While trying to reconcile pixelwise frame sizing behaviors, I narrowed down two related issues.

clone-frame does not correctly clone frames on a pixelwise basis.

make-frame's text-pixels geometry support does not produce specified pixelwise geometry. This also impacts frameset-restore's ability to precisely reproduce pixelwise frame sizes.

I consider these to be related as clone-frame's use of make-frame could be using text-pixels but if that doesn't work then pixelwise cloning won't work. I did read through the code base as best as I could but could not find the source of the text-pixels issue.

The following reproducer, under -Q, shows the same results on 29.4 and 30.0.92. My main platform is NS and I also did some testing on GTK. GTK's issues seem a bit "messier" and I didn't spend any time trying to understand them in depth as I was more interested to know if GTK worked correctly or not, which it doesn't.

(switch-to-buffer "*Messages*")
(let ((target-text-width 1700)
      (target-text-height 1000)
      (native-width)
      (native-height)
      (msg (lambda (s frame)
             (message "%s text-width=%d (Δ%d) text-height=%d (Δ%d) native-width=%d (Δ%d) native-height %d (Δ%d)\n"
                      s
                      (frame-text-width frame) (- (frame-text-width frame) target-text-width)
                      (frame-text-height frame) (- (frame-text-height frame) target-text-height)
                      (frame-native-width frame) (- (frame-native-width frame) native-width)
                      (frame-native-height frame) (- (frame-native-height frame) native-height)))))
  (set-frame-position nil 0 0)
  (set-frame-size nil target-text-width target-text-height 'pixelwise)
  (setq native-width (frame-native-width)
        native-height (frame-native-height))
  (message "Targets: text-width=%d text-height=%d\n" target-text-width target-text-height)
  (funcall msg "orig" (selected-frame))

  (message "clone-frame under frame-resize-pixelwise nil; expectation: use lines/columns geometry; outcome: met")
  (let ((frame-resize-pixelwise nil))
    (let ((new-frame (clone-frame)))
      (funcall msg "new" new-frame)
      (delete-frame new-frame)))

  (message "clone-frame under frame-resize-pixelwise t; expectation: pixelwise geometry; outcome: unmet")
  (let ((frame-resize-pixelwise t))
    (let ((new-frame (clone-frame)))
      (funcall msg "new" new-frame)
      (delete-frame new-frame)))

  (message "clone-frame followed by manual resize; expectation: pixelwise geometry; outcome: met (but two steps)")
  (let ((new-frame (clone-frame)))
    (set-frame-size new-frame target-text-width target-text-height 'pixelwise)
    (funcall msg "new" new-frame)
    (delete-frame new-frame))

  (message "manual clone under frame-resize-pixelwise using text-pixels; expectation: pixelwise geometry; outcome: unmet")
  ;; code lifted from clone-frame
  ;; incorrect width offset seems to be equal to frame-scroll-bar-width
  (let* ((frame-resize-pixelwise t)
         (frame (selected-frame))
         (no-windows nil)
         (windows (unless no-windows
                    (window-state-get (frame-root-window frame))))
         (default-frame-alist
          (seq-remove (lambda (elem)
                        (memq (car elem) frame-internal-parameters))
                      (frame-parameters frame)))
         (new-frame))
    (when (and (display-graphic-p frame) frame-resize-pixelwise)
      (push (cons 'width (cons 'text-pixels (frame-text-width frame))) default-frame-alist)
      (push (cons 'height (cons 'text-pixels (frame-text-height frame))) default-frame-alist))
    (setq new-frame (make-frame))
    (when windows
      (window-state-put windows (frame-root-window new-frame) 'safe))
    (unless (display-graphic-p frame)
      (select-frame new-frame))
    (funcall msg "new" new-frame)
    (delete-frame new-frame)))

This is an implementation of clone-frame that uses text-pixels under make-frame. This depends on make-frame text-pixels being corrected. Happy to supply this as a patch should the discussion of these issues progress in that direction.

(defun clone-frame (&optional frame no-windows pixelwise)
  "Make a new frame with the same parameters and windows as FRAME.
With a prefix arg NO-WINDOWS, don't clone the window configuration.  When
PIXELWISE is non-nil or if `frame-resize-pixelwise' is non-nil, and frame
is not text-only, clone the originating frame's pixel size.

FRAME defaults to the selected frame.  The frame is created on the
same terminal as FRAME.  If the terminal is a text-only terminal then
also select the new frame."
  (interactive (list (selected-frame) current-prefix-arg))
  (let* ((frame (or frame (selected-frame)))
         (windows (unless no-windows
                    (window-state-get (frame-root-window frame))))
         (default-frame-alist
          (seq-remove (lambda (elem)
                        (memq (car elem) frame-internal-parameters))
                      (frame-parameters frame)))
         (new-frame))
    (when (and (display-graphic-p frame)
               (or pixelwise frame-resize-pixelwise))
      (push (cons 'width (cons 'text-pixels (frame-text-width frame)))
            default-frame-alist)
      (push (cons 'height (cons 'text-pixels (frame-text-height frame)))
            default-frame-alist))
    (setq new-frame (make-frame))
    (when windows
      (window-state-put windows (frame-root-window new-frame) 'safe))
    (unless (display-graphic-p frame)
      (select-frame new-frame))
    new-frame))

-Stephane