Win32: Emacs 22.2 - Very slow file name completion for remote drives

Win32: Emacs 22.2 - Very slow file name completion for remote drives

[Valeriy E. Ushakov]

In GNU Emacs 22.2.1 (i386-mingw-nt5.1.2600)
 of 2008-03-26 on RELEASE
Windowing system distributor `Microsoft Corp.', version 5.1.2600
configured using `configure --with-gcc (3.4)'

I've been using ntemacs 20.x happily since 20.3, iirc, and have been
sticking with 20.7 for a while, mostly out of inertia.

I'm now trying to switch to 22.2 and I've run into a problem that
pretty much prevents me from switching.

I often work from home over VPN with files on remote drives at the
office.  The link is fast, so it's reasonably comfortable.  emacs20
takes maybe a second or two maximum to save a file or show filename
completion list (faster than it used to be on a uVAX, so I don't mind
:)

emacs22 OTOH is *extremely* slow when it comes to filename completeion
for remote drives.  It takes emacs22 some 10 to 30 seconds to print
"Making completion list..." and another dozen or two to actually come
up with the completion list.

When I'm actually saving a file, emacs22 saves it quite fast, just
like emacs20.  It's completion that is excruciatingly slow.  The set
of customizations I have is ~the same in both emacs20 and emacs22 and
starting emacs22 without loading ~/.emacs doesn't change anything -
same extremely long delay for filename completion.

Completion in emacs20 launched alongside is snappy.  Using native file
dialog in emacs22 is also fast, so I'm pretty much convinced the
problem is somewhere in read-file-name and callees.

I've traced emacs20 and emacs22 using File Monitor from SysInternals
(http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb896642.aspx) and I
see the following.

Emacs20 does for C-x C-f p:/ <TAB>

OPEN		P:\	SUCCESS	Options: Open Directory  Access: 00100001
QUERY INFO	P:\	SUCCESS	FileNameInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\	SUCCESS	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\	SUCCESS	FileFsAttributeInformation
CLOSE		P:\	SUCCESS
OPEN		P:\	SUCCESS	Options: Open Directory  Access: 00100001
DIRECTORY	P:\	SUCCESS	FileBothDirectoryInformation: *
OPEN		P:\	SUCCESS	Options: Open Directory  Access: 00100001
DIRECTORY	P:\	SUCCESS	FileBothDirectoryInformation: work
CLOSE		P:\	SUCCESS
DIRECTORY	P:\	SUCCESS	FileBothDirectoryInformation
OPEN		P:\	SUCCESS	Options: Open Directory  Access: 00100001
DIRECTORY	P:\	SUCCESS	FileBothDirectoryInformation: WINDOWS
CLOSE		P:\	SUCCESS
OPEN		P:\	SUCCESS	Options: Open Directory  Access: 00100001
DIRECTORY	P:\	SUCCESS	FileBothDirectoryInformation: tmp
CLOSE		P:\	SUCCESS
[...etc, completing under 2 secs...]



While emacs22 does:

OPEN		P:\	SUCCESS	Options: Open Directory  Access: 00100001
QUERY INFO	P:\	SUCCESS	FileNameInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\	SUCCESS	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\	SUCCESS	FileFsAttributeInformation
CLOSE		P:\	SUCCESS
OPEN		P:\	SUCCESS	Options: Open Directory  Access: 00100001
DIRECTORY	P:\	SUCCESS	FileBothDirectoryInformation: *
OPEN		P:\work	SUCCESS	Options: Open  Access: 00100080
QUERY INFO	P:\work	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\work	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileAllInformation
CLOSE		P:\work	SUCCESS
OPEN		P:\work	SUCCESS	Options: Open  Access: 00100080
QUERY INFO	P:\work	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\work	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileAllInformation
CLOSE		P:\work	SUCCESS
DIRECTORY	P:\	SUCCESS	FileBothDirectoryInformation
OPEN		P:\WINDOWS	SUCCESS	Options: Open  Access: 00100080
QUERY INFO	P:\WINDOWS	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\WINDOWS	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileAllInformation
CLOSE		P:\WINDOWS	SUCCESS
OPEN		P:\WINDOWS	SUCCESS	Options: Open  Access: 00100080
QUERY INFO	P:\WINDOWS	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\WINDOWS	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileAllInformation
CLOSE		P:\WINDOWS	SUCCESS
OPEN		P:\tmp	SUCCESS	Options: Open  Access: 00100080
QUERY INFO	P:\tmp	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\tmp	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileAllInformation
CLOSE		P:\tmp	SUCCESS
OPEN		P:\tmp	SUCCESS	Options: Open  Access: 00100080
QUERY INFO	P:\tmp	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileFsVolumeInformation
QUERY INFO	P:\tmp	BUFFER OVERFLOW	FileAllInformation
CLOSE		P:\tmp	SUCCESS
[...etc, taking about 22 secs...]

Further down the line I also see FileFsDeviceInformation calls
(besides FileFsVolumeInformation and FileAllInformation).


So with all those extra queries emacs22 only chugs along at few files
per second.

I've trested precompiled emacs21.3 binaries and it's as fast as
emacs20 and the File Monitor log is similar to emacs20 too.
Precompiled emacs22.1 is slow like 22.2.

I've looked into emacs22 sources and I don't see radical diffs from
emacs-21.4a sources for dired.c.  I wonder if something was changed in
mingw stat emulation maybe.


SY, Uwe
-- 
uwe@stderr.spb.ru                       |       Zu Grunde kommen
http://snark.ptc.spbu.ru/~uwe/          |       Ist zu Grunde gehen