From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Path: news.gmane.io!.POSTED.blaine.gmane.org!not-for-mail From: Jean Louis Newsgroups: gmane.emacs.devel Subject: Re: non-gnu elpa issue tracking Date: Wed, 9 Dec 2020 22:18:04 +0300 Message-ID: References: <20201209125516.lenqswi7fhiscbr2@E15-2016.optimum.net> Mime-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Injection-Info: ciao.gmane.io; posting-host="blaine.gmane.org:116.202.254.214"; logging-data="6171"; mail-complaints-to="usenet@ciao.gmane.io" User-Agent: Mutt/2.0 (3d08634) (2020-11-07) Cc: Boruch Baum , Emacs-Devel List To: Stefan Kangas Original-X-From: emacs-devel-bounces+ged-emacs-devel=m.gmane-mx.org@gnu.org Wed Dec 09 20:52:00 2020 Return-path: Envelope-to: ged-emacs-devel@m.gmane-mx.org Original-Received: from lists.gnu.org ([209.51.188.17]) by ciao.gmane.io with esmtps (TLS1.2:ECDHE_RSA_AES_256_GCM_SHA384:256) (Exim 4.92) (envelope-from ) id 1kn5VI-0001Rl-0a for ged-emacs-devel@m.gmane-mx.org; Wed, 09 Dec 2020 20:52:00 +0100 Original-Received: from localhost ([::1]:36602 helo=lists1p.gnu.org) by lists.gnu.org with esmtp (Exim 4.90_1) (envelope-from ) id 1kn5VH-0001to-0K for ged-emacs-devel@m.gmane-mx.org; Wed, 09 Dec 2020 14:51:59 -0500 Original-Received: from eggs.gnu.org ([2001:470:142:3::10]:38750) by lists.gnu.org with esmtps (TLS1.2:ECDHE_RSA_AES_256_GCM_SHA384:256) (Exim 4.90_1) (envelope-from ) id 1kn51h-0005m5-Vo for emacs-devel@gnu.org; Wed, 09 Dec 2020 14:21:29 -0500 Original-Received: from stw1.rcdrun.com ([217.170.207.13]:39077) by eggs.gnu.org with esmtps (TLS1.2:ECDHE_RSA_AES_256_GCM_SHA384:256) (Exim 4.90_1) (envelope-from ) id 1kn51e-0005Rr-M5 for emacs-devel@gnu.org; Wed, 09 Dec 2020 14:21:25 -0500 Original-Received: from localhost ([::ffff:41.202.241.31]) (AUTH: PLAIN securesender, TLS: TLS1.2,256bits,ECDHE_RSA_AES_256_GCM_SHA384) by stw1.rcdrun.com with ESMTPSA id 000000000001E43F.000000005FD123AE.00005139; Wed, 09 Dec 2020 12:21:18 -0700 Content-Disposition: inline In-Reply-To: Received-SPF: pass client-ip=217.170.207.13; envelope-from=bugs@gnu.support; helo=stw1.rcdrun.com X-Spam_score_int: -18 X-Spam_score: -1.9 X-Spam_bar: - X-Spam_report: (-1.9 / 5.0 requ) BAYES_00=-1.9, SPF_HELO_PASS=-0.001, SPF_PASS=-0.001 autolearn=ham autolearn_force=no X-Spam_action: no action X-BeenThere: emacs-devel@gnu.org X-Mailman-Version: 2.1.23 Precedence: list List-Id: "Emacs development discussions." List-Unsubscribe: , List-Archive: List-Post: List-Help: List-Subscribe: , Errors-To: emacs-devel-bounces+ged-emacs-devel=m.gmane-mx.org@gnu.org Original-Sender: "Emacs-devel" Xref: news.gmane.io gmane.emacs.devel:260607 Archived-At: * Stefan Kangas [2020-12-09 19:59]: > Boruch Baum writes: >=20 > > I've read sumaries of Richard Stallman's presentation about the > > proposed, and in comparing it with Stefan Monnier's in-progress web > > interface, have several suggestions: > > > > 1) License disclosure: The summaries indicate that RMS is open to having > > the repository host packages bearing *any* free license, but there > > may be users who are pickier, so a package's license should be > > disclosed prominently on the listing page and the package detail > > page; >=20 > Are there any packages out there that don't use the GPL? Could you > point us to some examples? Just to name a few, among more of them: grep --color -nH --null -e "Apache License" *.el auth-source-xoauth2-20200911.1554.el=005:;; Licensed under the Apache Licen= se, Version 2.0 (the "License"); emidje-20190209.1726.el=0016:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Version = 2.0 (the "License"); you may not use furl-20150509.316.el=0025:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0= (the "License"); go-noisegate-20200503.1358.el=0013:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Ve= rsion 2.0 (the "License"); govc-20201020.1619.el=0015:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.