bug#35969: 26.2, Excorporate

["tenspd137 ." <dcday137@gmail.com>]

Thomas -

I was able to try stepping through an Emacs/proxy/Exchange test in an
emacs -Q session.  After setting the proxy and configuring the
debugger to step through url-http and url-http-async-sentilnel, the
only thing I noticed is that it appears url-http-async-sentinel is not
being called.  I also put the url-https-proxy-connect override you
gave me earlier into a file, loaded it and set the debugger to run
through that as well as set up proxies.  A broken down list of steps:

1.  Load file containing proxy and altered url-https-proxyconnect, set
debugger to run through it when hit.
2.  set up url-http and url-http-async-sentinel to be picked up by debugger
3.  eval (url-retrieve-synchronously
"https://outlook.office365.com/EWS/Exchange.asmx"), step through
url-http
4.  Input username and password when asked
5.  Continue stepping until end

url-http-async-sentinel is never called. " *http* ... -####" has text
indicating failure. url-https-proxy-connect is indeed called. I don't
know how to look at the actual <process>, if I try to C-x C-e  or M-:
"connection", it goes into the debugger.  The url's, etc look good as
far as I can tell.  Not sure what else I can do.  If there are certain
pieces of url-http you want me to look at, just let me know, but not
really knowing what has to happen under the hood, I am not going to be
able to do much else.

Thanks!

-C



On Tue, Jun 4, 2019 at 4:28 PM Thomas Fitzsimmons <fitzsim@fitzsim.org> wrote:
>
> "tenspd137 ." <dcday137@gmail.com> writes:
>
> > Oh - I see.  Because you want to look at the *HEADERS* flying around
> > in that case.  Understood.
>
> Right.
>
> > Quick question - using emacs -Q on my proxied machine
> >
> > (setq url-http-proxy "myproxy") doesn't seem to work, so I have been just doing:
> >
> > (setq url-proxy-services '(("http" . "myproxy")
> >                ("https" . "myproxy")))
> >
> > then, I evaluate:
> >
> > (defun url-https-proxy-connect (connection)
> >   (setq url-http-after-change-function 'url-https-proxy-after-change-function)
> >   (message "THIS WAS CALLED: url-https-proxy-connect")
> >   (process-send-string connection (format (concat "CONNECT %s:%d HTTP/1.1\r\n"
> >                                                   "Host: %s\r\n"
> >                                                   "\r\n")
> >                                           (url-host url-current-object)
> >                                           (or (url-port url-current-object)
> >                                               url-https-default-port)
> >                                           (url-host url-current-object))))
> >
> > which, if I understand correctly, adds the messaging to the orgiinal
> > url-https-proxy-connect.
>
> That's correct.
>
> > Then I evaluate
> >
> > (url-retrieve-synchronously "https://outlook.office365.com/EWS/Exchange.asmx")
> >
> > after sending username and password, THIS WAS CALLED does not appear
> > in the messages.  Am I using it correctly, or is this not being
> > called?  I have to ask, because at this point in my emacs usage, I
> > always bet first that I have done something wrong.
>
> I think you're doing everything correctly, so this suggests that Emacs
> isn't doing any proxy handling, or at least that it is not initiating
> the "CONNECT" protocol.
>
> From the wget output in your other email, it shows wget
> connecting to the proxy with CONNECT.  This protocol keeps the TLS
> "tunnel" through the proxy open, and as far as I know, is required for
> Exchange authentication to work through a proxy.
>
> Then the logs also show:
>
> Connection: Keep-Alive
> Proxy-Connection: Keep-Alive
>
> which are important; even when you set Connection keep-alive, Emacs was
> still sending both Connection close and Connection keep-alive which is
> probably not valid.
>
> You may have reached the limit of what Emacs can currently do for
> proxies, but it's up to someone (maybe me) to eventually implement
> CONNECT properly if it isn't already.
>
> A next step would be to repeat your Emacs/proxy/Exchange experiments
> until you get url-https-proxy-connect to be called or figure out why it
> isn't being called.
>
> The only two callers are url-http and url-http-async-sentinel.  To step
> through them with edebug do:
>
> C-h f url-http RET C-x o TAB RET C-u C-M-x
>
> Likewise for url-http-async-sentinel, then redo your experiment and step
> through the functions with SPC and eval stuff with C-x e to see where
> they go off the rails before calling url-https-proxy-connect.
>
> > Still looking into wget verbosity....
>
> I saw the other email, nice; is that output just with the -d option?
>
> BTW, it seems like Emacs is supposed to read the _proxy environment
> variables the way wget does.  Have you tried running emacs -Q in an
> environment that has http_proxy and https_proxy set, and then not
> setting any of the Emacs proxy variables and doing the Exchange
> authentication experiment?
>
> Thanks,
> Thomas