yes-or-no-p and dialogs

yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Petteri Hintsanen]

Hello list,

Is there any way to "quit" yes-or-no-p queries with MS Windows dialogs?
I mean in the same way C-g would do in the minibuffer?

Case in point: I am visiting an Org file with an active (running) clock.
The file has no unsaved changes.

Then I try to close (kill) Emacs by clicking on the "X" button on the
upper right corner of the frame.

A dialog pops up, asking whether I'd like to clock out and save.  This
dialog has "Yes" or "No" buttons, but no way to cancel, as far as I can
see.

Now occasionally I'd like to interrupt Emacs quitting, and go back to my
file to adjust the clock and whatnot, but with that (modal) dialog it
seems to be impossible -- Emacs will unconditionally quit.  Should the
dialog have "Cancel" or "X" or something?  I could set use-dialog-box to
nil, but occasionally dialogs are useful.

This is Emacs 28.2 on MS Windows 10.

Thanks,
Petteri

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Petteri Hintsanen <petterih@iki.fi>
> Date: Tue, 27 Dec 2022 18:06:19 +0200
> 
> Is there any way to "quit" yes-or-no-p queries with MS Windows dialogs?
> I mean in the same way C-g would do in the minibuffer?
> 
> Case in point: I am visiting an Org file with an active (running) clock.
> The file has no unsaved changes.

What is "an active (running) clock"?  Can you show simple instructions
to reproduce this, for someone who doesn't use Org every hour of every
day?

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Thibaut Verron]

Le mar. 27 déc. 2022 à 18:07, Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> a écrit :

> > From: Petteri Hintsanen <petterih@iki.fi>
> > Date: Tue, 27 Dec 2022 18:06:19 +0200
> >
> > Is there any way to "quit" yes-or-no-p queries with MS Windows dialogs?
> > I mean in the same way C-g would do in the minibuffer?
> >
> > Case in point: I am visiting an Org file with an active (running) clock.
> > The file has no unsaved changes.
>
> What is "an active (running) clock"?  Can you show simple instructions
> to reproduce this, for someone who doesn't use Org every hour of every
> day?
>

Hi,

I'm not the original poster, but I can reproduce it by:
1. Opening a .org file
2. Creating a headline
3. Calling org-clock-in
4. Saving the buffer
5. Clicking the X to close the window

By the way, the clock is not required, the same happens with an unsaved
buffer: first there is a right-click style menu asking what to do, then at
the end, the "modified buffers exist, quit anyway?" dialog only has "yes"
and "no", no "cancel".

I agree with Petteri, imo those dialogs should have a "cancel" button.

Best wishes,
Thibaut

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Thibaut Verron <thibaut.verron@gmail.com>
> Date: Tue, 27 Dec 2022 18:37:19 +0100
> Cc: help-gnu-emacs@gnu.org
> 
> I'm not the original poster, but I can reproduce it by:
> 1. Opening a .org file

OK

> 2. Creating a headline

What does it mean? which command(s) to invoke and how?

> 3. Calling org-clock-in

What do I do here? just "M-x org-clock-in RET" or something else?

> 4. Saving the buffer
> 5. Clicking the X to close the window
> 
> By the way, the clock is not required, the same happens with an unsaved buffer: first there is a right-click
> style menu asking what to do, then at the end, the "modified buffers exist, quit anyway?" dialog only has
> "yes" and "no", no "cancel".

On my system, I see "Cancel" as the 3rd possibility, when I do this
the other way, i.e. with a buffer with unsaved changes.  So maybe this
is a Windows 10 thing.

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Thibaut Verron]

Le mar. 27 déc. 2022 à 19:13, Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> a écrit :

> On my system, I see "Cancel" as the 3rd possibility, when I do this
> the other way, i.e. with a buffer with unsaved changes.  So maybe this
> is a Windows 10 thing.
>

That's interesting, why does the windows version make a difference?

Anyway, I was wrong and the situation is not the same: with a buffer with
unsaved changed, "yes" means "exit without saving" and "no" means "don't
exit", so "no" is really the cancel button.

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Petteri Hintsanen]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

> What is "an active (running) clock"?  Can you show simple instructions
> to reproduce this, for someone who doesn't use Org every hour of every
> day?

Org-mode can clock your working time, in the same way as timeclock
package does.  Starting a clock is similar to doing M-x timeclock-in.
Actually the same issue can be replicated simply by:

- M-x timeclock-in RET
- Enter any project name.
- Quit Emacs by clicking on "X" button.
- Dialog pops up asking "You're currently clocking time, clock out?"
- No way to cancel?


For completeness, here are instructions for org-mode:

- C-x C-f foo.org RET
- Enter a headline, for example

* foo

- Move point onto the headline and do C-c C-x C-i (org-clock-in) to
  start the clock.
- Save the buffer by C-x C-s
- Quit emacs by clicking on "X" button
- Dialog pops up asking "Clock out and save?"
- No way to cancel?


However, I found an acceptable workaround: set confirm-kill-emacs to
y-or-n-p.

Thanks,
Petteri

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Eli Zaretskii]

> From: Petteri Hintsanen <petterih@iki.fi>
> Date: Tue, 27 Dec 2022 20:23:26 +0200
> 
> - M-x timeclock-in RET
> - Enter any project name.
> - Quit Emacs by clicking on "X" button.
> - Dialog pops up asking "You're currently clocking time, clock out?"
> - No way to cancel?

OK, thanks.  I've now made it show also a 3rd button "Cancel".

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Petteri Hintsanen]

Eli Zaretskii <eliz@gnu.org> writes:

> OK, thanks.  I've now made it show also a 3rd button "Cancel".

Great!  I'll use my workaround (confirm-kill-emacs) until your change is
released.

Thanks for your time.
Petteri

Re: yes-or-no-p and dialogs

[Jean Louis]

* Petteri Hintsanen <petterih@iki.fi> [2022-12-27 19:07]:
> Is there any way to "quit" yes-or-no-p queries with MS Windows dialogs?
> I mean in the same way C-g would do in the minibuffer?

(setq use-dialog-box nil) ➜ t

and now you can interrupt it by using C-g:

(y-or-n-p "OK? ")

> Then I try to close (kill) Emacs by clicking on the "X" button on the
> upper right corner of the frame.
> 
> A dialog pops up, asking whether I'd like to clock out and save.  This
> dialog has "Yes" or "No" buttons, but no way to cancel, as far as I can
> see.

I understand, that is serious usability problem. There shall be option to cancl such dialogs.

On my system I can't see them, I do not know why, even though my variable:

use-dialog-box ➜ nil

-- 
Jean

Take action in Free Software Foundation campaigns:
https://www.fsf.org/campaigns

In support of Richard M. Stallman
https://stallmansupport.org/