= 0 (the "License"); ietf-docs-20190420.851.el=0017:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Versio= n 2.0 (the "License"); mmm-jinja2-20170313.1420.el=0030:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Ve= rsion 2.0 (the "License"); you may not pack-20191017.456.el=0013:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2= =2E0 (the "License"); redpen-paragraph-20200506.1558.el=0014:;; Licensed under the Apache License= , Version 2.0 (the "License"); rust-mode-20200709.723.el=0012:;; Apache License (version 2.0). salt-mode-20200210.1227.el=0032:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Ver= sion 2.0 (the "License"); you may not sayid-20200902.708.el=0012:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.= 0 (the "License"); thrift-20201021.956.el=0012:;; to you under the Apache License, Version 2.0= (the vale-mode-20190725.125.el=0016:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Versio= n 2.0 (the "License"); wedge-ws-20140714.2149.el=0014:;; Licensed under the Apache License, Versio= n 2.0 (the "License"); Then those packages where words "Free Software Foundation" do not exist: 0x0-20201014.1445.el - public domain CC0 1.0 questionable if free in other countries but US aggressive-fill-paragraph-20181106.1354.el - no license =20 alan-mode-20200723.1405.el - MIT =20 anaphora-20180618.2200.el - public domain, in other countries can be proprietary by default =20 anki-mode-20200703.739.el - no license, proprietary by default now these below I did not check, but the pattern says that there will be many like that. In these there is no "Free Software" inside. But I did not grep well enough. Pattern above should speak for itself. annotate-20200829.1336.el annotation-20201020.717.el aria2-20190906.2226.el ascii-table-20201019.700.el asilea-20150105.1525.el aurora-config-mode-20180216.2302.el auth-source-xoauth2-20200911.1554.el auto-sudoedit-20200427.635.el autotest-20200609.1811.el autotetris-mode-20180609.111.el back-button-20150804.2004.el baff-20200824.2111.el bang-20200930.1300.el banner-comment-20190606.1809.el bap-mode-20200128.1354.el basic-c-compile-20170918.1649.el benchstat-20171014.907.el bento-20191025.2350.el biblio-bibsonomy-20190201.52.el bifocal-20200428.314.el bind-chord-20200805.1727.el bind-key-20200805.1727.el bitlbee-20151203.11.el blackboard-bold-mode-20160813.206.el blackout-20200503.1426.el bool-flip-20161215.1548.el browse-url-dwim-20140804.1922.el bufshow-20170110.323.el button-lock-20200309.1323.el cd-compile-20141108.1957.el cheatsheet-20170126.2150.el chicken-scheme-20141116.1939.el chronometrist-goal-20200906.1522.el ciel-20180914.815.el clojars-20180825.1955.el codcut-20190929.2126.el comint-hyperlink-20191104.2224.el commify-20200921.2002.el conda-20200818.1614.el config-general-mode-20171024.1840.el counsel-codesearch-20180925.803.el counsel-dash-20200103.1411.el counsel-jq-20200907.1458.el coverage-20191113.1958.el cpputils-cmake-20181006.328.el css-autoprefixer-20180311.1600.el css-comb-20160416.559.el cssh-20150810.1709.el ctrlf-20201020.1353.el cubicaltt-20181016.1157.el cucumber-goto-step-20131210.519.el currency-convert-20201017.1817.el dark-souls-20140314.2226.el dash-at-point-20180710.1356.el deft-20200515.1513.el deno-fmt-20200602.1550.el dfmt-20170728.1023.el diary-manager-20200922.1329.el didyoumean-20200905.1843.el digit-groups-20200506.37.el dired-fdclone-20180403.608.el dired-launch-20200430.1625.el dired-toggle-sudo-20200401.1353.el direnv-20200529.1305.el dirtree-prosjekt-20151127.1416.el dispass-20140202.1531.el