filling feature?

Bug or filling feature?

[Lennart Borgman]

Why does fill-paragraph in org-mode produce something like this:

  bla bla http://some.where/ bla bla bla
                 //bla bla

The // on the second line was added by fill-paragraph and is aligned
with that on the first line. I did not change any setting. Or at least
I do not think I did. I did a customize-save-customized however, to
save another totally unrelated setting.

Re: Bug or filling feature?

[Joe Brenner]

Lennart Borgman <lennart.borgman@gmail.com> wrote:

> Why does fill-paragraph in org-mode produce something like this:
>
>   bla bla http://some.where/ bla bla bla
>                  //bla bla
>
> The // on the second line was added by fill-paragraph and is aligned
> with that on the first line. I did not change any setting. Or at least
> I do not think I did. I did a customize-save-customized however, to
> save another totally unrelated setting.


I think this is a long-standing bug (though I don't know if it's ever
been reported as one).  It comes up in a lot of contexts.

If you start with the following paragraph, and re-format it with the
fill column after the word "multiple"...

The greater than symbol: > is used for multiple purposes when one
is out riding the inner tubes.

...you end up with this:

The greater than symbol: > is used for multiple
                         > purposes when one
is out riding the inner tubes.

At a guess, this is a bad side-effect of some code that was written
for formatting quoted paragraphs in mail messages and so on.

Myself, I normally format things with fill-paragraph for its speed, but
in cases where it messes up, I use an elisp wrapper to run an external
script:

  http://groups.google.com/group/emacs-perl-intersection/browse_thread/thread/35c4c3832bef103e

Re: Bug or filling feature?

[Lennart Borgman]

On Sun, Jan 17, 2010 at 3:31 AM, Joe Brenner <doom@kzsu.stanford.edu> wrote:
>
> Lennart Borgman <lennart.borgman@gmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Why does fill-paragraph in org-mode produce something like this:
>>
>>   bla bla http://some.where/ bla bla bla
>>                  //bla bla
>>
>> The // on the second line was added by fill-paragraph and is aligned
>> with that on the first line. I did not change any setting. Or at least
>> I do not think I did. I did a customize-save-customized however, to
>> save another totally unrelated setting.
>
>
> I think this is a long-standing bug (though I don't know if it's ever
> been reported as one).  It comes up in a lot of contexts.


I think in my case it was related to something saved by
desktop-save-mode. It disappeared when I closed this org file buffer
before restarting Emacs, but unfortunately I did not save the old
desktop file. I think some fill paragraph pattern (ie
comment-start-skip) for another mode than org-mode was stored in the
desktop file for that file.

I can only guess how that happened.