Which is the best java plugin for emacs?

Which is the best java plugin for emacs?

[lu]

Which is the best java plugin for emacs?
JDEE?
It seems there is no new version for 2 years,
and it seems the jdee for emacs have not been
updated for nearly 2year.
It is a good idea that gnu take over the development
of jdee because jdee seems dead.

Re: Which is the best java plugin for emacs?

[Nick Roberts]

 > Which is the best java plugin for emacs?
 > JDEE?
 > It seems there is no new version for 2 years,
 > and it seems the jdee for emacs have not been
 > updated for nearly 2year.
 > It is a good idea that gnu take over the development
 > of jdee because jdee seems dead.

Presumably by "gnu take over the development" you mean integrate it into Emacs.
If JDEE is indeed dead, I don't it would be a good idea because this would
need additional effort for the integration (over that already needed for
maintenance).  Think of GNU as a body that provides software but *needs*
resources.

-- 
Nick                                           http://www.inet.net.nz/~nickrob

Re: Which is the best java plugin for emacs?

[Tim X]

"lu@luxdo.jp" <lu@luxdo.jp> writes:

> Which is the best java plugin for emacs?
> JDEE?
> It seems there is no new version for 2 years,
> and it seems the jdee for emacs have not been
> updated for nearly 2year.
> It is a good idea that gnu take over the development
> of jdee because jdee seems dead.
>

So what problems have you found with the current version? 

I'm asking as there is a growing belief these days that if a package isn't
updated every few months, then it must be dead and unsupported. While I can
understand how this perception can arise, its not necessarily correct. For
example, it may be that the current state of JDEE is fine and works as expected
without any bugs. 

Its been over 7 years since I ran JDEE and although I'd hoped to avoid having
to do further Java development, it looks like a new Java based project is about
to land on my desk. If there are issues with the current JDEE version, I'd like
to know.


On the issue of it being taken over by GNU - thats not always an easy or viable
option. A lot will depend on how well the JDEE developers tracked code
contributions and how easily the copyright can be handed over to GNU. There are
a number of examples of packages which the GNU Emacs team wanted to put into
Emacs, but have not been able to because the original author has not been
available to sign over copyright etc. Given the financial costs of defending
even rediculous copyright claims (think SCO and Linux), the FSF are rightfully
very careful about these issues.

Tim
-- 
tcross (at) rapttech dot com dot au

Re: Which is the best java plugin for emacs?

[Galen Boyer]

On Sat, 23 Jun 2007, lu@luxdo.jp wrote:

> It is a good idea that gnu take over the development
> of jdee because jdee seems dead.

I don't think GNU can.  The JDEE depends on beanshell which is an open
source scripting engine for java and I believe that would not jive with
the GNU licensing.

-- 
Galen Boyer