distel-completion-lib-20180827.1344.el dmacro-20200803.635.el dpaste_de-20131015.1232.el dtk-20201006.1835.el dynamic-fonts-20140804.1922.el edit-at-point-20191013.1218.el edit-indirect-20200805.1840.el edn-20201009.1244.el egg-timer-20200314.1727.el eldoc-cmake-20190419.2244.el eldoc-overlay-20200715.1214.el elpa-clone-20191006.1953.el el-patch-20200922.1329.el emacsql-mysql-20200714.28.el emidje-20190209.1726.el emms-bilibili-20180103.418.el empos-20151011.1916.el eno-20191013.1239.el epic-20170210.23.el erc-crypt-20200520.451.el erc-view-log-20140227.2039.el eredis-20191004.1545.el eri-20201020.717.el eshell-autojump-20150927.724.el eslint-fix-20180514.700.el ethan-wspace-20190522.1448.el execline-20190711.2010.el express-20140804.1922.el exwm-surf-20171204.1140.el face-shift-20190825.1131.el fakespace-20120818.6.el fancy-dabbrev-20200129.1933.el fasd-20200925.1549.el fetch-20131201.730.el fillcode-20200524.2226.el fixmee-20200512.1530.el fix-muscle-memory-20160920.451.el flames-of-freedom-20191202.1637.el flappymacs-20171026.6.el fliptext-20171124.2056.el fm-bookmarks-20170104.1716.el font-utils-20150806.1751.el forecast-20200919.1348.el format-sql-20150422.1333.el friendly-remote-shell-20200828.1218.el friendly-shell-20200828.1218.el friendly-shell-command-20200828.1218.el friendly-tramp-path-20200502.1032.el fringe-current-line-20140111.411.el fuo-20190812.927.el furl-20150509.316.el git-time-metric-20181116.2011.el gntp-20141025.250.el go-capf-20200814.1046.el godoctor-20180710.2152.el go-errcheck-20160723.43.el go-gopath-20160705.1034.el go-guru-20200822.1936.el goldendict-20200731.1119.el golden-ratio-20191028.1732.el golint-20200302.2058.el go-noisegate-20200503.1358.el google-c-style-20200925.1727.el go-playground-cli-20160503.914.el go-rename-20200822.1936.el go-translate-20200912.212.el govc-20201020.1619.el greek-polytonic-20190303.1358.el habitica-20190721.1620.el hardhat-20160414.1413.el heaven-and-hell-20190713.1830.el helm-bitbucket-20191022.2055.el helm-catkin-20190506.1451.el helm-charinfo-20170810.1231.el helm-fuzzy-find-20171106.400.el helm-gitignore-20170211.8.el helm-itunes-20151013.648.el helm-lean-20200930.604.el helm-ls-svn-20190316.2203.el helm-nixos-options-20191126.759.el helm-prosjekt-20151127.1416.el helm-spotify-20160905.2147.el helm-sql-connect-20170319.1251.el helm-youtube-20190101.1733.el hercules-20200420.747.el hexo-20200416.1410.el hide-mode-line-20190922.115.el hidepw-20200326.112.el highlight-blocks-20190318.1557.el highlight-defined-20181106.1718.el highlight-indent-guides-20200820.2328.el highlight-numbers-20181013.1744.el highlight-quoted-20160123.1140.el hippie-namespace-20140804.1922.el historian-20200203.1927.el hlint-refactor-20190115.900.el hsluv-20181130.1607.el httprepl-20141101.1734.el http-twiddle-20160801.1915.el hyperkitty-20200927.106.el ido-exit-target-20170717.1851.el ido-load-library-20140804.1922.el ietf-docs-20190420.851.el iflipb-20200731.1655.el ignoramus-20160414.1409.el imgbb-20180609.1649.el import-js-20180709.1833.el inherit-local-20170409.1649.el inline-docs-20170523.450.el insert-shebang-20200320.1537.el ipcalc-20200809.1457.el ipretty-20180606.522.el isolate-20190808.731.el ivy-clipmenu-20200302.1419.el ivy-historian-20200203.1927.el ivy-pass-20170812.1955.el ivy-prescient-20201017.1519.el ivy-todo-20200323.2005.el ivy-xcdoc-20160917.1203.el ivy-youtube-20181126.1039.el jade-mode-20160525.1441.el javap-mode-20120223.2208.el jemdoc-mode-20170704.2027.el jg-quicknav-20170809.130.el jmt-mode-20201019.2342.el journalctl-mode-20200607.910.el jq-format-20190428.1434.el json-reformat-20161027.1407.el json-rpc-20200417.1629.el kaleidoscope-20180723.1945.el kapacitor-20190414.1908.el keydef-20090428.1931.el