If two windows show a single buffer, then the region highlighting is strange in the non-selected window. It is not hard to reproduce, 1. emacs -Q 2. Visit a longish file. 3. C-x 3 and scroll up in any of the window. 4. M-: (setq highlight-nonselected-windows t) RET. 5. Create an active region and compare the highlighting. I'm attaching a screenshot to demonstrate the issue in case the reproducer wasn't clear.