keyswap-20160813.957.el kfg-20140909.611.el kolon-mode-20140122.1134.el kpm-list-20170924.1352.el ksp-cfg-mode-20190414.2348.el kubel-20201020.2043.el kubernetes-helm-20190603.1533.el kurecolor-20200113.2027.el language-id-20200929.1339.el learn-ocaml-20200526.1603.el line-up-words-20200616.906.el linkode-20200819.1409.el lisp-local-20200409.1330.el lispyscript-mode-20170720.1917.el list-utils-20200502.1309.el live-preview-20201010.1948.el logpad-20190927.2043.el lusty-explorer-20200602.424.el malyon-20161208.2125.el mandoku-tls-20171118.240.el maxframe-20200617.218.el mbsync-20200128.1053.el memento-mori-20190719.1051.el memoize-20200103.2036.el meta-presenter-20190414.1720.el milkode-20140927.529.el minimal-session-saver-20140804.1922.el mix-20200920.1500.el mocha-20200729.1130.el modern-fringes-20200321.1817.el move-dup-20200819.940.el mozc-20201018.345.el mpages-20150710.1404.el multi-20131013.1544.el namespaces-20130326.2250.el name-this-color-20151014.2030.el nav-flash-20191204.1427.el nemerle-20200622.1027.el netrunner-20160910.2332.el nixos-options-20191126.759.el nix-sandbox-20191126.759.el nlinum-hl-20190301.2117.el noaa-20200420.1949.el no-emoji-20180515.1837.el ob-axiom-20200411.1031.el ob-cfengine3-20191011.1721.el ob-deno-20201019.101.el ob-diagrams-20160407.1240.el ob-elvish-20180427.1900.el ob-html-chrome-20181219.1042.el ob-mongo-20170720.1919.el ob-translate-20170720.1919.el ocamlformat-20201017.801.el ocp-indent-20191023.1304.el one-time-pad-encrypt-20160329.1513.el operate-on-number-20150707.623.el org-brain-20200930.2103.el org-clock-split-20200331.526.el org-easy-img-insert-20160915.2014.el org-fragtog-20200703.229.el org-journal-20201019.1813.el - this example is file without any license, thus proprietary. - author Bastian Bechthold, probably not intended, but in the file here is no license information org-journal-list-20190221.2052.el - no license information known, proprietary thus by default org-kanban-20200729.2120.el - no license informaiton, proprietary by default org-mobile-sync-20180606.524.el org-redmine-20170710.438.el org-rtm-20160214.1236.el org-seek-20161217.502.el org-shoplist-20201003.1236.el org-snooze-20181229.1424.el org-static-blog-20200720.715.el orgstrap-20201019.605.el org-tanglesync-20200130.2301.el org-themis-20160122.404.el origami-predef-20200823.1054.el otama-20160404.1049.el outline-toc-20200401.1208.el outorg-20190720.2002.el pack-20191017.456.el package+-20191112.4.el package-filter-20170728.446.el package-safe-delete-20150116.1607.el panda-20200917.520.el parsebib-20200513.2352.el parse-csv-20160512.1723.el passmm-20181130.1612.el password-generator-20181229.1601.el password-vault-20160126.1820.el pc-bufsw-20201011.1918.el pepita-20200917.519.el persistent-scratch-20200921.2309.el persistent-soft-20150223.1853.el perspective-20200827.1945.el phabricator-20160510.1425.el phi-search-mc-20160324.1503.el pinboard-popular-20180511.1726.el plaster-20190622.818.el point-stack-20200427.107.el poly-ruby-20180905.929.el poporg-20170403.751.el prescient-20201017.1519.el prettier-js-20190311.1604.el prettify-greek-20160603.908.el projector-20190703.1418.el projekt-20150324.848.el prompt-text-20190408.311.el quilt-20190828.506.el racer-20191001.2344.el rainbow-identifiers-20141102.1526.el random-splash-image-20170316.350.el rcirc-groups-20170731.2101.el rc-mode-20160913.1918.el rdp-20120929.154.el read-aloud-20170730.1127.el redpen-paragraph-20200506.1558.el region-occurrences-highlighter-20200815.1608.el register-channel-20180926.2349.el replace-symbol-20160518.12.el replace-with-inflections-20180831.635.el restclient-20200901.1442.el restclient-helm-20200901.1442.el rfc-mode-20201005.809.el rivet-mode-20201013.1949.el rjsx-mode-20200224.2149.el ron-mode-20200830.1554.el rubik-20180222.2014.el rubocopfmt-20200713.1146.el ruby-electric-20200328.1528.el rufo-20191112.1609.el rum-mode-20191004.1119.el runtests-20150807.831.el rust-mode-20200709.723.el ryo-modal-20200907.647.el sailfish-scratchbox-20200228.817.el sass-mode-20190502.53.el sayid-20200902.708.el scheme-complete-20181029.1255.el scratch-20190314.614.el scratch-ext-20140104.516.el selected-20200528.606.el selectrum-prescient-20201017.1519.el sfz-mode-20200716.1023.el shadchen-20141102.1839.el shadowenv-20200617.1556.el sharper-20201014.335.el shell-split-string-20151224.1008.el shelltest-mode-20180501.141.el shx-20200905.1918.el simpleclip-20200211.1459.el simple-httpd-20191103.1446.el simple-rtm-20160222.1535.el slirm-20160201.1425.el slow-keys-20180831.459.el smblog-20200424.938.el smex-20151212.2209.el smiles-mode-20160717.1120.el smmry-20161024.2019.el soar-mode-20190513.1436.el solaire-mode-20201006.22.el soundcloud-20150502.326.el sourcetrail-20170411.57.el space-theming-20200502.1032.el spark-20160503.528.el sparkline-20150101.1319.el sprintly-mode-20121006.534.el sproto-mode-20151208.403.el sql-clickhouse-20191209.1443.el sql-impala-20181218.410.el sql-presto-20190113.1742.el sql-sqlline-20191102.2120.el steam-20190916.633.el string-utils-20140804.1922.el stripes-20200330.2022.el stylus-mode-20160525.1441.el svelte-mode-20201009.831.el swap-regions-20180915.1346.el sws-mode-20160525.1441.el sxiv-20200803.1431.el symbolword-mode-20201013.1049.el synonymous-20180325.1817.el syntactic-sugar-20140804.1922.el sysctl-20200615.1824.el ta-20160619.1645.el teletext-20201019.700.el teletext-yle-20201019.756.el tern-20200708.143.el tern-auto-complete-20200708.143.el tern-context-coloring-20170102.2253.el textmate-20110816.2146.el tfsmacs-20200917.518.el thrift-20201021.956.el tinysegmenter-20141124.1013.el tldr-20200330.1025.el todoist-20200517.1825.el todotxt-mode-20200228.952.el toggle-20200609.1811.el toml-20200901.1340.el tql-mode-20170724.254.el traad-20180730.48.el tramp-hdfs-20201001.2022.el trident-mode-20190410.2036.el truthy-20140804.1922.el try-20181204.236.el tt-mode-20130804.1110.el turkish-20170910.1511.el twtxt-20200902.19.el undercover-20200830.1638.el unicode-enbox-20140804.1922.el unicode-escape-20160620.1135.el unicode-fonts-20200803.1335.el unicode-troll-stopper-20190209.411.el unicode-whitespace-20140804.1922.el unipoint-20140113.2224.el urscript-mode-20190219.1604.el use-package-chords-20200805.1727.el use-package-ensure-system-package-20200805.1727.el utop-20200601.410.el uuid-20120910.851.el vale-mode-20190725.125.el validate-html-20200913.2002.el vcsh-20200226.1339.el vector-utils-20140804.1922.el viking-mode-20160705.2027.el vmd-mode-20200727.701.el walkman-20200418.1554.el wdl-mode-20180831.1946.el weak-ref-20200217.2200.el web-mode-20201009.1633.el wedge-ws-20140714.2149.el whois-20200715.1715.el wiki-nav-20200309.1323.el wiki-summary-20181010.1824.el wilt-20180220.854.el wispjs-mode-20170720.1919.el with-shell-interpreter-20200828.1217.el wn-mode-20151110.552.el wonderland-20130913.119.el wordgen-20170803.1820.el wttrin-20170614.1206.el x86-lookup-20180528.1635.el xah-css-mode-20200905.2218.el xah-elisp-mode-20201014.1717.el xah-find-20190314.2039.el xah-fly-keys-20201012.759.el xah-get-thing-20170821.1053.el xahk-mode-20170821.1107.el xah-lookup-20200420.1528.el xah-math-input-20200217.740.el xah-reformat-code-20200913.1702.el xah-replace-pairs-20180508.249.el xml-format-20191011.1159.el xml-rpc-20200907.104.el yaml-tomato-20151123.2111.el yankpad-20200409.1747.el ytel-20200725.1056.el zeal-at-point-20180131.2354.el znc-20160627.2032.el zoom-20200708.1105.el zpl-mode-20180906.1059.el ~/Programming/others/my-elpa/packages $=20